Diesel Truck Insurance: Is It More Expensive?

The cost of insuring a diesel truck depends on a variety of factors, including the make and model, the age and condition of the vehicle, and the intended use. Trucks are generally more affordable to insure than cars, with lower annual insurance premiums on average. However, high-value trucks with powerful engines, advanced technology, and high price tags can be more expensive to insure due to potentially pricier repairs and replacements. Diesel trucks, known for their longevity and fuel efficiency, may have higher resale values, impacting insurance costs. Personal and commercial use also determine insurance requirements, with commercial insurance typically featuring higher claim amounts and addressing more complex legal issues.

Characteristics and values of insurance on a diesel truck

Truck insurance costs vary by state

The cost of insuring a truck varies based on several factors, including the type of truck, its features, and whether it is new or used. Diesel trucks, for example, are known for their longevity, higher resale value, and fuel efficiency. These factors can influence insurance costs, with newer trucks with more advanced features and higher price tags often having higher insurance premiums due to potentially pricier repairs.

When it comes to insurance costs, trucks are generally more affordable to insure than cars. In 2023, the national average for truck insurance premiums was $2,160 annually, compared to $2,790 for cars. This cost advantage is attributed to factors such as the standard parts used in trucks, which are typically cheaper to repair or replace than those in sedans. Trucks also benefit from their size and frame, which provide better safety in crashes.

However, it is important to note that insurance costs can vary significantly, especially when comparing different states. Commercial truck insurance rates can be influenced by various factors specific to each state, such as local regulations, road conditions, accident statistics, and population density. For example, states with riskier roads may have stricter insurance requirements, leading to potentially higher rates. Similarly, higher population density and increased traffic congestion can increase the risk of accidents, resulting in higher insurance premiums for carriers in those states.

The income of truck drivers can also be influenced by the state they operate in. Nebraska, for instance, has the highest-paid truckers, with an average income of $90,000, and it also boasts the sixth-lowest commercial truck insurance rates, making it a favourable state for owner-operators. Mississippi is another state with low insurance rates, with average local premium rates significantly lower than those in neighbouring Alabama.

Overall, the cost of insuring a truck depends on a multitude of factors, and the specific state in which the truck is operated can have a significant impact on insurance rates. Understanding these variations can help truck owners make informed decisions and even influence their choice of state to operate in, as some owners choose to relocate to take advantage of lower insurance rates.

Diesel trucks are more fuel-efficient

While diesel trucks are generally more expensive than gasoline trucks, diesel engines are much more fuel-efficient. Diesel engines are built sturdily to handle the high compression forces of the diesel engine cycle, and diesel fuel acts as a natural lubricant, resulting in astonishing engine longevity. Diesel engines can achieve 200,000 miles before requiring major repairs—twice the mileage of gas engines, which may require more frequent work after 100,000 miles.

Diesel engines are a popular option for heavy-duty trucks due to their high torque output and better fuel economy. In a test of 22 heavy-duty pickups, diesel trucks averaged 20% better fuel economy than gas-fed trucks, with diesel models averaging 18 miles per gallon (mpg) and gas-fed models averaging 15 mpg. This difference in fuel efficiency is due to the differences in how the engine burns fuel and the properties of the fuel itself. Diesel engines spin at a slower rate than gas engines, which prevents faster fuel burn. Diesel fuel is also more energy-dense than gasoline, providing more energy per gallon.

The higher fuel efficiency of diesel trucks is particularly noticeable during long-distance driving. While diesel trucks may not be ideal in stop-and-start traffic, they can outperform gas vehicles over long distances. For example, a diesel-powered car can typically achieve 50 mpg or higher, and some diesel trucks can achieve nearly 60 mpg. This fuel efficiency can result in significant fuel savings over time, even if diesel fuel is generally more expensive.

The fuel efficiency of diesel trucks also contributes to their higher resale value compared to gas-powered vehicles. Diesel engines are known for their longevity, with many engines lasting beyond the 1,000,000-mile mark. This resilience is due to features like cylinder liners, which can be replaced individually instead of requiring a new engine. As a result, used diesel trucks may have lower insurance costs due to their lower total price, making them a cost-effective option for those seeking a fuel-efficient vehicle.

