Homeowners Insurance: Who's Unprotected?

A surprising number of homeowners do not carry homeowners' insurance, despite the financial risks involved. In 2023, around 12% of homeowners were choosing not to carry insurance, a figure that has been rising in recent years. This equates to more than 6 million homeowners nationwide, or approximately 7.4% of all properties in the country. The decision to go without insurance is particularly common among lower-income homeowners, with nearly half of those without insurance making less than $40,000 per year. Certain demographics are also disproportionately affected, including Native American, Hispanic, and Black homeowners, as well as those in rural areas or specific metropolitan areas such as Houston and Miami.

12% of homeowners are choosing not to carry insurance

Homeowners insurance is an important safety net that protects your financial situation and investment. It is a crucial form of protection for your home and assets in the event of damage or loss, which happens more often than one might think. While most lenders require buyers to purchase homeowners insurance to secure a mortgage, it is not always mandatory.

In recent years, an increasing number of homeowners have been choosing to go without insurance. According to a report by The Wall Street Journal, around 12% of homeowners are opting not to carry insurance. This percentage translates to about 6.1 million homeowners nationwide and puts $1.6 trillion in property value at risk.

The decision to forgo insurance is particularly common among certain demographics. The Consumer Federation of America's study found that 22% of Native American homeowners, 14% of Hispanic homeowners, and 11% of Black homeowners have no insurance. Additionally, 35% of owners of manufactured homes and 29% of homeowners who inherited their homes lack coverage. Income also plays a significant factor, with homeowners earning less than $50,000 per year being twice as likely to lack insurance.

The rising cost of insurance, especially in disaster-prone states, is a primary reason for this trend. With coverage becoming more expensive, many individuals are struggling to afford it and are forced to make difficult choices. As a result, they are left vulnerable to financial ruin in the event of natural disasters or significant damage to their homes.

The lack of insurance among a significant portion of homeowners has broader implications. It contributes to racial inequality and can widen the racial wealth gap, as insurance access disproportionately impacts minority communities. Additionally, it poses a potential threat to entire communities, as uninsured homes can hinder the recovery of the local economy after a disaster.

The decision to opt out of homeowners insurance can have far-reaching consequences, and it is essential to weigh the risks carefully. While it may provide temporary financial relief, the long-term costs of being uninsured can be devastating.

Homeowners earning $50,000 are twice as likely to lack insurance

A 2024 report by the Consumer Federation of America reveals that over six million homeowners in the United States lack homeowners insurance. This equates to around 7.4% of all homeowners in the country, or one in thirteen. The report estimates that this lack of insurance leaves $1.6 trillion in property value unprotected.

The report also highlights disparities among different demographic groups. Homeowners earning under $50,000 per year are twice as likely to lack insurance compared to homeowners in general. Among lower-income homeowners, 15% are without coverage. This vulnerability is compounded by the fact that these homeowners often live in older structures with outdated infrastructure, which can be more costly to fix.

Other at-risk groups include Native American, Hispanic, and Black homeowners, who are disproportionately affected by a lack of insurance. 22% of Native American homeowners, 14% of Hispanic homeowners, and 11% of Black homeowners have no insurance. Additionally, 35% of owners of manufactured homes and 29% of homeowners who inherited their homes are also uninsured.

The report warns that the problem of uninsured homes is likely to worsen in the coming years without significant investments in climate change adaptation and stronger oversight of the insurance industry. It calls for state insurance regulators to collect more data to track homeowners insurance gaps and address inequalities in insurance markets.

35% of owners of manufactured homes lack coverage

In the United States, 35% of owners of manufactured homes lack home insurance coverage. This is a pressing issue, as manufactured homes are the largest source of unsubsidized affordable housing in the country, with 22 million people living in these units.

Manufactured homes, commonly known as mobile homes, are often treated as movable personal property or automobiles rather than real estate. This means that they are usually financed using personal property loans with higher interest rates and shorter repayment terms than mortgages. As a result, owners of manufactured homes tend to be older, lower-income, and more financially vulnerable than owners of site-built homes.

The lack of insurance coverage among owners of manufactured homes puts them at significant risk in the event of natural disasters or other significant damage to their homes. It also contributes to racial inequality, as Hispanic, Black, and Native American homeowners are more likely to be uninsured.

To address this issue, lawmakers can work to improve consumer protections and access to traditional financing for manufactured homes. This includes ensuring that these homes are treated as real estate rather than personal property and that owners have access to the same legal safeguards as mortgage borrowers, such as robust protections against foreclosure and eviction in the event of default.

