Insurance Costs: Florida Vs California, Who's Higher?

Florida and California have different car insurance laws and companies, resulting in varying costs and requirements. Florida is a no-fault state, requiring drivers to have personal injury protection (PIP) insurance, which can be expensive. California, on the other hand, is a tort state, requiring bodily injury liability coverage. California has a higher number of vehicle thefts and a higher cost of living than Florida, but Florida's insurance rates are higher, ranking among the top five most expensive states. California's insurance premiums have been increasing, with a 15% increase from 2022 to 2023, making it one of the three most expensive states for full coverage.

Florida's insurance requirements

Florida has some unique insurance requirements, particularly regarding auto insurance. Florida is a no-fault state, meaning that each person pays for their own accident expenses, regardless of who is at fault. This is reflected in the state's mandatory insurance requirements, which include personal injury protection (PIP) and property damage liability (PDL) insurance. PIP covers medical expenses and other costs, such as lost wages, up to a certain limit, while PDL covers damage to another person's property. Florida law requires a minimum of $10,000 in both PIP and PDL coverage for standard four-wheeled vehicles.

It is important to note that Florida does not require bodily injury liability (BIL) insurance, which covers injuries sustained by others in an accident. However, experts recommend adding this coverage as injured parties can still sue for damages if their injuries or damages exceed what the minimum insurance requirements cover. Additionally, Florida has higher insurance rates than most states, with the average cost of minimum coverage being $1,123 per year. This is due to various factors, including busy roadways, harsh weather conditions, and a high rate of uninsured drivers.

Florida also has specific insurance requirements for motorcycles. While property damage liability insurance is generally not required for motorcycle operators, they may need to obtain it if they have a history of traffic violations or failing to pay for damages. PIP coverage is mandatory for all motor vehicles registered in Florida, but it does not cover injuries sustained in a motorcycle accident. Some insurance companies offer PIP and medical payment insurance for motorcycles as additional coverage. Motorcycle riders in Florida are also required to have at least $10,000 in medical benefits coverage if they wish to ride without headgear.

In addition to auto insurance, Florida residents may also want to consider comprehensive insurance, which covers losses from incidents other than collisions, such as fire, theft, windstorm, vandalism, flood, or hitting an animal. While not mandatory, comprehensive insurance can provide valuable protection for Floridians, especially considering the state's susceptibility to hurricanes and flooding. Uninsured motorist (UM) insurance is another option, which covers the policyholder and their passengers if they are hit by an uninsured or underinsured driver.

California's insurance requirements

California has different insurance requirements compared to Florida. California is a tort state, meaning that drivers at fault are responsible for third-party damages, medical expenses, and other liabilities. California requires drivers to have a minimum of property damage liability and bodily injury liability coverage. The precise cost of insurance depends on the driver's coverage, driving history, and chosen insurance company.

In 2022, Governor Gavin Newsom signed the Protect California Drivers Act, which increased the minimum auto liability limits. The new law impacts younger drivers and low-income drivers the most, as they tend to purchase minimum liability insurance. The previous minimum liability limits were not enough to cover most claims due to the rising costs of repairs and medical expenses.

California requires drivers to carry evidence of insurance in their vehicles at all times. This can be in the form of a California Insurance Proof Certificate (SR 22/SR 1P), a DMV authorization letter, or a California Proof of Insurance Certificate (SR 22) form for broad coverage. If a driver is involved in a collision resulting in $1,000 or more in damage, or anyone is injured or killed, they must report the collision to the DMV within 10 days. Failure to have proper insurance coverage can result in a suspension of driving privileges for up to four years.

Insurance companies in California are required by law to electronically report private-use vehicle information. If the DMV does not receive proof of insurance for a vehicle, its registration will be suspended, and it may not be operated or parked on public roadways. California also offers a Low-Cost Automobile Insurance Program for those who cannot afford liability insurance.

Florida's insurance costs

There are several reasons why Florida's insurance costs are so high. One major factor is that Florida is a no-fault state, which means that drivers are required to have personal injury protection (PIP) insurance. This type of insurance can be expensive and is not required in many other states, including California. Florida also has a high number of uninsured drivers, with more than 20% of drivers on the road lacking insurance. This is one of the highest rates in the country and can drive up the cost of insurance for other drivers.

