Monitored Auto Insurance: Devices Tracking Your Driving

Many insurance companies offer programs that track your driving habits using a telematics device, also known as a car insurance tracker. These devices are either plugged into your car's onboard diagnostics or downloaded as a smartphone app. They monitor your speed, acceleration, braking, location, phone usage, and other details, sending the information back to the insurance company. This data is used to adjust your premium or offer discounts to safe drivers. While these programs can lead to cheaper insurance rates, there are also privacy concerns and risks associated with sharing driving data.

Telematics technology

The data collected by telematics devices includes information such as mileage, speed, braking patterns, acceleration, location, time of day, phone usage, and more. This data is then sent to the insurance company, which uses it to calculate insurance premiums and offer discounts or rewards for safe driving.

The use of telematics technology in auto insurance has benefits and drawbacks. On the one hand, it can help drivers save money on their insurance premiums by rewarding safe driving habits. It can also help drivers become more aware of their driving behaviours and encourage them to adopt safer practices. Additionally, telematics technology can assist insurance companies in combating fraudulent claims and controlling the price of auto insurance for all customers.

On the other hand, there are privacy concerns associated with telematics technology, as it involves allowing an insurance company to track a driver's data and whereabouts. There is also a risk that the collected data could be used against the driver if they need to file an insurance claim after an accident. Furthermore, insurance companies may sell the collected data to third-party companies for profit.

Overall, telematics technology in auto insurance has the potential to benefit drivers who practice safe driving habits and are comfortable with the data collection involved. However, it is important for individuals to carefully consider the potential benefits and drawbacks before opting into a telematics-based insurance program.

Safe driving apps

One example of a safe driving app is DriveMyWay by American Family Insurance, which offers a discount of up to 20% on your auto insurance premium for safe driving. The app monitors behaviours such as speeding, braking, and phone use, providing feedback to help you improve your driving skills and save money.

While safe driving apps can be a great way to save money and encourage safer driving, it's important to consider the potential drawbacks. Some people may feel nervous about their driving habits being monitored, and there are privacy concerns about sharing driving data. Additionally, insurance companies may use the data to increase rates for risky driving behaviours, and there is a risk of this data being used against you in the event of an accident or insurance claim.

It's also worth noting that safe driving apps are not the only form of telematics technology. Some insurance companies offer physical devices that plug into your vehicle's onboard diagnostics port, while others may provide a combination of a mobile app and a physical device. These devices can track similar driving behaviours as the apps and may be required for certain insurance programs or discounts.

When considering the use of safe driving apps or other telematics devices, it is essential to research and understand the specific data being collected, how it will be used by the insurance company, and the potential impact on your insurance rates. While these tools can offer benefits, it's important to weigh the pros and cons before deciding if they are right for you.

Tracking driver behaviour

The data collected by these devices includes:

• Speed
• Acceleration
• Braking patterns
• Mileage and time spent driving
• Location
• Phone usage while driving
• Turning and cornering

This information is used by insurance companies to identify safe drivers and offer them discounted rates. It can also be used to identify and reject fraudulent insurance claims. For example, if a driver claims they were driving responsibly when an animal darted in front of them, but the data shows they were driving recklessly or intentionally caused the accident to claim insurance money.

There are benefits and drawbacks to using these tracking devices. On the one hand, they can help lower insurance premiums for safe drivers and even improve driving habits by making drivers more aware of their speed, braking, and phone usage. On the other hand, there are privacy concerns as it involves giving up personal data and allowing your driving habits to be monitored. Additionally, there is a risk of higher insurance rates if you are deemed a risky driver based on the data collected.

Some insurance companies that offer usage-based insurance programs with tracking devices include:

• Allstate: Drivewise
• American Family: KnowYourDrive, DriveMyWay
• Farmers: Signal
• Geico: DriveEasy
• Nationwide: SmartRide
• Progressive: Snapshot
• State Farm: Drive Safe & Save
• Travelers: IntelliDrive
• USAA: SafePilot

Discounts for safe driving

Many insurance companies offer programs that track your driving habits using telematics technology. These devices monitor your speed, acceleration, braking, and other details each time you drive and report the information to the insurance company. This allows insurers to set rates that reflect your level of risk.

Usage-based insurance (UBI) programs that utilize telematics devices are becoming more popular because they can lead to cheaper car insurance rates for safe drivers. UBI programs use telematics data about your driving habits to calculate personalized insurance premiums. This is sometimes referred to as "black box" car insurance or "pay how you drive."

Some insurance companies offer an introductory discount just for enrolling in a UBI program. After that, your driving behavior determines your discount. The safer you drive, the higher your discount will be.

Pros

• Lower monthly car insurance premiums
• Improved driving habits and reduced risk of accidents
• Additional rewards such as cashback or rate discounts

Cons

• Loss of privacy
• Potential for higher rates if you are deemed a risky driver
• Limited mileage as you can only drive a certain number of miles per month
• Insurance companies may sell your private data to third-party companies

Privacy concerns

The use of telematics devices or insurance trackers by auto insurance companies raises several privacy concerns for drivers. While these devices can monitor a range of driving habits, including speed, acceleration, braking, mileage, and location, they also collect personal and sensitive data. This data can include phone usage, driving patterns, and even the vehicle's location history. As a result, some drivers may feel their privacy is invaded, and their data is at risk of being misused or sold to third parties without their consent.

One of the primary privacy concerns is the potential for insurance companies to access and track a driver's location through GPS data. While insurance companies claim their focus is on how a person drives rather than where they drive, the collection of location data still raises concerns about surveillance and the potential for this information to be misused. For example, constant location tracking can reveal personal details such as places frequently visited, daily routines, and even the driver's home address. This information, if accessed by malicious actors, could be used for stalking, identity theft, or other harmful purposes.

In addition to location tracking, insurance trackers also monitor other driving habits, such as acceleration, braking, and phone usage. While this data is intended to assess driving behaviour, it can reveal sensitive information about a person's life. For instance, frequent phone usage while driving may indicate a person is a high-risk driver, but it could also imply they are a rideshare driver or have a job that requires constant communication. As a result, some drivers may feel their profession or personal habits are being judged or profiled based on this data.

Furthermore, there is a risk of insurance companies misusing the collected data or selling it to third parties for profit. While insurance companies claim to encrypt and protect the data, there is always a possibility of a data breach or unauthorized access. This concern is heightened by the fact that insurance companies often have broad discretion in how they use the data, and their policies regarding data sharing with third parties may not be transparent. As a result, drivers may feel their privacy is at the mercy of the insurance company's data handling practices, over which they have little control.

Another privacy concern arises when insurance companies use the collected data to deny or dispute claims. In the event of an accident, the insurance company may use the data from the tracking device to argue that the driver was at fault, even if there are mitigating circumstances. For example, if a driver was slightly speeding when another vehicle ran a red light and caused a collision, the insurance company could use the speeding data to deny the claim, leaving the driver financially responsible for repairs or medical bills. This dynamic creates an inherent conflict of interest, as the insurance company's incentive to minimize payouts may conflict with the driver's right to fair compensation.

Lastly, the use of insurance trackers may disproportionately affect certain demographics, such as teenagers, elderly drivers, or those with previous driving infractions. These individuals, who are already considered high-risk by insurance companies, may face higher rates or even loss of coverage if their driving habits do not meet the insurer's standards. As a result, they may feel their privacy is invaded as the tracking devices become a means of constant surveillance and judgement, rather than a tool for improving driving skills and obtaining discounts.

Frequently asked questions