Auto Insurance In California: What's Happening?

California is one of the most expensive states for car insurance, with quotes up to 24% higher than the national average. The average annual premium for drivers in California is $1,782, based on sample data. The cheapest car insurance company in California for most drivers is Geico, which costs an average of $35 per month for minimum coverage and $124 per month for full coverage. The best car insurance company depends on your needs and budget.

California's auto insurance rates are rising faster than in other states

Another factor is the regulatory environment in California. The state has strict regulations on insurance rate increases, with a provision that requires hearings for any personal insurance rate increase requests above 7% if challenged by the public. This has led to a backlog of rate increase requests, with insurance companies claiming that the state has been slow to approve their requests. The insurance industry also blames the state's cumbersome regulations for their financial losses. However, consumer advocates argue that insurance companies are taking advantage of the situation and trying to push for deregulation.

The increase in auto insurance rates has been significant, with some drivers in Los Angeles experiencing a more than 25% increase in their insurance costs compared to the previous year. The average cost of full coverage in California was $2,417 as of June, up from $1,666 the previous year. The approved rate increases for auto insurance in California have averaged 13.2%, compared to an average of 10.6% in 2019 before the pandemic.

The rising insurance rates have squeezed drivers financially and contributed to inflation. Additionally, the higher costs have made it challenging for some drivers to obtain insurance, with reports of delays, higher premiums, and questionable insurer behavior. California's insurance commissioner, Ricardo Lara, has acknowledged the issue and urged consumers to contact the Department of Insurance for assistance in finding more affordable options.

Insurers are reluctant to do business in California

California's insurance market is facing a crisis as insurers are pulling out of the state. This is due to a combination of factors, including regulatory disagreements, the legal environment, and increased costs.

The state's insurance regulations also limit the ability of insurers to cancel policies and require certain levels of coverage. For example, California's "efficient proximate cause" rule mandates that property insurers cover post-fire flooding, such as mudslides. Additionally, California is one of only four states that require insurers to sell insurance to "good drivers," and the only state that mandates a 20% discount for these drivers. The state also has unique requirements for usage-based insurance, largely banning telematics and only allowing the number of miles driven to be considered in setting rates.

The high cost of living in California, particularly the high cost of construction and home prices, further contributes to the reluctance of insurers to do business in the state. As a result of these factors, insurers feel they cannot adequately price their policies and can only lose money by operating in California.

The situation has led to a decrease in the availability of insurance in California, with residents facing longer wait times and higher premiums. The state's insurance commissioner, Ricardo Lara, has acknowledged the crisis and is working to address the issue. However, insurers argue that the state's approval of rate increases is not keeping up with the rising costs, and their requests for rate adjustments continue to be pending.

California has a lot of insurance regulations

California's insurance regulations are designed to balance the need for insurance companies to remain solvent with protecting consumers from excessive price increases. The state has Proposition 103, a consumer protection law that requires insurers to justify rate increases before the state approves them. This has been a point of contention for insurance companies, some of which have become reluctant to do business in California.

In addition to Proposition 103, California has other regulations that impact auto insurance. For example, California is one of only four states that require insurers to sell insurance to "good drivers", and the only state that mandates a 20% discount for these drivers. California also requires that insurance premiums be based on a driver's record, experience, and miles driven annually.

The state also has specific requirements for the types of insurance that drivers must carry. Drivers must have a minimum level of liability insurance, which covers injury or death to one or more people and damage to property. California also offers a Low-Cost Auto Insurance Program for drivers who cannot afford traditional insurance.

The insurance regulations in California have led to a unique market for auto insurance, with higher rates and longer wait times for coverage. However, the regulations also provide protections for consumers, ensuring that insurance companies cannot raise rates excessively.

California's insurance department hasn't approved a rate increase in over two years

California's insurance department hasn't approved a rate increase for personal car insurance in over two years. This prolonged freeze on rate increases has been in place since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic and has resulted in insurance rates in California being lower than in other states.

The freeze was initially implemented in response to the “stay-at-home” order issued by the state in March 2020, which significantly reduced the number of cars on the roads. As a result, California Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara ordered insurance companies to refund a portion of the premiums paid by drivers, totalling approximately $2.4 billion.

However, insurance companies are now expressing their reluctance to do business in California due to the low rates, which they argue are insufficient to cover rising costs. They have filed requests to raise their auto insurance rates, but none have been approved so far. This has led to concerns about the potential impact on consumers, as well as the viability of the insurance market in the state.

The situation in California is further complicated by Proposition 103, a consumer protection law that requires insurers to justify any rate increases before the state approves them. This additional layer of regulation is viewed as a burden by insurance companies, who must navigate a more complex and time-consuming process to adjust their rates.

The state's insurance department has its reasons for maintaining the freeze, but it is facing increasing pressure from insurance companies and consumers alike as the former seek to maintain profitability and the latter struggle with higher premiums and longer wait times to obtain insurance.

Insurers are making it harder for consumers to get new policies

In California, drivers are facing a perfect storm when it comes to auto insurance. A combination of factors, including a surge in road accidents, has led to a crisis in the state's car insurance market. This has resulted in higher premiums and more stringent requirements for consumers. For many Californians, it is becoming increasingly challenging to obtain and maintain affordable auto insurance. One of the primary issues is that insurers are tightening their requirements and making it harder for consumers to obtain new policies. This trend is particularly noticeable in Southern California, where some drivers are finding themselves unable to get the coverage they need.

Insurers are becoming more selective about their customers, and this cautious approach is making it difficult for new customers to enter the market. Existing customers are also facing stricter requirements at renewal time. This change in strategy from insurance providers is a direct response to the challenging market conditions and the need to mitigate their risks. One of the main strategies insurers are employing is to require more extensive documentation and proof of driving history. Consumers are now often asked to provide detailed records, including driving records, vehicle maintenance history, and proof of prior insurance.

Obtaining these records can be a cumbersome and time-consuming process for consumers, and it may act as a barrier for those who need insurance promptly. The situation is even more challenging for drivers with a less-than-perfect record, as insurers are increasingly reluctant to take on what they perceive as higher-risk customers. Good drivers with a clean record are also facing difficulties as they may be caught up in this net and still struggle to find insurance. Insurers are also more closely scrutinizing vehicle types and models, with some companies refusing to insure certain makes and models, particularly those that are older or considered high-risk. This can disproportionately affect lower-income drivers who may not be able to afford newer or safer vehicles.

Additionally, insurance companies are implementing stricter underwriting guidelines and raising the bar for credit scores and claims history. These stringent measures are making it harder for consumers to meet the requirements and obtain the necessary coverage. The impact of these changes is being felt across the state, and it remains to be seen how long this trend will continue. For now, drivers in California are facing a challenging market and must navigate these hurdles to obtain and maintain the auto insurance coverage they need. It is essential for consumers to be aware of these changing requirements and to take proactive steps to ensure they can meet the insurer's standards, whether it be maintaining a good driving record, keeping thorough documentation, or being prepared to shop around for insurers that suit their specific circumstances.

Frequently asked questions