Insurance Fraud: P&C Vs Life And Health

Insurance fraud is a deliberate deception perpetrated against or by an insurance company or agent for financial gain. It can be committed by applicants, policyholders, third-party claimants, or professionals who provide services to claimants. Insurance agents and company employees may also commit insurance fraud.

The types of insurance that are most affected by fraud are healthcare, workers' compensation, and auto. The cost of insurance fraud is estimated to be between $80 billion to $100 billion annually across all lines of insurance. The Coalition Against Insurance Fraud estimates that U.S. insurers lose $80 billion annually to fraud across all lines of business.

Property and casualty (P&C) insurance covers damages to property or a business. This includes auto insurance, home insurance, commercial insurance, and marine insurance. Life insurance, on the other hand, covers the risk of the death of a policyholder and lasts for decades.

While there is fraud in both P&C and life insurance, it is difficult to say which has a bigger problem with fraud. However, given the broader range of P&C insurance types and the higher estimated cost of fraud in this sector, it can be argued that P&C insurance has a bigger problem with fraud.

The cost of insurance fraud in the US is estimated to be more than $40 billion per year

Insurance fraud takes many forms and can be committed by applicants, policyholders, third-party claimants, or professionals who provide services to claimants. It can also be committed by insurance agents and company employees. Common types of fraud include "padding" (inflating claims), misrepresenting facts on an insurance application, submitting claims for injuries or damage that never occurred, and staging accidents. Fraudulent activities are carried out by organised criminals, professionals such as doctors and lawyers, and ordinary people looking to make a bit of money.

Healthcare, workers' compensation, and auto insurance are generally considered the most affected sectors. Auto insurance fraud alone costs insurers at least $29 billion a year, according to a 2017 study by Verisk. This includes practices such as unrecognized drivers, underestimated mileage, violations/accidents, and false garaging to lower premiums. Healthcare fraud affects all types of property/casualty insurance coverage that include a medical care component, and the National Health Care Anti-Fraud Association (NHCAA) estimates that the financial losses due to healthcare fraud are $68 billion, or as high as $300 billion.

The true cost of insurance fraud is not just financial. It stifles innovation, affects consumers, and requires resources to establish fraud prevention and detection units. Insurance fraud is a complex and evolving issue, and technology plays a crucial role in detecting and preventing it. Data technologies can help cut the time needed to recognise fraud, and advances in analytical technology are crucial in keeping pace with sophisticated fraud rings that constantly develop new scams.

The Coalition Against Insurance Fraud estimates that US insurers lose $80 billion annually to fraud

Insurance fraud is a significant issue in the United States, with the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud (CAIF) estimating that US insurers lose around $80 billion annually due to fraudulent activities. This figure has increased substantially over time, with the CAIF's previous estimate from 1995 placing the loss at $80 billion, which, when adjusted for inflation, would be approximately $160 billion in today's dollars. The rise in insurance fraud can be attributed to various factors, including the internet, which has facilitated new tactics and provided fraudsters with new advantages when filing false claims.

The $80 billion loss estimated by CAIF represents a significant cost to both the insurance industry and American consumers. The insurance industry consists of over 7,000 companies that collect more than $1 trillion in premiums each year. Insurance fraud increases the cost of insurance for consumers, with the FBI estimating that the average family pays an additional $400 to $700 per year in premiums due to fraud. This additional cost highlights the financial burden that insurance fraud places on families, contributing to the overall economic impact of the issue.

The $80 billion estimate by CAIF may even be conservative, as some insurance companies may not realize they have been defrauded due to the sophisticated methods employed by fraudsters. The true extent of insurance fraud may be larger than what is currently estimated, indicating an even greater challenge for the industry and policymakers.

Furthermore, insurance fraud has a diverse range of forms and affects multiple industries. For example, Medicare fraud is estimated to cost $60 billion annually, impacting the federal government and taxpayers. Additionally, there is Workers' Compensation Fraud, where entities purport to provide workers' compensation insurance at a reduced cost but instead misappropriate premium funds without providing insurance. This type of fraud results in significant losses for businesses and individuals who are left without the necessary coverage.

The impact of insurance fraud extends beyond financial losses, as it can also lead to increased premiums and reduced trust in the insurance industry. Consumers are justifiably concerned about insurance fraud, with 78% expressing worry about this issue. Insurance fraud not only affects the financial stability of individuals and families but also undermines the very purpose of insurance, which is to provide protection and peace of mind during unforeseen events.

The Coalition Against Insurance Fraud's 2016 study found that nearly three-quarters of insurers were deemed to be fully engaged in using anti-fraud technology

Insurance fraud is a significant issue, with the non-health insurance fraud costing more than $40 billion per year, and the average US family pays between $400 and $700 per year in increased premiums as a result. The Coalition Against Insurance Fraud (CAIF) is a US organisation founded in 1993 by 17 groups representing government, business, and consumer interests. The coalition has since expanded to include over 250 member organisations. CAIF's primary goal is to combat insurance fraud through government affairs, public education, events, and research. They also provide resources for consumers, including scam alerts, information on where to report fraud, and advice on protecting themselves.