29% of those who inherited their homes don't have insurance

Homeowners' insurance is one of the most sought-after insurance policies, and for good reason. It financially protects your home and assets in the event of damage or loss, which happens more often than you may think. While most US homeowners have home insurance, a significant number do not. This puts them at extreme risk in the event of natural disasters or other significant damage to their homes.

Homeowners' Insurance in the US

According to various sources, between 93% and 95% of US homeowners have some form of homeowners' insurance. This means that around 5% of homeowners in America, or more than 6 million homeowners, do not carry homeowners' insurance. This figure equates to about 7.4% of all properties in the country, leaving $1.6 trillion in property value unprotected.

There are several reasons why some homeowners may not have insurance. One reason could be the cost. Homeowners' insurance can be expensive, and some people may struggle to afford the premiums, especially those with lower incomes. In fact, homeowners earning less than $50,000 per year are twice as likely to lack insurance compared to homeowners in general, and among lower-income homeowners, 15% are without coverage.

Another reason could be that they don't understand the importance of having insurance. A Forbes Advisor survey of 2,000 homeowners found that most don't know how home insurance works, even though many said they were paying more for it than the previous year. This lack of understanding could lead some people to believe that they don't need insurance or that they are already covered by their existing policies.

Additionally, certain demographics of homeowners are disproportionately at risk of being uninsured. For example, 22% of Native American homeowners, 14% of Hispanic homeowners, and 11% of Black homeowners have no insurance. This disparity contributes to racial inequality and is likely to widen the long-standing racial wealth gap.

Inherited Homes and Insurance

Of particular relevance to this topic is the fact that 29% of homeowners who inherited their homes lack coverage. When a house is inherited, the deceased homeowner's policy does not automatically transfer to the new owner. As a result, the new owner must obtain their own policy. However, they may not qualify for a traditional policy if they do not plan to move into the home, as homeowner's insurance is typically only provided for homes that are the primary residence of the policyholder.

In such cases, alternative insurance options may be available, such as unoccupied property policies, landlord insurance (if the home is to be rented out), or second home insurance. However, these types of policies can be more expensive than standard homeowner's insurance due to the increased risks associated with vacant properties.

Rural homeowners are most likely to not have insurance

According to one source, around 5% of homeowners in America don't have home insurance. However, it is unclear whether this figure includes rural homeowners.

High Costs

Home insurance is often more expensive in rural areas than in urban or suburban areas. This is because rural homes tend to be located farther away from emergency services, such as fire stations and fire hydrants. Insurance companies use a classification system, typically called an ISO rating, to assess the risk associated with a property's distance from these emergency services. A higher ISO rating indicates increased risk, which leads to higher insurance premiums.

Unique Property Features

Rural properties often have larger plots of land and unique features such as silos, sheds, barns, gazebos, and outbuildings. These additional structures may not be adequately covered by standard home insurance policies, which typically have limited coverage for structures that are not attached to the main house. Rural homeowners may need to purchase additional coverage or endorsements to ensure these features are protected.

Business Use of Property

Conducting any business on the rural property, such as operating a hobby farm or a company, can result in higher insurance rates or even nullify the possibility of obtaining a policy. Special endorsements may be required to cover customers' liability or the business use of buildings and equipment.

Age of Home and Buildings

Older homes and buildings are more likely to have issues that could lead to insurance claims. Outdated roofing, HVAC systems, and electrical wiring are considered red flags by insurance providers and can lead to higher premiums or difficulties in obtaining coverage.

Distance from Fire Protection

In addition to the distance from fire stations and fire hydrants, other factors such as brush fire zones, tree mitigation, and propane heat sources can further increase the fire risk associated with rural properties. Insurance companies may view these properties as less favorable for insurance and impose surcharges or higher premiums.

Difficulty in Finding Carriers

The unique characteristics and challenges of insuring rural properties can make it difficult for homeowners to find insurance carriers willing to provide coverage. Rural residents may need to work with broker agents who have access to multiple carriers to find suitable insurance options.

In summary, rural homeowners may face challenges in obtaining insurance due to the high costs, unique property features, business use, older structures, increased fire risk, and the difficulty of finding carriers willing to provide coverage. These factors contribute to the likelihood of rural homeowners not having sufficient insurance coverage for their properties.

Frequently asked questions