Obamacare Vs Private Insurance: Which Offers Better Coverage?

The Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare, has been a controversial topic since its inception in 2010. One of the most contentious elements was the individual mandate, which imposed a tax penalty on those who could afford health insurance but chose not to buy it. While this was designed to motivate individuals who needed health insurance to enroll in a marketplace plan, it was unpopular with many Americans, who saw it as a violation of personal liberty. In 2017, Congress passed a tax reform bill that included repealing the mandate starting in 2019, which was celebrated by opponents as a significant tax cut and a victory for individual freedom. However, supporters of the mandate, along with insurance industry experts, predicted that this would cause Obamacare premium costs to spike. This is because the enrollees that Obamacare plans needed the most were young, healthy individuals who used medical services infrequently. With the mandate removed, these individuals would no longer be motivated to stay enrolled in marketplace plans and would instead seek more affordable options. This prediction appears to be correct, with over a million Americans dropping their Obamacare plans in 2018. As a result, the proportion of older, sicker enrollees who use more medical services has increased, driving up the cost of coverage. This has led to a growing number of people turning to alternative insurance solutions, such as short-term health insurance or private insurance plans.

Cost: Obamacare is driving up the cost of health insurance, but non-Obamacare plans may not cover essential health benefits

It is widely acknowledged that Obamacare is driving up the cost of health insurance. In 2018, the average premium increase for an Obamacare plan was 27%, and industry experts predicted another spike in premium rates for 2019, estimated to be in the 19 to 24% range. This increase is blamed on the repeal of the individual tax mandate and the delay in risk adjustment payments to insurance companies.

However, non-Obamacare plans, also known as Term Medical plans, can offer greater savings through lower deductibles and out-of-pocket costs. These plans are available for up to a year and provide access to more doctors, office visits, hospital stays, and surgeries. They are also considered real medical insurance, offering up to $2 million in lifetime benefits.

While non-Obamacare plans can offer more affordable premiums, it is important to consider the trade-off in terms of covered benefits. Non-Obamacare plans are not required to cover essential health benefits, which include:

• Ambulatory patient services (outpatient care without hospital admission)
• Maternity and newborn care
• Mental health and substance use disorder services
• Rehabilitative and habilitative services and devices
• Preventive and wellness services and chronic disease management
• Pediatric services, including dental and vision care

On the other hand, Obamacare plans are designed to cover these essential health benefits, making them a more comprehensive option, especially for individuals with pre-existing conditions or those who require maternity care.

The decision between Obamacare and non-Obamacare plans ultimately depends on an individual's specific needs and circumstances. While cost is an important factor, it is crucial to weigh it against the level of coverage and benefits provided by each type of plan.

Coverage: Non-Obamacare plans can offer more choice of doctors and hospitals, but may not cover pre-existing conditions

When it comes to coverage, there are some key differences between Obamacare and non-Obamacare plans that are worth noting. Non-Obamacare plans, also known as Term Medical plans, often provide access to a wider choice of doctors and hospitals. This means that individuals may have more flexibility and freedom to choose their preferred providers and facilities without being restricted to a narrow network. This can be especially beneficial for those seeking specialty care or facing long wait times with doctors in the Obamacare network.

However, one significant disadvantage of non-Obamacare plans is that they may not cover pre-existing conditions. These plans are typically designed for individuals without major pre-existing conditions and may require applicants to answer medical questions or complete a brief medical history. On the other hand, Obamacare plans are created specifically for individuals with pre-existing conditions and do not require any medical questions to qualify.

It is important to note that while non-Obamacare plans may offer more choice in terms of providers and facilities, they might not cover all the essential health benefits that Obamacare plans include. Obamacare plans cover a range of essential health benefits, such as prescription drugs, mental health services, preventive care, chronic disease management, and laboratory services.

Additionally, non-Obamacare plans may have limitations on coverage for preventive or maternity care. However, if an individual with a non-Obamacare plan does get sick, they have the option to switch to an Obamacare plan during the next open enrollment season without any medical questions asked. This flexibility allows individuals to adjust their coverage based on their changing health needs.

In summary, while non-Obamacare plans offer more choice in terms of providers and facilities, they may not cover pre-existing conditions and might have limitations on certain essential health benefits. Obamacare plans, on the other hand, are designed to provide coverage for individuals with pre-existing conditions and include a range of essential health benefits. The choice between the two ultimately depends on an individual's specific health needs and preferences.

Flexibility: Obamacare plans are only available during open enrollment, but non-Obamacare plans can be purchased at any time

One of the key differences between Obamacare and non-Obamacare plans is their flexibility in terms of enrolment periods. Obamacare plans, also known as ACA (Affordable Care Act) plans, are typically only available for enrolment during the open enrolment period. This period usually occurs annually and may vary in timing, but it generally falls between November and December. On the other hand, non-Obamacare plans, also referred to as private insurance or Term Medical plans, can be purchased at any time outside of the open enrolment period. This flexibility can be advantageous for individuals who miss the Obamacare open enrolment window or require coverage for a limited period.

