Dave Ramsey's Take On Adjustable Comp Life Insurance

Dave Ramsey is a well-known personal finance expert who has built a reputation for providing no-nonsense financial advice to his followers. When it comes to the topic of adjustable comp life insurance, also known as variable universal life insurance, Ramsey has a strong opinion that aligns with his overall philosophy on life insurance.

Ramsey believes that life insurance serves one primary purpose: to replace your income if you die. He argues that life insurance is not an investment vehicle and that combining insurance with investing is a red flag. As a result, he recommends term life insurance as the best option for most people. Term life insurance is simple, affordable, and separate from any complex investment schemes.

In contrast, adjustable comp life insurance is a type of permanent life insurance that includes a cash value account. While it offers adjustable premiums and the ability to access cash value while alive, Ramsey and his team argue that it is a poor product due to high fees, complicated structures, and underwhelming outcomes. They emphasize that the ultimate goal of life insurance should be to protect your loved ones, not create investment opportunities.

Overall, Ramsey's stance on adjustable comp life insurance aligns with his broader philosophy of keeping finances simple, effective, and focused on providing security for your family.

Dave Ramsey's stance on whole life insurance

Dave Ramsey is a well-known personal finance expert who has written several books and hosted radio and YouTube shows on the subject. He is a strong advocate for term life insurance and advises people to avoid whole life insurance.

Ramsey's stance on whole life insurance is primarily that it is an unnecessary expense for most people. He argues that life insurance should only be used to replace your income if you die and support your dependents. Once you have built up enough wealth and no longer have dependents relying on your income, you no longer need life insurance. This is typically a short period of 10-20 years while you are raising children or have a mortgage. Whole life insurance, on the other hand, lasts your entire life and can be up to 10 times more expensive than term life insurance.

Another issue Ramsey highlights is that whole life insurance adds complicated investment options with poor returns on investment (ROIs). He compares it to mixing home or auto insurance with an investment scheme, which is not a good idea. The administrative fees for whole life insurance are also extremely high and can cut into your returns. Additionally, if you die before spending the cash value portion of a whole life insurance policy, that money goes back to the insurance company, and your beneficiaries will not receive it.

Instead of whole life insurance, Ramsey recommends buying term life insurance and investing the savings in a tax-advantaged retirement account. Term life insurance is much cheaper and serves the sole purpose of providing financial protection for your loved ones if you die prematurely. By investing the difference, you can build real wealth and become self-insured over time.

In summary, Dave Ramsey's stance on whole life insurance is negative due to its high cost, unnecessary features, poor investment returns, and the fact that it is only suitable for a short period when you have dependents. He advises people to stick to term life insurance and invest their savings elsewhere.

The purpose of life insurance

Life insurance is particularly important if you have people depending on your income. It is recommended that you buy a 10-20 year term policy worth 10-12 times your annual income. You should also consider how much of the household income you provide, whether anyone depends on you financially, and how your family will pay final expenses and repay debts after your death.

Life insurance can also function as an investment, as certain types of life insurance policies build cash value and count as financial assets while the policyholder is alive. However, it is generally advised to keep your life insurance and investments separate.

The pros and cons of variable universal life insurance

Dave Ramsey's website does not appear to explicitly mention adjustable comp life insurance, but it does provide a detailed explanation of variable universal life insurance, which seems to be a similar concept.

Variable universal life insurance is a type of permanent life insurance that combines a death benefit with a savings component, known as cash value. This type of insurance allows you to invest and grow the cash value through subaccounts that operate like mutual funds, offering the potential for higher returns compared to other types of life insurance. However, it is important to note that this also comes with higher risks, as you could lose money if your investments perform poorly.

Pros:

• The death benefit is often income tax-free, allowing your beneficiaries to receive the full amount without tax deductions.
• It offers flexible premium payments, giving you the option to adjust the amount and frequency of contributions within the limits of your contract.
• There is potential for tax-deferred growth on your cash value, which means you may be able to defer taxes on any growth until you withdraw the money.
• You may have the ability to adjust your coverage amount, increasing or decreasing the size of your death benefit within the limits set by the insurer.