Trucks are generally cheaper to insure than cars

While it may be surprising, trucks are generally cheaper to insure than cars. In 2023, the national average for truck insurance premiums was $2,160 annually, while car insurance averaged $2,790, resulting in a 23% saving for truck owners. This is due to several factors that make trucks less expensive to insure than cars. Firstly, trucks are often safer for occupants in the event of a crash due to their larger frames and better impact absorption, resulting in cheaper premiums. Their higher safety ratings also contribute to lower insurance costs.

Additionally, trucks are a staple in rural, ranching, and farming communities, where their larger back areas and towing capabilities are essential. In these communities, there is a lower risk of accidents and fewer traffic incidents, which brings premium costs down. Standard truck models are also designed with durability, towing, and hauling in mind, and often lack the advanced technology and automatic features of modern sedans. As a result, repairs or part replacements are typically more affordable, making insurance premiums more competitive.

Furthermore, trucks are made of sheet metal or aluminum, which are more affordable materials to replace or repair compared to the parts used in some cars. While trucks may be more expensive upfront, with the cheapest pickup truck, the Nissan Frontier, priced at $18,990, their higher resale value and fuel efficiency can offset this initial cost over time. For example, diesel trucks are known for their longevity, often surpassing 1,000,000 miles, and their fuel efficiency, achieving up to the low-to-mid 30s for highway mpg.

However, it is important to note that insurance costs can vary based on the make and model of the truck, with larger and more expensive trucks, such as the Ford F-450, commanding higher insurance premiums due to their advanced features and potentially pricier repairs. Despite this, trucks from certain manufacturers, such as Hyundai, Honda, and Toyota, are known for having more affordable insurance rates. Ultimately, while trucks may be more costly to purchase initially, their insurance premiums can be more competitive than those of cars, making them a financially viable option for some buyers.

Commercial truck insurance is more expensive

The type of truck is a significant factor in determining insurance costs. Trucks with high-end features, such as powerful engines, advanced technology, and high towing capabilities, tend to be more expensive to insure due to potentially pricier repairs and replacements. The age and condition of the truck also play a role, with older or poorly maintained trucks often considered higher-risk by insurance companies. Brand new vehicles can also have higher insurance premiums because of their higher value and repair costs.

The cargo being hauled impacts insurance rates, with hazardous, flammable, or high-value cargo resulting in higher premiums due to increased risk of theft, damage, or accidents. The driver's age, experience, and driving record are other critical factors. Inexperienced or younger drivers tend to face higher rates, and a history of traffic violations or accidents will lead to increased premiums.

Additionally, the operating radius and routes taken can affect insurance costs. Carriers operating in areas with high population density, higher crime rates, or frequent inclement weather may experience higher insurance rates. The size of the fleet also matters, as larger fleets tend to pay less on a cost-per-mile basis, while increasing fleet size leads to higher overall premiums.

Commercial truck insurance costs have been steadily rising, with the American Trucking Research Institute reporting that the average cost-per-mile for operating a truck exceeded $2,000 in 2022. As a result, trucking companies are facing challenges due to increasing operating costs.

Used diesel trucks are cheaper to insure

While diesel trucks are growing in popularity due to their performance, capabilities, and efficiency, new diesel trucks may be more expensive to insure than new gas trucks. However, this is not the case for used models. The total price of a used diesel truck is lower, and insurance companies will take this into account when calculating premiums.

In addition, trucks are generally more affordable to insure than cars. In 2023, the national average for truck insurance premiums was $2,160 annually, while car insurance averaged $2,790, resulting in a 23% savings for truck owners. This is due to several factors, including the larger frame of trucks, which absorbs crash impact better than cars, leading to cheaper premiums. Trucks also have a lower risk of accidents, especially in rural areas, which brings down premium costs.

Furthermore, many trucks have standard parts that are less expensive to repair than sedans. Trucks traditionally made for durability, towing, and hauling often lack the same technology and automatic features as sedans, making them more affordable to insure. Diesel trucks, in particular, are known for their longevity, with many engines going strong past the 1,000,000-mile mark. This higher resale value is another factor that can contribute to lower insurance costs for used diesel trucks.

Frequently asked questions