Additionally, Florida faces unique challenges such as flood or hurricane damage, which can increase the cost of insurance. The state also has busy roadways and harsh weather conditions, which can lead to higher rates of accidents and damage. Florida's insurance market is challenging and expensive for insurance companies to operate in, which makes finding affordable policies difficult for consumers.

The cost of insurance in Florida can vary depending on the city and even the specific ZIP code within that city. For example, Gainesville has the cheapest state minimum insurance in Florida, with an average cost of $693 per year, while Hialeah is the most expensive city, with an average cost of $1,461 per year.

It's worth noting that California also has high insurance costs, with an average annual cost of $2,416. However, this is still lower than Florida's average. California's high costs can be attributed to factors such as its high cost of living, congested urban areas, and legislative and regulatory environment.

California's insurance costs

California has a higher number of vehicle thefts and a much higher overall cost of living than Florida. However, Florida is a no-fault state, meaning that its insurance policies are generally more expensive than California's. Florida also requires personal injury protection (PIP) insurance, which can be expensive. Florida's car insurance rates are higher than those of California and most other states.

The average cost of car insurance in California is $2,935 per year for full coverage and $844 per year for minimum coverage. The cheapest car insurance company in California is Progressive, with policies averaging $481 annually. California is an expensive place to buy insurance, with full coverage costing $237 more per year than the national average.

Several factors influence the cost of car insurance in California. For example, drivers in densely populated areas tend to pay higher rates. Drivers in Los Angeles pay 36% more than the state average for full coverage, while the average cost in San Francisco is 13% more than the state average. Urban customers may pay more than rural customers due to the increased likelihood of accidents in dense traffic. California parents adding a 16-year-old driver to their full-coverage policy can expect an average premium of $6,885 per year. Drivers with a DUI on their license pay an average of $7,315 annually, 149% more than the state average.

Insurers base their premiums on insurance company rates filed with and approved by the California Department of Insurance. These rates include discounts for some risks and additional charges for others. For example, an insurance company's rate for automobile insurance might include a discount for multiple policies with the insurer and an extra charge for insuring a sports car.

California offers two main types of financial assistance for health insurance costs: premium assistance and cost-sharing subsidies. Premium assistance is a tax credit that reduces an individual's monthly premium cost. Cost-sharing reductions lower an individual's out-of-pocket expenses, such as copays, coinsurance, deductibles, and out-of-pocket maximums.

Insurance companies in Florida and California

When it comes to insurance companies in Florida and California, there are a few key differences to note, especially in terms of car insurance. Florida is a no-fault state, which means that car insurance costs tend to be higher than in California, a tort state. In a no-fault state, drivers are required to carry personal injury protection, which can drive up the cost of insurance. Florida also has a higher minimum coverage level for property damage liability than California. As a result, the average cost of car insurance in Florida is $1,123 per year, compared to $665 per year in California. However, it's important to note that insurance rates can vary significantly within each state, depending on factors such as the city and specific insurance company. For example, in Florida, GEICO is the cheapest option, with an average annual cost of $590, while in California, Progressive offers the lowest rates at $481 per year.

In terms of specific insurance companies, eligible military members in Florida can get a discounted rate from USAA, with an average annual cost of $406. In California, Travelers is known for providing reliable insurance coverage, offering several discounts, including for new homebuyers and those with smart home technologies. Chubb's Masterpiece plan is another option in California, which includes extended replacement cost and water backup coverage.

When it comes to homeowners insurance, in Florida, companies such as Tower Hill offer policies that include flood insurance, which is especially important in areas prone to storms. Meanwhile, in California, the average cost of homeowners insurance is about $1,435 per year, which is lower than the national average. However, in wildfire-prone areas, rates are expected to increase, and earthquake coverage typically requires a separate policy. Mercury Insurance is a Los Angeles-based company that offers competitive rates by providing fewer endorsements than larger competitors.

Overall, when comparing insurance companies in Florida and California, it's important to consider the specific type of insurance, as well as the unique circumstances and requirements of each state. Additionally, insurance rates can vary significantly within each state, so it's always a good idea to shop around and get quotes from multiple companies to find the best rate for your needs.

Frequently asked questions