The 2016 CAIF study found that nearly three-quarters of insurers were actively employing anti-fraud technology. This technology is a crucial tool in the fight against insurance fraud, which has become an increasingly prevalent issue. Insurance fraud can take many forms, including premium diversion, fee churning, and asset diversion. Premium diversion, the most common type of insurance fraud, involves an insurance agent embezzling premiums for personal use or selling insurance without a license and then failing to pay claims. Fee churning involves a series of intermediaries taking commissions through reinsurance agreements, gradually reducing the premium until there is insufficient money to pay claims. Asset diversion, on the other hand, occurs during the acquisition or merger of an insurance company, where the subject uses the acquired company's assets to pay off debt, ultimately diverting the remaining assets for personal gain.

In addition to these schemes, disaster-related fraud, such as that seen in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, can also be significant. This can involve false or exaggerated claims, misclassification of damage, claims from individuals outside the disaster zone, bid-rigging by contractors, and charity fraud. The cost of insurance fraud is substantial, and the efforts of organisations like CAIF and the use of anti-fraud technology by insurers are essential steps in combating this issue.

The FBI reports that the size of the insurance industry makes it an attractive target for criminals

The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) reports that the insurance industry is an attractive target for criminals due to its size. The industry consists of more than 7,000 companies that collect over $1 trillion in premiums each year. This provides more opportunities and bigger incentives for committing illegal activities. The total cost of insurance fraud (non-health insurance) is estimated to be more than $40 billion per year, costing the average U.S. family between $400 and $700 per year in increased premiums.

Insurance fraud is a deliberate deception perpetrated against or by an insurance company or agent for financial gain. It can be committed by applicants, policyholders, third-party claimants, or professionals who provide services to claimants. Common frauds include "padding" (inflating claims), misrepresenting facts on an insurance application, submitting claims for injuries or damage that never occurred, and staging accidents.

Organized criminals, professionals, and ordinary people are all capable of committing insurance fraud. Organized criminals may steal large sums through fraudulent business activities, while professionals such as medical providers and technicians may inflate service costs or charge for services not rendered. Ordinary people may commit fraud to cover their deductible or view filing a claim as an opportunity to make money.

Healthcare, workers' compensation, and auto insurance are generally considered the most affected sectors by fraud. The cost of insurance fraud is significant, with estimates ranging from tens to hundreds of billions of dollars annually. The Coalition Against Insurance Fraud estimates that U.S. insurers lose $80 billion annually to fraud across all lines of business. The true cost of fraud is not quantifiable as it extends beyond payment of inappropriate claims and includes costs associated with fraud prevention and detection.

The FBI highlights the impact of natural disasters, such as Hurricane Katrina, which caused approximately $100 billion in economic damages and led to approximately 1.6 million insurance claims totaling $34.4 billion in insured losses. Insurance Fraud may have accounted for as much as $6 billion of the $80 billion in government funding appropriated for reconstruction.

To combat insurance fraud, insurers have established special investigation units (SIUs) and invested in training and technology. State governments have also enacted specific insurance fraud statutes and established anti-fraud units to investigate and prosecute insurance fraud. However, despite these efforts, insurance fraud remains a significant issue, and it is clear that more needs to be done to address this problem effectively.

The National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) was created to combat fraud relating to natural and man-made disasters

The National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) is a non-profit organisation that was created to combat insurance fraud and theft. It does this by partnering with insurance companies, consumers, and law enforcement agencies. The NICB has been in existence for over 110 years and has unmatched data and technology, enabling it to be proactive in the fight against insurance fraud.

The NICB provides fraud resources, education, and investigative assistance to law enforcement organisations, public agencies, and prosecutors to detect, deter, and stop insurance crimes. They also offer curriculum and advanced intelligence training academies to law enforcement officers, investigators, and intelligence analysts to learn about trends and tools to fight insurance crime.

In addition to its work with law enforcement, the NICB also informs and educates the public about insurance fraud and crime through national and local media interviews, social media campaigns, public service announcements, infographics, and other digital assets. The NICB is recognised as the go-to resource for information on insurance crime.

The NICB has a proud legacy of fighting vehicle crimes and brings specialised experience, knowledge, and unique datasets to this area. They also track medical fraud trends and crimes, including fraudulent billing by medical professionals and prescription drug rings. The NICB also works to identify, prevent, and investigate workers' compensation fraud, which is a growing problem impacting the insurance industry.

When disasters strike, the NICB is actively involved in the post-disaster response, helping to identify, prevent, and investigate contractor fraud. They have issued alerts and warnings to residents to avoid being victimised by dishonest contractors in the wake of hurricanes and other natural catastrophes. The NICB also assists in the aftermath of disasters by coordinating intelligence sharing, response support, and community outreach.

Frequently asked questions