Exploring Universal Healthcare And Private Insurance Globally

Universal healthcare is a system where all citizens have access to a full range of quality health services without financial hardship. While many countries have universal healthcare, some also have private insurance options. For example, Canada's universal healthcare system, Canadian Medicare, covers approximately 70% of Canadians' healthcare needs, while the remaining 30% is paid for through the private sector. Similarly, Australia's Medicare system, established in 1984, coexists with a private health system. In countries with universal healthcare, private insurance often acts as a supplement, covering treatments, prescriptions, and other forms of healthcare not covered under the universal policy.

Countries with universal healthcare and private insurance

Universal healthcare is a system where all citizens are provided with access to essential health services without financial hardship. While the specifics of universal healthcare vary from country to country, it generally covers a range of health services, from health promotion to prevention, treatment, rehabilitation, and palliative care. Many countries with universal healthcare also allow their citizens to opt for private insurance to cover additional health costs not included in their universal healthcare plans. Here are some examples of countries that offer universal healthcare and allow private insurance:

Canada

Canada's universal healthcare system, Canadian Medicare, provides coverage for approximately 70% of Canadians' healthcare needs. The remaining 30% is paid for through the private sector, which typically includes services not covered or only partially covered by Medicare, such as prescription drugs, eye care, medical devices, gender care, psychotherapy, physical therapy, and dentistry. About 65-75% of Canadians have some form of supplementary health insurance, often provided by their employers or through secondary social service programs for vulnerable demographics.

Australia

Australia's universal healthcare system, Medicare, provides free public hospital care and subsidized private care. Australian citizens and permanent residents are covered by Medicare, which also extends restricted access to citizens of certain other countries through formal agreements. Private health insurance in Australia acts as a supplement to universal healthcare, covering costs for vision care, dental, hospital accommodation, surgery fees, and more.

New Zealand

New Zealand's universal healthcare system treats all citizens and permanent residents in public hospitals for free. The government also provides subsidies for healthcare costs, with the cost of visiting a GP ranging from government-paid to $45 for children and $75 for adults. New Zealand also has a separate Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme, where the government subsidizes certain pharmaceuticals. Private health insurance is available for those who can afford it, covering additional costs not included in the universal plan.

Singapore

Singapore has a universal healthcare system where the government ensures affordability through compulsory savings and price controls. The private sector provides most care, and many Singaporeans have supplemental private health insurance, often provided by their employers, for services not covered by the government.

Other Countries

Other countries that offer universal healthcare and allow private insurance include Chile, Costa Rica, and the United Arab Emirates. While these countries have different approaches to their universal healthcare systems, they generally follow the model of providing essential health services to all citizens while allowing private insurance to cover additional or supplementary costs.

How does universal healthcare work?

Universal health coverage (UHC) means that all people have access to a full range of quality health services, from health promotion to prevention, treatment, rehabilitation, and palliative care across their life course. It should be provided when and where they need it, without financial hardship.

UHC is based on the 1948 WHO Constitution, which declares health a fundamental human right. The WHO recommends reorienting health systems using a primary health care (PHC) approach, which is the most effective and cost-efficient way to deliver UHC.

Each country has a unique path to achieving UHC, and the specific services covered are based on the needs of their populations and the resources available. For example, in Australia, the universal public health insurance program, Medicare, provides free public hospital care and subsidised private care. In contrast, China achieved UHC through three public insurance programs: Urban Employee Basic Medical Insurance, the Newly Cooperative Medical Scheme, and the Urban Resident Basic Medical Insurance.

Some countries, such as Australia, New Zealand, and Canada, have single-payer systems, while others, like China and Germany, have multiple payers. In some countries with single-payer systems, private insurance is allowed for faster access or additional services.

While the specific mechanisms for achieving UHC vary, the common goal is to ensure that all people have access to the health services they need without financial barriers.

Countries with single-payer healthcare

Single-payer healthcare systems are government-funded and available to all citizens, regardless of their income or employment status. Some countries may also provide healthcare to non-citizen residents, while others require them to purchase private insurance.

