Michigan's Auto Insurance Reform: Limiting Fee Hikes

Michigan has taken several steps to limit auto insurance fees, including eliminating the mandate for unlimited personal injury protection (PIP) on auto insurance policies, reducing PIP premiums, and establishing a fee schedule between auto insurers and medical providers. These changes aim to lower costs for Michigan drivers while maintaining high coverage options and strengthening consumer protections. The state's new auto insurance law also prohibits insurers from using non-driving factors such as credit scores and gender when setting insurance rates. Additionally, Michigan has implemented reforms to lower the costs of its Michigan Catastrophic Claims Association (MCCA) fees, which are paid by drivers as part of their auto insurance premiums. These measures have resulted in significant savings for Michigan drivers, with reductions in PIP insurance requirements translating to savings of up to $1,771 per year.

Michigan drivers save over $1,000 on average due to legal reforms

Michigan drivers have long been burdened by high auto insurance costs, but a series of legal reforms have brought significant relief, with savings of over $1,000 on average. The state's new auto insurance law, signed by Governor Whitmer, aims to lower costs while maintaining high coverage options and strengthening consumer protections.

The reforms give Michigan drivers more choices and control over their Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage. For the first time, drivers can choose a level that suits their needs and budget. Previously, unlimited PIP coverage was mandatory, but now there are several options, including $50,000, $250,000, and $500,000 limits, or even the option to opt out entirely if certain conditions are met. This flexibility has resulted in substantial savings, with some estimates reaching up to $1,771 per year.

The new law also addresses the high cost of medical care, which has been a contributing factor to the state's high auto insurance rates. It establishes a fee schedule between auto insurers and medical providers, similar to the cost control provisions used in health insurance. This fee schedule will make PIP medical coverage more affordable for policyholders without compromising the services available to accident victims.

In addition, the Michigan Catastrophic Claims Association (MCCA) has lowered its per-vehicle assessment, resulting in savings of at least $120 per car for drivers. Those who choose limited PIP coverage will not have to pay any assessment to the MCCA.

The legal reforms also prohibit auto insurers from using certain non-driving factors, such as credit scores, marital status, gender, education, and occupation, to set insurance rates. This ensures that premiums are based primarily on factors related to driving, such as an individual's record and claims history.

The combination of these reforms has led to substantial savings for Michigan drivers, with the average annual cost of full coverage car insurance now standing at around $3,000, a significant decrease from previous years. These changes not only reduce the financial burden on drivers but also encourage competition and fairness in the auto insurance market, benefiting consumers across the state.

Michigan drivers can now choose from six PIP coverage limits

Michigan drivers can now choose from six Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage limits, allowing them to select a level that suits their needs and budget. This change was implemented as part of the state's new auto insurance law, which came into effect for policies issued or renewed after July 1, 2020.

The six PIP coverage options available to Michigan drivers are:

• Unlimited coverage per person per accident: This option provides lifetime reimbursement for reasonable and necessary medical expenses related to an accident. It is available to all drivers and was the mandatory coverage before the law reform.
• Up to $500,000 in coverage per person per accident: This option is accessible to all drivers.
• Up to $250,000 in coverage per person per accident: All drivers can choose this option. Additionally, policyholders can exclude some or all drivers on their policy if they have a health insurance policy that covers auto injuries with a deductible below $6,000.
• Up to $50,000 in coverage per person per accident: This choice is reserved for drivers enrolled in Medicaid and meeting additional eligibility requirements. They must ensure that their household members also have appropriate coverage, such as another auto insurance policy, Medicaid, or other health insurance.
• Opt-out with no PIP coverage: This selection is exclusively for drivers with Medicare Parts A and B, fulfilling additional eligibility criteria. Household members must also have suitable coverage through another auto insurance policy or health insurance.
• $250,000 per person per accident with PIP medical exclusion(s): This option is available to a named insured individual with non-Medicare health coverage that includes auto accident injuries. It also applies to household members if they have health insurance covering auto accident injuries.

If a driver does not select a PIP medical option, the unlimited PIP medical coverage will be automatically chosen as the default.

The new law limits medical fees charged to auto insurers

Michigan has introduced a new law that limits the medical fees charged to auto insurers by hospitals, doctors, and other healthcare providers. This law is designed to address the high cost of auto insurance in the state, which has been driven in part by the increased costs of services that these providers have charged auto insurance companies.

The new law establishes a fee schedule between auto insurers and medical providers, which is intended to control the costs that medical providers can charge auto insurers for their services. This is similar to the cost control provisions used by other types of insurance, such as health insurance. The fee schedule will make Personal Injury Protection (PIP) medical coverage premiums more affordable for policyholders, while not affecting the services that existing and future accident victims are entitled to.

Under Michigan's no-fault law, insurers cover the reasonable and necessary medical expenses for drivers and their passengers injured in an accident, regardless of fault. As a result, the state's drivers have some of the highest auto insurance costs in the nation. The new law will help to reduce these costs for drivers while still ensuring that they receive the necessary medical coverage in the event of an accident.

The fee schedule will be implemented for policies issued or renewed after July 1, 2020, and drivers will see a reduction in their PIP medical coverage premiums as a result. The specific reductions will depend on the chosen PIP option, with an average reduction of 45% or greater for the $50,000 PIP option, and an average reduction of 10% or greater for the unlimited PIP option.

Michigan drivers pay a portion of their premiums to the Michigan Catastrophic Claims Association (MCCA)

The MCCA also provides refunds to Michigan drivers. In 2022, eligible Michigan policyholders received $400 per vehicle as a refund. The refund was sent as a check or an ACH deposit. The MCCA's actuarial analysis determined that approximately $3 billion of the surplus could be returned to policyholders while ensuring continuity of care for auto accident survivors.

The MCCA is funded by Michigan drivers through their auto insurance premiums. The MCCA then uses these funds to reimburse auto insurers for PIP medical costs that exceed a certain amount, which is currently $580,000. This helps to reduce the financial burden on auto insurers and ensures that accident survivors continue to receive the care they need.

The MCCA plays a crucial role in Michigan's auto insurance system by providing financial stability to auto insurers and ensuring that accident survivors receive the necessary care and benefits. The changes to the MCCA fees and the introduction of refunds are part of Michigan's efforts to lower auto insurance costs for drivers while maintaining comprehensive coverage options.

Michigan is one of 12 no-fault states in the country

In a no-fault state, you normally seek compensation for damage by filing a claim directly with your insurance company. This is called a first-party claim. For example, collision damage to your car is paid by your insurance company. If you are less than 50% at fault, your deductible is waived. However, under the amended Michigan No-Fault Law, the other driver may be responsible for up to $3,000 in collision damages. This is referred to as a mini-tort claim.

Under the new law, your insurance company is still responsible for paying wage loss benefits for up to three years after the accident. Medical expenses are owed assuming you elected this coverage when purchasing your auto coverage. Before the change in the law, unlimited medical coverage was mandatory and covered all accident-related medical treatment. If you elected to waive medical coverage, the other driver may be responsible for paying these damages.

The Michigan No-Fault Insurance Law was designed to help people injured in car accidents. It ensures that victims get the help they need promptly and without regard to fault. The law was passed in 1973, and Michigan was previously a tort liability state.

Frequently asked questions