Insurance Costs: Miata Vs Mustang — Which Costs More?

The cost of car insurance is a crucial consideration when purchasing a new vehicle. The Mazda MX-5 Miata and the Ford Mustang are both popular sports cars, but their insurance costs can vary significantly. Several factors influence the insurance rates for these cars, including the driver's age, gender, location, driving record, and the specific model of the car. In this discussion, we will delve into the insurance costs associated with the Miata and the Mustang, examining various scenarios and factors that can impact the overall expense.

The Mazda MX-5 Miata is $384 cheaper to insure than the Ford Mustang annually

When it comes to insurance, the make and model of your car can have a significant impact on your premiums. Two popular sports car choices, the Mazda MX-5 Miata and the Ford Mustang, offer a stark contrast in insurance costs. The Mazda MX-5 Miata is $384 cheaper to insure than the Ford Mustang annually, making it an attractive option for those conscious of their wallet.

The Mazda MX-5 Miata, known for its sleek design and agile handling, offers a fun driving experience without breaking the bank on insurance. With an average insurance rate of $2,062 per year, or approximately $172 per month, the Miata is a cost-effective choice for sports car enthusiasts. The cheapest model to insure is the Sport Convertible, with an estimated annual cost of $1,930. On the other hand, the priciest model is the RF Club Coupe, which will set you back about $2,172 per year.

Comparatively, the Ford Mustang, an iconic muscle car, commands a higher insurance premium. While the specific cost will depend on various factors, including the driver's age, gender, and driving record, it is generally more expensive to insure than the Miata. For instance, a 20-year-old male can expect to pay around $4,094 per year, while his female counterpart will pay approximately $2,954, a substantial difference of $1,140. By age 50, the gap narrows, with men paying $1,824 and women $1,782, a difference of only $42.

The disparity in insurance costs between the Miata and the Mustang can be attributed to several factors. Firstly, the Mustang's powerful engine and performance capabilities may contribute to higher premiums. Insurance companies often view high-performance vehicles as riskier to insure due to their potential for speeding and involvement in accidents. Secondly, the cost of repairs and replacement parts for the Mustang could be higher than those for the Miata, influencing the insurance rates.

Additionally, the safety features and security of the vehicle play a role in insurance pricing. The Mustang's advanced safety technologies, such as ABS, can help mitigate the impact of accidents, potentially reducing insurance costs. On the other hand, if the Mustang is considered a target for theft or vandalism, insurance rates may increase to account for the added risk. It's worth noting that insurance companies have different methods for classifying vehicles, and some may place the Mustang in the same category as the Miata, resulting in similar insurance rates.

In conclusion, while the Mazda MX-5 Miata is $384 cheaper to insure than the Ford Mustang annually, the final insurance cost will depend on various factors specific to the driver and the insurance company's assessment. It's always a good idea to shop around and compare quotes from multiple insurance providers to find the best rate for your desired vehicle.

The age and gender of the driver can affect the insurance cost of a Miata

The age and gender of the driver can significantly impact the insurance cost of a Mazda MX-5 Miata. Generally, younger drivers are considered higher-risk due to their inexperience and higher accident rates, resulting in higher insurance premiums. For instance, a 20-year-old male driver of a 2024 Mazda Miata can expect to pay an average of $4,094 per year, while a 20-year-old female driver will pay approximately $2,954 annually, a difference of $1,140. However, by age 50, the gender disparity narrows, with men paying around $1,824 and women paying $1,782, a difference of only $42.

The cost of insuring a Miata decreases as the driver's age increases, with the cheapest age for insurance being 60 years old. This is because older drivers are typically considered lower-risk and may benefit from discounts offered by insurance companies. Additionally, the Miata's safety ratings, performance, and theft rates can influence its insurance cost.

It is worth noting that insurance rates are highly personalized and can vary depending on other factors such as driving record, location, coverage, vehicle features, and deductible amount. Comparing quotes from multiple insurance providers can help Miata owners find the most competitive rates.

While age is a significant rating factor in most states, some states, such as Hawaii and Massachusetts, do not permit its use. Similarly, certain states, including California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Michigan, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania, prohibit the use of gender as a rating factor, resulting in equal rates for men and women if all other factors are identical.

The insurance cost of a Mustang can depend on the driver's age and driving record

The insurance cost of a Mustang can vary significantly depending on the driver's age and driving record. For instance, a 16-year-old driver can expect to pay around $6,766 annually for full coverage, whereas a 40-year-old driver with a clean driving record may pay approximately $1,546 or even as low as $1,201 with USAA. The cost of insurance for a Mustang is influenced by various factors, including the driver's age, location, driving history, and the chosen coverage level.

