Auto Insurance: Provincial Government Plans And You

Auto insurance is mandatory for all drivers in Canada, but the way it's managed differs between provinces. Four of Canada's ten provinces have some form of public insurance. In British Columbia, Manitoba, and Saskatchewan, all of the mandatory coverage can be purchased from a single regulatory body. In Quebec, the system is hybrid: drivers must buy their personal injury benefits plan from a public provider, but they get their property damage coverage from private insurers.

British Columbia, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba have government auto insurance

In Canada, auto insurance is mandatory for all drivers, and the industry is closely monitored by the provincial government. However, the differences across provinces can be stark.

There are several benefits to public auto insurance. Firstly, it is based on the principle that if the government compels motorists to purchase auto insurance, then the government should ensure motorists pay fair premiums and receive high-quality coverage. Secondly, public auto insurers in Canada have historically operated on a not-for-profit basis, with the exception of the Insurance Corporation of British Columbia (ICBC). This means that public insurance providers do not have the same profit pressures as private companies and are therefore more likely to have low premiums and be able to fully compensate claimants.

However, it is important to note that even in provinces with public auto insurance, private insurance companies still have a role. Drivers can choose to purchase additional coverage from private insurers, which may offer more competitive pricing or more expansive service.

Quebec has a hybrid system

Quebec has a hybrid auto insurance system, a combination of public and private insurance components. This means that Quebecers receive some coverage from the Société de l'assurance automobile du Québec (SAAQ), but they also need to purchase additional coverage from other, private insurers.

The public insurance component is managed by the SAAQ and covers personal injury resulting from automobile accidents. This means that if you are injured in a car accident, your medical expenses, rehabilitation costs, and income replacement benefits are covered by the insurer. The public insurance plan also covers tourists in Quebec on the basis of their share of responsibility in the accident.

The private insurance component, on the other hand, covers property damage and liability. This includes damage to your own vehicle, damage to other people's property, and liability if you are responsible for causing injury or damage to others in an accident.

Quebec's hybrid system has resulted in lower auto insurance rates in the province compared to others. This is due to various factors, including lower mandatory coverage limits. For example, while drivers in Quebec only need to purchase a minimum of $50,000 in civil liability coverage, all other provinces require at least $200,000 for third-party liability claims.

The Quebec government also regulates auto insurance rates to ensure fairness and affordability for consumers. Insurers must submit rate proposals to regulatory authorities for approval, helping to prevent excessive rate increases. Additionally, Quebec operates under a no-fault auto insurance system, meaning that anyone injured in a motor vehicle accident in the province is covered by the SAAQ, regardless of who is at fault.

When registering a vehicle in Quebec, you automatically enrol in the public insurance plan, with registration fees including the premium for personal injury coverage. You must then purchase additional private insurance from a licensed company.

Private insurance is more expensive for high-risk drivers

In Canada, auto insurance is mandatory for all drivers, and the industry is closely monitored by the provincial government. There are two types of auto insurance: public and private. Newfoundland and Labrador, Nova Scotia, P.E.I., New Brunswick, Ontario, Alberta, and Quebec all have private insurance, while British Columbia, Manitoba, and Saskatchewan have public insurance.

Private insurance companies compete against each other for customers, allowing them to shop around and choose the company that best suits their needs in terms of coverages, customer service, and price. However, private insurance is more expensive for high-risk drivers.

High-risk drivers are those with a problematic driving record, such as multiple tickets or accidents, serious violations like a DUI or reckless driving, or a history of driving without insurance. Insurance companies see these drivers as more likely to file a claim, resulting in higher car insurance rates. High-risk drivers may also have fewer insurance company options and may have to shop in the non-standard market, which includes companies willing to take on the added risk of insuring high-risk drivers.

While private insurance can be more expensive for high-risk drivers, there are ways to reduce costs. High-risk drivers can compare quotes from standard and non-standard companies, enroll in a safe driving course, improve their credit score, or bundle their auto and homeowners insurance.

Public insurance is non-profit and has lower premiums

In Canada, auto insurance is mandatory for all drivers, and each province handles auto insurance differently. Some Canadian provinces have public auto insurance, which is a government-owned and operated system of compulsory automobile insurance. British Columbia, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, and Quebec are the provinces that use public auto insurance. In these provinces, the government determines the factors that insurers can and can't use when setting auto insurance rates.

Public auto insurance is based on the idea that if the government compels motorists to purchase auto insurance, it should also ensure that they pay fair premiums and receive high-quality coverage. One of the main arguments in favour of public insurance is that since it operates on a non-profit basis, it is more likely to have lower premiums than private insurance companies, which need to make profits for their owners.

Public auto insurers in Canada have historically operated on a not-for-profit basis, except for the Insurance Corporation of British Columbia (ICBC), which had its legislation amended in 2010 to pay dividends to the provincial treasury. Proponents of public insurance argue that since public insurers don't have to make profits, they can reinvest their extra revenue into lower premiums or more benefits for their members. This is in contrast to for-profit insurance companies, which distribute their surplus to shareholders.

While it is challenging to make accurate comparisons of premiums across Canada due to differing insurance models and mandated minimum levels of coverage, some studies have found that the four provinces with public auto insurance have lower insurance rates than those with private insurance systems. For example, a 2015 Deloitte analysis found that the four provinces with public provision had the cheapest insurance rates in the country.

In addition to potentially lower premiums, public auto insurance also offers other benefits. For instance, in British Columbia, ICBC not only provides auto insurance but also handles driver's licensing, registration, and other services. Similarly, in Manitoba, Manitoba Public Insurance (MPI) takes care of licensing, registration, and additional services. These integrated services can provide added convenience for motorists.

In summary, public auto insurance in Canada is provided by government-owned corporations in British Columbia, Manitoba, and Saskatchewan, while Quebec has a hybrid system with the government administering insurance for bodily injury and private insurers covering property damage. Public insurance operates on a non-profit basis, and proponents argue that this leads to lower premiums compared to private insurance companies, which need to generate profits. While empirical comparisons are challenging due to varying insurance models, some studies support the claim that public insurance provinces have lower insurance rates. Additionally, public auto insurance can offer integrated services and benefits beyond just auto insurance, providing added value to motorists.

Private insurance is competitive and may offer lower prices

Private insurance companies compete for customers' business, and as a customer, you can shop around and choose the one that best suits your needs. This means comparing coverages and customer service, as well as price.

Proponents of private insurance argue that an open and competitive market for auto insurance would force providers to be cost-efficient and compete on price, resulting in lower premiums. They also argue that competition will force private insurers to treat claimants as fairly as possible, since insured customers can simply change providers if they feel mistreated.

Private insurance offers more choice and value for consumers. For example, private insurers offer things that public insurers do not, like first-accident forgiveness and new vehicle replacement coverage.

However, it's important to note that the question of whether private or public insurance is more efficient remains an open one. While some studies have found that rates in provinces with private insurance are lower than in provinces with public insurance, others have found the opposite. Additionally, public insurance supporters argue that a non-profit entity, such as a government-run insurer, would be more likely to have low premiums since they do not have to make profits for owners.

Frequently asked questions