Insurance Appraisals: Higher Value, Why?

An insurance appraisal is a binding contractual process that can be invoked to resolve disputes between policyholders and insurance companies when they disagree on the amount of loss or the scope of damages. This typically occurs when the insurer offers a lower settlement than expected or determines a different scope of damages than what the insured anticipated. The appraisal process involves hiring an appraiser, which can be costly and may not always be worth it for smaller claims. The cost of an appraisal can vary depending on the property's condition and the complexity of the dispute, with commercial property insurance appraisals costing around $4,000 on average but potentially reaching $10,000 or more for intricate cases. The appraiser's fees must be paid regardless of the outcome, and they are required to be impartial, which means they do not act in the best interests of either party. The process can be advantageous for policyholders with complex valuation arguments as it may result in higher payouts, especially if the arguments are challenging for a judge or jury to understand without an accounting background.

The appraisal process is initiated to resolve a dispute between the insurer and insured

The insurance appraisal process is a binding contractual process that can be initiated to resolve a dispute between the insurer and the insured when they disagree on the amount of loss or the scope of damages. This process is often faster and more cost-effective than litigation, but it can still be costly, with commercial property insurance appraisals costing around $4,000 on average and increasing to $10,000 or more for complex disputes. The appraisal process typically involves three elements: a structured process for valuing an asset from multiple perspectives, a trained and certified assessor, and a set of professional methods and standards to produce an accurate valuation.

When the insurer and insured cannot agree on the value of a claim, either party can invoke the appraisal clause in their insurance policy to initiate the process. The appraisal clause allows both the insurer and the insured to hire their own appraiser, who should be competent, disinterested, and impartial. The appraisers will then work together to select an umpire, who will render a binding decision if the appraisers cannot agree on the value of the property or the amount of loss. The selection of a qualified and impartial umpire is critical to the success of the appraisal process.

It is important to note that the insurance company may still attempt to deny, delay, or underpay valid claims, and they often retain the right to deny the claim even after an appraisal award has been determined. Additionally, appraisal does not address coverage issues and is only applicable when the parties agree on the scope of coverage but disagree on the amount of loss. Before initiating an appraisal, it is recommended to seek legal counsel with experience in the insurance appraisal process to determine if it is in the best interest of the policyholder.

While the appraisal process can be beneficial for resolving disputes, it may not always be the best option. For smaller disputed claims, the cost of the appraisal may outweigh the potential benefit. Furthermore, finding impartial appraisers and umpires can be challenging, and there is a risk of an inadequate investigation if the appraiser is unqualified or unfamiliar with the specific dispute. Therefore, it is crucial to carefully consider the potential advantages and disadvantages before initiating the appraisal process to resolve a dispute between the insurer and the insured.

Appraisers are hired to determine the amount of loss, which can be costly

Appraisers are typically hired for larger dispute amounts. The more complex the appraisal, the higher the fees involved. Complex appraisals are also beneficial for appraisers as they can charge higher fees. This can lead to conflicts between the policyholder and the appraiser.

The cost of an appraisal can vary depending on the property's condition. Commercial property insurance appraisals can cost around $4,000, but this can increase to $10,000 or more for complex disputes. Therefore, it is important to consider the size difference between the estimates and the insurers. If the difference in value is small, an appraisal may not be worth the cost.

The appraisal process can be costly, and for smaller disputed claims, the outcome may not be worth the expense. Appraisers can be difficult to find as they often prefer working for insurers due to the likelihood of repeat business. This can be a disadvantage for policyholders as insurance companies have the right to deny the claim, even after an appraisal award has been determined.

In addition, appraisers are hired to be impartial and disinterested. They do not act in the best interests of either party and cannot help with coverage issues. They are there to determine the amount of loss only. This can be a disadvantage for the insured as they may feel they are not being advocated for.

The insurance company may deny the claim after an umpire's findings

An insurance appraisal is a method of alternative dispute resolution that can be invoked when a policyholder and an insurance company disagree on the amount of a claim payment. The appraisal clause allows the policyholder to hire an independent appraiser to determine the value of their damages, and the insurance company will also hire their own appraiser. The two appraisers will then select a third appraiser, or umpire, to act as an unbiased third party to resolve differences relating to the claim. The appraisers will review the claim, estimate the damage, and try to come to an agreement on the amount of loss. If they cannot agree, their different valuations are submitted to the umpire for the final determination.

