Understanding The Complexities: Short-Term Limited Duration Insurance And Its Excepted Benefit Status

Short-term, limited-duration insurance is not an excepted benefit, but it is exempt from PHS Act requirements as it is not individual health insurance coverage. Excepted benefits refer to hospital indemnity or other fixed indemnity insurance that meets specific payment standards and regulatory criteria. This type of insurance is offered on an independent, non-coordinated basis and is exempt from federal consumer protections and requirements for comprehensive coverage. The Departments are proposing amendments to the federal regulations to outline the conditions for hospital indemnity and fixed indemnity insurance to qualify as excepted benefits. These amendments aim to address misleading marketing and sales tactics and changes in market conditions and the legal landscape.

Short-term limited-duration insurance is not an excepted benefit

Short-term limited-duration insurance (STLDI) is not an excepted benefit. Excepted benefits refer to insurance that pays a fixed amount under specified conditions without regard to other insurance coverages. For hospital indemnity and other fixed indemnity insurance to be considered an excepted benefit, it must pay a fixed dollar amount per day or period of hospitalization or illness, regardless of the amount of expenses incurred.

STLDI, on the other hand, is defined as "health insurance coverage provided pursuant to a contract with an issuer that has an expiration date specified in the contract (taking into account any extensions that may be elected by the policyholder without the issuer's consent) that is less than 12 months after the original effective date of the contract." This type of insurance is not considered individual health insurance coverage under the PHS Act and is therefore exempt from its requirements.

Prior to the Affordable Care Act, STLDI served as a means for individuals to obtain health coverage during transitional periods, such as when changing jobs or group health plans. However, the regulations have since changed, and the Departments have proposed amendments to address misleading marketing and sales tactics associated with certain benefit designs.

It is important to note that the definition of STLDI has been amended to further limit the length of coverage. The current rules define STLDI as having an initial contract term of no more than three months and a maximum coverage period of no more than four months, including any renewals or extensions. These changes aim to provide clarity and protect consumers from potentially misleading information regarding their insurance coverage.

Fixed indemnity insurance is an excepted benefit

Short-term, limited-duration insurance is not an excepted benefit. However, fixed indemnity insurance is an excepted benefit if it meets certain conditions.

Fixed indemnity insurance is a form of "junk insurance" that has been defined as an excepted benefit since the mid-1990s. Historically, this benefit was understood as a form of income replacement rather than direct payment for medical care. Because it serves a different purpose than traditional health insurance, fixed indemnity coverage is exempt from most federal health insurance regulations, including the health insurance standards of the Affordable Care Act (ACA). As a result, fixed indemnity coverage may discriminate based on pre-existing conditions, decline to cover essential health benefits, and does not need to cap enrollees' annual out-of-pocket spending.

To be considered an excepted benefit, fixed indemnity insurance must meet specific criteria. Firstly, it should be offered on an independent, non-coordinated basis, separate from any group health plan maintained by the same plan sponsor. Secondly, the benefits must be paid without regard to other insurance coverage or the specific treatment received. This means that the payment should not be based on the services or items received, the estimated or actual amount of expenses incurred, or the severity of the illness or injury. Thirdly, the benefit design must be truly "fixed", ensuring that benefits do not vary with an individual course of treatment.

The Departments, including HHS, are proposing amendments to the regulations governing fixed indemnity excepted benefits coverage. These proposed regulations aim to prevent plans and issuers from offering fixed indemnity coverage that mimics comprehensive coverage without providing the same consumer protections. One proposed change is to prohibit fixed indemnity plans in the individual market from paying benefits on a per-service basis, addressing the practice of designing complex, fee-for-service-style plans that resemble comprehensive coverage.

It is important to note that short-term, limited-duration insurance is exempt from PHS Act requirements because it is not individual health insurance coverage. However, it does not qualify as an excepted benefit.

Short-term limited-duration insurance is exempt from PHS Act requirements

Short-term limited-duration insurance (STLDI) is exempt from the requirements of the Public Health Service Act (PHS Act) because it is not considered "individual health insurance coverage" as defined by the PHS Act. This means that while STLDI is not an excepted benefit, it is still exempt from certain regulations.

The PHS Act, as outlined in Section 2791(b)(5), specifies that "individual health insurance coverage" refers to health insurance offered to individuals in the individual market, which does not include short-term, limited-duration insurance. This type of insurance is typically associated with temporary coverage during transitions between different forms of health insurance, such as when individuals change jobs or encounter similar situations.