Canada's single-payer healthcare system, Canadian Medicare, was established through federal legislation in 1957 and 1966, and was consolidated in 1984. It provides universal, publicly funded healthcare to all Canadians, covering approximately 70% of healthcare needs. The remaining 30% is paid for through the private sector, which typically relates to services not covered or only partially covered by Medicare, such as prescription drugs, eye care, and dentistry.

Australia's universal public health insurance program, Medicare, was established in 1984 and provides free public hospital care and subsidised private care. Medicare is funded by a 1.5% income tax levy, with exceptions for low-income earners, and an additional 1% levy on high-income earners without private health insurance. Private health insurance in Australia acts as a supplement to universal healthcare coverage, covering costs such as vision and dental care, hospital accommodation, and surgery fees.

New Zealand's single-payer system also coexists with a private health system. Hospitals are public and treat citizens or permanent residents, with fees paid by the government. The cost of visiting a GP ranges from government-paid to $45 for children and from government-paid to $75 for adults under the current subsidies. This system is funded by taxes.

Taiwan's single-payer system, National Health Insurance (NHI), is a compulsory social insurance plan that centralises the disbursement of healthcare funds. NHI is mainly financed through premiums based on payroll tax and supplemented with out-of-pocket payments and direct government funding. The population coverage of NHI reached 99% by the end of 2004.

Singapore's single-payer system ensures affordability through compulsory savings and price controls, while the private sector provides most care. Singapore's medical savings account system is known as MediSave.

Countries with multi-tiered healthcare systems

Many countries have multi-tiered healthcare systems, with different ways of financing healthcare for different people and purposes. Here are some examples:

Australia

Australia's Medicare system, established in 1984, provides universal public health insurance. It offers free public hospital care and subsidised private care. Australian citizens, permanent residents, and New Zealand citizens can enrol in the programme. Restricted access is provided to citizens of certain other countries through formal agreements. Other visitors and undocumented immigrants are treated as private-pay patients.

Private health insurance is also available in Australia, which can be used to cover the costs of gaps in universal healthcare coverage, such as vision care, dental costs, hospital accommodation, and surgery fees.

Canada

Canada's universal healthcare system, established in 1966, is publicly funded and guided by the provisions of the Canada Health Act of 1984. Canadian Medicare provides coverage for approximately 70% of Canadians' healthcare needs, with the remaining 30% paid for through the private sector. This typically relates to services not covered or only partially covered by Medicare, such as prescription drugs, eye care, and dentistry. About 65-75% of Canadians have some form of supplementary health insurance, often provided by their employers.

Germany

Germany has a universal multi-payer system with two main types of health insurance: public and private. All German residents must have health insurance. Those who make below a certain income must use public health insurance, while private health insurance is only available to freelancers, high earners, and certain other categories. Employers pay for half of their employees' health insurance contributions, while the self-employed must pay the full contribution themselves.

Singapore

Singapore has a universal healthcare system where the government ensures affordability, largely through compulsory savings and price controls, while the private sector provides most care. Overall spending on healthcare amounts to only 3% of annual GDP, with 66% coming from private sources. Many Singaporeans also have supplemental private health insurance, often provided by their employers, for services not covered by the government's programmes.

Countries with public-private insurance systems

Many countries have a public-private insurance system, where the government provides a basic level of universal healthcare, and private insurance companies offer additional coverage.

In some countries, like Germany, the government mandates that all citizens have health insurance, and citizens can choose between public and private insurance providers. In Germany, the majority of citizens choose to be covered by one of the 110 nonprofit public insurance providers, known as "sickness funds". However, citizens can opt-out of this system and instead choose private coverage from for-profit or nonprofit carriers.

In other countries, like Canada, the government provides universal healthcare, but many citizens also have private insurance to cover services not included in the public plan, like prescription drugs, eye care, and dentistry.

In the Netherlands, citizens are legally required to buy private insurance or pay a fine. However, children under 18 are insured by the government, and special assistance is available for those with limited incomes.

In Switzerland, citizens are also legally required to buy private insurance, but the government provides subsidies for low-income households.

In Australia, the government provides universal healthcare, but the government has also introduced financial incentives for adults to purchase private hospital insurance, and about half of Australians have done so.

Frequently asked questions