The open enrolment period for health insurance plans is a designated time frame during which individuals can enrol in or make changes to their health insurance coverage. It is typically the only time when people can enrol in an Obamacare plan without experiencing a qualifying life event, such as a change in marital status, the birth of a child, or a move to a new area. During this period, individuals can compare and select from a range of health insurance options available in their area.

Obamacare plans are designed to provide coverage for individuals with pre-existing conditions and ensure that everyone has access to healthcare, regardless of their medical history. As a result, these plans may have higher premiums due to the higher costs associated with covering sicker individuals. Obamacare plans also tend to have narrower provider networks, limiting enrollees to a specific list of participating doctors and facilities for their medical services to be covered.

In contrast, non-Obamacare plans are created for individuals without major pre-existing conditions. These plans often offer greater savings, with lower deductibles and out-of-pocket costs. They provide access to a wider range of doctors, office visits, hospital stays, and surgeries. Additionally, non-Obamacare plans can be customised to suit an individual's preferences, allowing them to choose their monthly premium, deductible, and other features.

While non-Obamacare plans offer flexibility in terms of enrolment periods, it is important to consider the trade-offs. These plans may not cover pre-existing conditions, and individuals with such conditions may find themselves without adequate coverage if they opt for a non-Obamacare plan. Additionally, non-Obamacare plans may not include all the essential health benefits mandated by the Affordable Care Act, such as maternity and newborn care, mental health services, and rehabilitative services.

Tax: Obamacare plans are eligible for tax credits and subsidies, but non-Obamacare plans may not be

One of the key differences between Obamacare and private insurance is that Obamacare plans are eligible for tax credits and subsidies, whereas non-Obamacare plans are not. This is because Obamacare, or the Affordable Care Act, is a government scheme, and private insurance is not.

The tax credits and subsidies available through Obamacare can make a significant difference to the cost of health insurance. For example, in 2018, 87% of Obamacare enrollees qualified for tax credits, which reduced their premium payments. This was an increase from 84% in 2017. However, for the remaining 13% of enrollees—more than 1.5 million people—who did not qualify for government subsidies, Obamacare may have been unaffordable.

The cost of health insurance is a significant factor when choosing a plan. Many people are turning to non-Obamacare plans, also known as Term Medical plans, as these can offer greater savings through lower deductibles and out-of-pocket costs. However, it is important to note that you may have to pay a tax penalty for purchasing a non-Obamacare plan, so it is worth speaking to a tax professional about your options.

Another factor to consider is that Obamacare plans are required to cover essential health benefits, such as outpatient care, maternity and newborn care, mental health services, rehabilitative services, preventive care, and pediatric services. Private insurance plans must also offer these essential health benefits, but they may have broader networks, giving you more choice when it comes to choosing your doctors and hospitals.

Ultimately, the decision between Obamacare and private insurance depends on your individual needs and circumstances. Obamacare may be a good option if you qualify for tax credits and subsidies, whereas private insurance could offer more choice and flexibility, but at a potentially higher cost.

Customisation: Obamacare plans have limited customisation, but non-Obamacare plans allow users to choose their monthly premium, deductible, etc

When it comes to customisation, Obamacare plans offer limited options in this regard. With Obamacare, individuals do not have the flexibility to tailor their plan to their specific needs and preferences, as the monthly premium, deductible and other features are predetermined. This lack of customisation can be a significant drawback for those who desire more control over their healthcare choices and costs.

On the other hand, non-Obamacare plans, also known as Term Medical plans, offer users much greater flexibility and customisation. With these plans, individuals can choose their monthly premium, deductible and other features based on their unique circumstances and requirements. This customisation allows people to design a plan that aligns with their budget and healthcare priorities, ensuring they only pay for what they need.

For example, if an individual is healthy and does not anticipate significant healthcare expenses, they can opt for a lower premium and higher deductible, resulting in lower overall costs. Conversely, those with more complex health needs or higher expected costs may prefer a higher premium and lower deductible to ensure greater coverage.

The customisation offered by non-Obamacare plans also extends to the choice of providers. Non-Obamacare plans often have broader networks, allowing individuals to visit any provider or facility they choose without restrictions. In contrast, Obamacare plans typically enforce narrow provider networks, limiting enrollees to a list of participating doctors and facilities. This restriction can be inconvenient and limit an individual's ability to receive care from their preferred providers.

Additionally, non-Obamacare plans offer a range of additional benefits that can be tailored to specific needs. These may include prescription drug coverage, teleconsultations with doctors, discounts on vision care, and more. The ability to customise these benefits allows individuals to create a plan that aligns with their unique healthcare needs and preferences.

While Obamacare plans provide essential coverage for those with pre-existing conditions or complex health needs, the lack of customisation may be a significant drawback for those seeking greater control and flexibility in their healthcare choices. Non-Obamacare plans fill this gap by offering individuals the ability to design a plan that suits their specific needs, budget and healthcare priorities.

Frequently asked questions