Cons:

• Complexity: Variable universal life insurance is more complex than term or whole life insurance policies, making it more challenging to understand and manage.
• Higher premium payments: This type of insurance typically requires higher premium payments compared to other types of life insurance due to higher contract charges and investment fees.
• Long-term commitment: Variable universal life insurance is designed for long-term financial goals and is not suitable for short-term investing.
• Market risk: The cash value of your policy is subject to market fluctuations, which means you could lose money if your investments perform poorly. There is also a risk of losing your life insurance coverage if the cash value is insufficient to cover the costs.

The drawbacks of universal life insurance

Dave Ramsey's teachings on life insurance are that it is only necessary while you are building wealth and have dependents. He recommends a 10-20 year term policy worth 10-12 times your annual income. He advises against whole life insurance, which can be up to 10 times more expensive and includes complicated investment options with poor ROIs.

Universal life insurance is a type of permanent life insurance that offers flexible premiums and death benefits, and the opportunity to build cash value over time. However, there are several drawbacks to this type of insurance:

Fees

Universal life insurance policies come with a lot of fees, including administrative fees, surrender charges for cancelling your policy, and fees for transferring money between subaccounts. These fees can eat into your returns and make it difficult to build cash value.

Risk of loss

If your investments don't perform well, you could lose money in your cash value account and see your premiums increase. There is also the risk of your policy lapsing if you don't maintain your premiums and don't have sufficient cash value to cover the missed payments.

Reduced death benefit

If you withdraw money from your cash value account, your death benefit will be reduced. This means you could end up leaving your beneficiaries with less money than you intended.

Poor investment returns

The cash value account of a universal life insurance policy often doesn't perform as well as other investment options, such as growth stock mutual funds through tax-advantaged retirement accounts.

Complexity

Universal life insurance can be complicated, with different types of policies (variable, indexed, and guaranteed) and riders (add-ons) to choose from. It requires a more hands-on approach than other types of permanent policies, such as whole life insurance.

The difference between term and whole life insurance

Dave Ramsey, a finance expert, recommends term life insurance over whole life insurance. He believes that whole life insurance is a rip-off and a way to "screw people". Here's a detailed look at the differences between the two types of life insurance:

Term Life Insurance:

• Coverage Period: Term life insurance provides coverage for a set term or a specific amount of time, usually between 10 and 30 years.
• Cost: Term life insurance is generally more affordable than whole life insurance.
• Flexibility: It allows individuals to choose a term length that suits their unique situation, which can help reduce costs in the long run.
• Payout: If the policyholder passes away during the specified period, the beneficiary will receive a payout.
• Pros: Term life insurance is customizable, specific to your timeline, and usually more affordable.
• Cons: If you outlive the term length, your coverage will end, and you won't receive any benefits. It does not provide coverage for your entire lifetime, and the policy does not accumulate cash value.

Whole Life Insurance:

• Coverage Period: Whole life insurance provides coverage for an individual's entire life as long as they continue to pay the insurance premiums.
• Cost: Whole life insurance tends to be significantly more expensive than term life insurance.
• Investment Component: Whole life insurance serves as an investment and accumulates cash value over time, which can be used to pay premiums or borrowed against.
• Payout: The death benefit payout is guaranteed as long as the premiums are paid.
• Pros: The premiums remain the same, the payout is guaranteed, and the value of the plan grows at a constant rate.
• Cons: The policy length cannot be chosen, and it is typically more expensive. The death benefit amount can change if there is an outstanding loan against the policy's cash value.

In summary, term life insurance is generally recommended for individuals who only need coverage for a specific period, such as while they have financial dependents. On the other hand, whole life insurance may be suitable for those who want lifelong coverage and are comfortable with the higher premiums.

Frequently asked questions