The current regulations define short-term, limited-duration insurance as "health insurance coverage provided pursuant to a contract with an issuer that has an expiration date specified in the contract, including any extensions that may be elected by the policyholder without the issuer's consent, that is less than 12 months after the original effective date of the contract." This definition sets a clear timeframe for what constitutes short-term coverage.

However, it is worth noting that the definition of STLDI has been amended to further limit the length of coverage. The current rules define STLDI as having an initial contract term of fewer than 12 months and a maximum total coverage period of up to 36 months, including renewals and extensions. The proposed amendments aim to shorten the initial contract term to no more than three months and the maximum coverage period to no more than four months, including any renewals or extensions.

In contrast, insurance that pays a fixed amount under specified conditions, often referred to as "hospital indemnity or other fixed indemnity insurance," can be considered an excepted benefit when offered on an independent, non-coordinated basis. This type of insurance is exempt from federal consumer protections and requirements for comprehensive coverage. To qualify as an excepted benefit, hospital indemnity insurance must meet specific payment standards and other statutory and regulatory criteria.

Travel insurance can be considered an excepted benefit

In the context of travel insurance, it is important to understand the nature of the benefits provided. Travel insurance typically covers personal risks associated with planned travel, including trip interruption or cancellation, loss of baggage or personal effects, damages to accommodations or rental vehicles, and medical issues such as sickness, accident, disability, or death during travel. Notably, travel insurance does not usually include comprehensive medical coverage, and any health benefits provided are incidental to other forms of coverage.

The classification of travel insurance as an excepted benefit is outlined in the regulations of various acts, including the PHS Act, ERISA, and the Code. Specifically, travel insurance falls under the first category of excepted benefits, as confirmed by the Departments in their proposed regulations. This categorization is based on the definition of travel insurance, which encompasses the aforementioned personal risks incident to planned travel.

It is worth noting that travel insurance as an excepted benefit has certain limitations. For instance, it does not include major medical plans that provide comprehensive medical protection for travellers on extended trips of six months or longer, such as expatriates or military personnel on deployment. Additionally, travel insurance as an excepted benefit does not cover situations where health benefits are offered on a stand-alone basis; they must be incidental to other forms of coverage.

In summary, travel insurance can be considered an excepted benefit due to its nature of providing limited coverage for specific travel-related risks. This classification is important as it exempts travel insurance from certain regulatory requirements, allowing it to function as a supplemental form of protection for individuals during their travels without the need for comprehensive medical coverage.

Fixed indemnity insurance must pay a fixed amount to be considered an excepted benefit

Short-term, limited-duration insurance is not an excepted benefit. However, fixed indemnity insurance, when offered as an independent, noncoordinated benefit, is considered an excepted benefit. This means it is exempt from federal consumer protections and requirements for comprehensive coverage.

Fixed indemnity insurance is a form of health insurance that provides a fixed benefit amount per day or per period of hospitalisation or illness, regardless of the expenses incurred. To be considered an excepted benefit, this fixed benefit structure must be in place, and enrollees must maintain other coverage. The benefit must be provided under a separate policy, certificate, or contract of insurance, and there must be no coordination with any exclusion of benefits under another group health plan maintained by the same plan sponsor.

The Departments, including CMS and others, have noticed a significant increase in the number of health insurance policies labelled as fixed indemnity coverage. This has led to concerns about misleading marketing and sales tactics, with consumers believing they are purchasing comprehensive coverage when they are not. As a result, amendments are being proposed to outline the conditions for fixed indemnity insurance to qualify as an excepted benefit in the group market.

The NY Department of Insurance has its own regulations regarding fixed indemnity insurance. They analyse whether the amount of coverage exceeds the parameters found in New York Insurance Regulation 62. If it does, they will not consider it an "indemnity-type" policy, even if benefits are paid on a per-day or "fixed" basis. Instead, it is considered a form of health insurance that pays on an "expense incurred" basis.

In conclusion, while short-term, limited-duration insurance is not an excepted benefit, fixed indemnity insurance can be. However, to be considered an excepted benefit, fixed indemnity insurance must meet specific criteria, including paying a fixed amount and being offered independently of other comprehensive coverage.

Frequently asked questions