Auto Insurance Rates Rising In Michigan: Why?

Michigan's auto insurance rates are notoriously high, with drivers paying up to 270% more than the national average. While there was a brief decrease in 2021, rates are once again on the rise, and there are several factors contributing to this increase. One of the main reasons is the state's costly no-fault law, which includes high Personal Injury Protection (PIP) payouts. In addition, Michigan has a high percentage of uninsured drivers, frequent car thefts, and severe winter weather, all of which contribute to higher insurance rates.

Michigan's No-Fault Insurance Law

The law was modified in 2019 to give drivers more options for Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage levels, ranging from $50,000 for Medicaid recipients to unlimited coverage. Previously, drivers were required to purchase "unlimited" PIP coverage, which contributed to higher insurance premiums. However, opting for lower coverage limits comes with its own risks, especially with rising medical costs.

Additionally, Michigan has a high percentage of uninsured drivers, estimated at around 25%. This uninsured population impacts insurance rates for those who are insured, as insurers must shift costs to maintain profitability. The state's high insurance rates can also contribute to more drivers forgoing insurance, creating a vicious cycle.

While the 2019 changes to the No-Fault Insurance Law helped reduce insurance rates initially, other factors, such as car thefts, repair costs, and proposed legislative changes, could lead to future rate increases for Michigan drivers.

High number of car-deer collisions

Michigan has a high number of car-deer collisions, with around 50,000 accidents between cars and deer occurring annually. In 2023, this number rose to 58,806, accounting for a little over 20% of all car accidents in the state.

Michigan is ranked in the top four states in the country for car-deer collisions, with Oakland County being the second-highest county in the state for such accidents.

Most of these incidents do not result in human casualties, but they do lead to extensive vehicle damage, which insurance companies have to cover. The cost of these repairs, or the cost of replacing vehicles that have been totalled, is then passed on to policyholders in the form of higher premiums.

Deer are most active from April to June and from October to December, with 80% of deer-related accidents occurring during the latter two months. Most accidents take place at dawn and dusk, between 5 am and 8 am, and 5 pm and 10 pm.

To avoid collisions, drivers are advised to stay alert, drive at safe speeds, and be prepared for deer to dash out in front of them.

High percentage of uninsured drivers

Michigan has a high percentage of uninsured drivers, with almost 26% of drivers lacking auto insurance. This is nearly 13% higher than the national average. In some cities, like Detroit, it is estimated that over half of all drivers are driving without auto insurance.

When uninsured drivers get into an accident, the other party's insurance provider covers the property damage and medical expenses through uninsured motorist insurance. A high rate of uninsured drivers forces insurers to shift the cost to those with insurance to compensate for potential losses. This results in higher insurance premiums for those with coverage.

The high percentage of uninsured drivers in Michigan is one of the main factors contributing to the state's high insurance costs. The state's no-fault status, additional insurance requirements, rate of insurance fraud, claims processing practices, and personal injury lawsuits are also factors in the high insurance premiums.

To address the issue of uninsured drivers, Michigan implemented an auto insurance reform law in 2019. This law included new low-cost options, rate reductions, an amnesty period for uninsured drivers, and the elimination of certain non-driving factors from the rating process. As a result, Michigan experienced the largest decrease in uninsured motorists in the nation, with a 6.2% drop between 2020 and 2022.

Severe winter weather

Michigan's auto insurance rates are affected by several factors, one of which is the state's severe winter weather. The state was named the worst for winter driving conditions in 2023, with lake-effect snow, poorly maintained roads, black ice, and unsafe drivers contributing to hazardous conditions. These factors result in a high number of accidents and insurance claims, impacting insurance rates.

During the 2021-2022 winter season, there were 35,782 winter-weather crashes in Michigan, including 78 fatal crashes. The state experiences icy, snowy, and slushy road conditions during winter, significantly increasing the risk of accidents.

Winter weather in Michigan can be extremely dangerous, with high winds, freezing rain, heavy snowfall, and cold temperatures. These conditions can lead to travel difficulties, power outages, and health risks, especially for those living in poorly insulated homes or stranded outdoors. The wind chill, in particular, can accelerate heat loss from the body, leading to dangerous drops in body temperature.

To improve safety during winter, the Michigan State Police promote the "Drive Slow on Ice & Snow" campaign, encouraging drivers to take responsibility for their safety and that of others. Slowing down is crucial on icy and snowy roads, as it can take up to ten times longer to stop a vehicle. Additionally, drivers are advised to keep a safe distance from other vehicles, reduce distractions, and watch out for black ice.

Winter driving techniques, such as smooth acceleration and braking, can help prevent skidding. If a skid occurs, it's important to steer in the direction the rear of the car is sliding. Vehicles with front-wheel drive, all-wheel drive, or four-wheel drive may give a false sense of security, as they still face the same challenges as rear-wheel-drive vehicles when it comes to stopping and turning on wintry roads.

Preparing your vehicle for winter and carrying emergency supplies are also essential for safe winter driving. Maintaining your car, clearing snow and ice, and stocking it with necessary supplies are recommended. Additionally, choosing the right tires for winter conditions and ensuring proper tire maintenance are vital, as tires are the only points of contact between your vehicle and the road.

In conclusion, Michigan's severe winter weather significantly impacts auto insurance rates due to the increased number of accidents and insurance claims during this season. By driving cautiously and preparing their vehicles, Michiganders can enhance their safety on the road during the challenging winter months.

Inflation

In addition to inflation, there are other factors contributing to the rise in auto insurance rates in Michigan. One significant factor is the changes to the state's no-fault insurance rules. In 2019, Michigan amended its no-fault insurance laws, allowing drivers to opt for limited personal injury protection (PIP) coverage instead of unlimited coverage. While this change provided drivers with more affordable options, it also reduced the overall claims liability for insurers. As a result, insurance companies were able to offer cheaper premiums, which led to a decrease in average full-coverage insurance premiums in Michigan. However, this reform may be short-lived as there is a pending bill in the state legislature that aims to increase reimbursement rates for medical care following auto insurance claims. If this bill becomes law, it is expected to lead to higher auto insurance premiums for Michigan drivers.

Furthermore, Michigan has a high rate of car theft, ranking first in the country for automobile theft in 2022. The increase in car thefts translates to a higher risk of claims payouts for insurers, which may result in higher premiums for policyholders. Additionally, Michigan's severe winter weather conditions contribute to a higher number of accidents, leading to increased insurance claims and subsequent rate increases.

In summary, while inflation plays a significant role in the rising auto insurance rates in Michigan, other factors such as changes to no-fault insurance laws, high car theft rates, and severe winter weather also contribute to the increasing cost of auto insurance in the state.

Frequently asked questions