The umpire's decision is binding on both the policyholder and the insurance company. However, it is important to note that the insurance company may still deny the claim after the umpire's findings. This is because the appraisal process only addresses the amount of loss and not coverage issues. While the appraisal decision is binding on the amount of damage, there can still be disputes about what is covered under the policy. These coverage issues can be pursued and litigated separately from the appraisal. Additionally, the insurance company may have other reasons for denying the claim that are unrelated to the appraisal or the umpire's findings.

Furthermore, the appraisal process can be costly and time-consuming for the policyholder. Appraisers typically charge higher fees for larger dispute amounts, and complex appraisals can cost upwards of $10,000 to complete. The process can also take months or even years to conclude, depending on the complexity of the case and the diligence of the appraisers and umpire. If the policyholder is unhappy with the outcome of the appraisal, they may have to incur additional expenses to challenge the decision or pursue legal action.

In summary, while the appraisal process and the umpire's findings are intended to resolve disputes between the policyholder and the insurance company, the insurance company may still deny the claim. This can occur due to separate coverage issues, additional factors unrelated to the appraisal, or the policyholder's dissatisfaction with the outcome. Therefore, it is essential for policyholders to carefully consider the potential costs and benefits of invoking the appraisal clause and to seek legal counsel if necessary to protect their rights and interests.

Appraisal clauses are not always included in insurance policies

The appraisal process is a non-judicial method of settling disputes. It involves each party selecting an appraiser to value the asset in question. These appraisers should be competent, disinterested, and impartial. The appraisers then work together to select an umpire, who is also impartial, to render a binding decision in the event that the appraisers cannot agree on the value of the property or the amount of loss. The cost of the appraiser is borne by each party, while the umpire's cost is split equally.

While the appraisal process can be beneficial for settling disputes, it is important to note that it is not always the best option for policyholders. It can be costly, time-consuming, and there is no guarantee that the outcome will be favourable. In some cases, the insurance company may still deny, delay, or underpay valid claims even after an appraisal award has been determined.

Furthermore, finding impartial appraisers and umpires can be challenging. Experienced appraisers who are willing to work for policyholders are less common than those who work for insurance carriers. This can lead to an inadequate investigation that disadvantages the policyholder.

Therefore, it is essential for policyholders to carefully consider their options before invoking an appraisal clause. While it can be an effective way to resolve disputes, it is not always included in insurance policies, and there may be other methods of settlement that are more advantageous for the insured.

The process is generally faster and less expensive than litigation

When a dispute arises between an insurer and a policyholder, the process of invoking an appraisal clause is generally faster and less expensive than litigation. This is because the appraisal process is relatively straightforward and structured, and it does not involve the same level of legal complexity and adversarial nature as litigation.

The appraisal process typically involves the following steps: firstly, both parties—the insurer and the policyholder—will each hire their own appraiser. These appraisers are trained and certified professionals who are familiar with the asset and the market in which it will be valued. The appraisers will then work together to select an impartial umpire, such as a retired judge or an engineer, who will render a binding decision in case of disagreement between the appraisers. The appraisers will assess the asset's value from multiple perspectives, taking into account factors such as property value, market value, and potential future earnings.

The cost of an insurance appraisal can vary depending on the complexity of the dispute and the condition of the property. On average, a commercial property insurance appraisal can cost around $4,000, but this can increase to $10,000 or more for more complex cases. While this may seem like a significant expense, it is important to note that litigation can often be even more costly and time-consuming. Litigation involves legal fees, court costs, and the potential for prolonged proceedings, all of which can add up financially.

Additionally, the appraisal process can be faster than litigation as it does not require the same level of discovery and evidence gathering. Appraisers are able to quickly assess the asset and provide a valuation, whereas litigation may involve months of fact-finding and expert testimony. Furthermore, the appraisal process is often less adversarial, as it is a non-judicial process that focuses on resolving the dispute without resorting to litigation.

However, it is important to note that there are also potential disadvantages to the appraisal process. For example, finding impartial and qualified appraisers and umpires can be challenging, and there is no guarantee that the policyholder will receive a higher valuation through the appraisal process. Nonetheless, for policyholders who are facing a dispute with their insurance company, invoking an appraisal clause can be a faster and more cost-effective option than litigation.

Frequently asked questions