Age plays a crucial role in determining insurance rates, with younger drivers often facing significantly higher premiums than their older counterparts. This is due to the increased risk associated with less experienced drivers. For example, a 20-year-old male driver can expect to pay around $4,094 per year for a Mustang, while a 20-year-old female driver may pay approximately $2,954, demonstrating a substantial gender disparity in insurance costs at younger ages.

Driving history is another critical factor that insurance companies consider when calculating premiums. A driver with a clean driving record and no accidents or violations will typically be offered more favourable rates than someone with a history of speeding tickets or accidents. For instance, a 35-year-old driver with a speeding ticket from six years ago reported paying $125 per month for insurance on their Mustang, while a 29-year-old driver in a small town with no tickets or accidents pays around $95 per month for full coverage.

The chosen coverage level also impacts the cost of insurance for a Mustang. Full coverage insurance for a Mustang can range from $1,201 to $6,766 per year, depending on various factors, including age and driving history. Minimum coverage, on the other hand, can be significantly more affordable, with rates as low as $47 per month or $565 annually for a 40-year-old driver with a clean record.

Additionally, location plays a role in determining Mustang insurance rates. Insurance premiums can vary from state to state, with certain states, such as Michigan, mandating higher coverage levels, resulting in more expensive rates. California, Hawaii, and Massachusetts are exceptions, as they do not allow providers to adjust rates based on credit history.

The insurance company's classification of the Mustang can impact the insurance rate

The Ford Mustang is a classic American sports car with a powerful engine and a large frame. Insurers tend to associate sports cars with risky behaviour and higher performance, which can lead to increased insurance costs. The Mustang's classification as a sports car can therefore impact the insurance rate, with insurance companies typically considering sports cars to be higher risk.

The Mustang's safety features, such as rearview cameras, lane-keeping systems, and blind-spot information systems, can help to mitigate this. These features are designed to keep drivers safe and reduce the risk of accidents, which may lead to lower premium rates. However, the advanced technology used in these safety features can be costly to repair if damaged, which may counteract any savings.

The Mustang's classification as a high-performance vehicle can also influence its insurance rate. The Mustang has a 0-60 mph speed of 0 seconds and horsepower levels between 480 and 500, which contributes to its classification as a high-performance car. Insurers may associate high performance with risky driving behaviour, resulting in higher insurance costs.

Additionally, the Mustang's size and trim level can impact its insurance classification. As a larger vehicle, the Mustang may cost more to insure compared to smaller Ford models. Higher trim levels with premium upgrades, such as leather interiors and advanced sound systems, also contribute to a higher MSRP, leading to increased insurance costs.

It's important to note that insurance rates for the Mustang can vary significantly depending on individual factors such as age, driving history, location, and chosen coverage level. While the Mustang's classification as a sports car and high-performance vehicle can impact its insurance rate, shopping around and comparing quotes from different insurers can help owners find the most competitive rates.

The cost of the car and the driver's credit score can also affect insurance rates

The cost of the car is a significant factor in determining insurance rates. Insurers will look at past claims from similar models and evaluate repair costs, theft rates, and comprehensive claim payments. They will also consider the safety of the vehicle, how well it protects its occupants, and the potential damage it can inflict on another car. Therefore, if a specific vehicle model has a higher chance of inflicting damage in an accident, the insurer may charge more for liability insurance.

The type of car is also important. For example, sports cars tend to have higher insurance rates than other types of vehicles. This is reflected in the insurance rates for a Mazda Miata and a Ford Mustang. According to one source, insurance for a Mazda Miata costs $384 less per year than the Ford Mustang.

In addition to the cost and type of car, the driver's credit score can also impact insurance rates. A higher credit score generally leads to lower insurance rates, as insurance companies believe that drivers with poor credit are more likely to file claims. A poor credit score can increase insurance rates by more than $400 per month, depending on the company. However, it is important to note that some states, such as California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Michigan, ban companies from using credit scores to determine insurance rates.

The driver's age and gender also play a role in insurance rates. Younger drivers, especially those below 25, tend to have higher insurance rates due to their lack of experience and higher accident risk. Additionally, male drivers often pay more than female drivers, as statistics show that women tend to have fewer and less severe accidents.

Lastly, the location of the driver can affect insurance rates. Urban drivers tend to pay more for insurance due to higher rates of theft, vandalism, and accidents. The cost of medical care, car repair, and litigation frequency in a particular area can also impact insurance prices.

Frequently asked questions