Auto Repair Shop Mishaps: Insurance Coverage For Damage

When it comes to auto insurance coverage for damage from a repair shop, the answer depends on several factors, including the type of insurance policy held by the repair shop and the nature of the damage. Repair shops typically have insurance coverage for their own negligence, such as accidents during test drives or accidental damage while working on a vehicle. This coverage is provided by a basic liability policy or Garagekeepers insurance, which comes in three types: Legal Liability, Direct Excess, and Direct Primary. Legal Liability covers losses due to the repair shop's negligence, such as leaving windows open or keys in the ignition. Direct Excess includes Legal Liability coverage and also covers losses in excess of the customer's own insurance coverage. Direct Primary is the most comprehensive, covering damage regardless of the shop's liability or the customer's insurance coverage. It's important to inquire about the repair shop's insurance coverage before entrusting them with your vehicle.

Additionally, your own auto insurance policy may provide coverage for damage caused by a repair shop. Comprehensive and collision coverage can protect against various types of damage, including accidents, vandalism, theft, and natural disasters. However, standard policies typically exclude repairs for routine wear and tear or mechanical breakdowns. To include these, you may need to purchase additional coverage, such as mechanical breakdown insurance (MBI) or extended warranties. MBI covers repairs for mechanical issues outside of the vehicle's original warranty and can save you from significant out-of-pocket expenses.

Comprehensive insurance covers theft, fire, and vandalism

Comprehensive insurance is an optional coverage that protects your vehicle from damage caused by incidents outside of your control. This includes theft, fire, and vandalism, as well as other acts of nature, such as severe weather, and accidents with animals. It is often confused with collision coverage, which protects your vehicle in the event of a collision with another vehicle or object, regardless of fault.

Comprehensive insurance is ideal for those seeking extra protection for their vehicle. It is the highest level of insurance you can buy and covers damage sustained from both collision and non-collision accidents. It also protects you in the event of personal injury. This type of insurance is particularly suitable for experienced drivers or those with newer, more valuable vehicles.

While comprehensive insurance is not required by law in any state, lenders may require it if you are leasing or financing your vehicle. If you own your vehicle outright, the decision to purchase comprehensive insurance depends on your financial circumstances and the value of your car. It may be a worthwhile investment if your vehicle has a high cash value or if you cannot afford repairs or a replacement out of pocket.

Comprehensive insurance provides peace of mind, ensuring you are covered for unexpected events. It is important to note that standard comprehensive insurance does not cover everything. For example, it does not include negligence, driving with an invalid license, or normal wear and tear. Additionally, it does not cover personal belongings in your vehicle, which are typically covered by homeowners or renters insurance.

Collision coverage protects against single-vehicle accidents and hitting objects

Collision coverage is a type of auto insurance that covers the cost of repairs to your vehicle if it is damaged in an accident involving another vehicle or object. It is important to note that collision coverage only applies to damages to your vehicle and not to any other vehicles or objects involved in the accident. Additionally, it does not cover bodily injuries sustained in the accident. However, collision coverage can be extremely useful in the event of a single-vehicle accident or if you hit an object, such as a tree or fence.

In a single-vehicle accident, such as rolling over or colliding with an object, collision coverage will cover the cost of repairs to your vehicle. This ensures that you are not left financially responsible for the repairs, which can often be costly. For example, if you accidentally hit a tree or a lamppost, collision coverage will help pay for the repairs to your vehicle. This type of coverage is especially valuable if you are leasing or financing your vehicle, as it can protect your investment.

Collision coverage is also beneficial if you are involved in an at-fault accident, where you are considered responsible for the collision. In this case, collision coverage will cover the cost of repairs to your vehicle, minus your deductible. For instance, if you accidentally rear-end another car, collision coverage will help cover the cost of repairs to your vehicle, even though you are at fault. This can provide significant financial relief and help you get back on the road sooner.

Additionally, collision coverage can be useful in not-at-fault accidents, where another driver is responsible for the collision. In these cases, you may choose to use your collision coverage for repairs, especially if the other driver's insurance provider is still investigating the claim or if they do not have the appropriate liability coverage. This allows you to start the repair process quickly and avoid delays.

It is worth noting that collision coverage is not required by state law, but it is often a smart investment, especially if you drive frequently or in areas with high-volume traffic. While it may not be necessary for older vehicles that are fully paid off, it is crucial for newer vehicles or those that are leased or financed. By having collision coverage, you can have peace of mind knowing that you are protected in the event of an accident, regardless of who is at fault.

Auto insurance companies cannot force customers to use a specific repair shop

Your insurance company might offer a lifetime guarantee on work done by one of its recommended shops, but you are still free to pick any repair shop you like and get your own repair estimate. It is worth noting that some auto insurance companies let policyholders choose between generic (aftermarket) and OEM (original equipment manufacturer) parts for repairs. Some policies dictate that only OEM parts can be used for auto repairs.

If you don't already use a trusted repair shop, it is a good idea to read online reviews, seek recommendations from friends and relatives, compare repair costs quoted by several shops, and pick a shop whose automotive professionals are certified by the National Institute for Automotive Service Excellence.

Additionally, it is important to remember that your insurer might put some restrictions on your car repairs. For example, they can require you to obtain more than one repair estimate if they think the initial estimate is too high. The insurance company will then compare all your repair estimates with the estimate developed by their insurance adjuster. You don't have to accept the adjuster's estimate unless you are satisfied that it would cover the repair costs. You may even be able to negotiate a higher estimate. However, be prepared for your insurer to pick the lowest estimate to avoid paying a "grossly inflated" repair bill.

Customers can choose between generic and OEM parts for repairs

When it comes to repairing a car, customers have the option to choose between generic (aftermarket) and OEM (original equipment manufacturer) parts. This choice can impact the quality, price, and performance of the repaired vehicle. OEM parts are made by the vehicle manufacturer or an external company following the manufacturer's specifications. They are typically supplied in plain packaging and are identical to genuine parts, often at a better price. On the other hand, aftermarket parts are produced by any other company and can vary widely in quality and price. While some aftermarket suppliers produce more durable parts, others focus solely on direct replacement.

When deciding between generic and OEM parts, it's important to consider the specific vehicle and repair needs. For example, if you're looking for a more affordable option and don't mind potential variations in quality, aftermarket parts may be a suitable choice. On the other hand, if you want parts that are guaranteed to match the original specifications, OEM parts might be preferable.

It's worth noting that some auto insurance policies dictate the use of OEM parts for repairs, while others allow policyholders to choose between generic and OEM parts. Understanding your insurance coverage and repair options is essential to making informed decisions about your vehicle repairs. Additionally, customers have the right to choose their preferred auto repair shop, although insurance companies may offer recommendations or restrictions.

In terms of insurance coverage, standard policies typically cover specific types of repairs, such as those resulting from accidents, acts of vandalism, or severe weather. Comprehensive and collision coverage can provide additional protection for various types of damage, including vandalism, theft, natural disasters, and collisions. Mechanical breakdown insurance (MBI) is also available from some providers, covering repairs for engine breakdowns and other essential parts. When considering insurance coverage, it's important to review the specific details of your policy to understand what types of repairs are included.

Auto insurance does not cover normal wear and tear

Auto insurance is designed to cover unexpected costs, such as accidents, acts of vandalism, or severe weather events. It does not cover normal wear and tear, which is a predictable and expected cost of owning a vehicle. Wear and tear is generally defined as the deterioration of a vehicle and its parts due to regular use over time. This includes items such as brake pad replacement, timing belt replacements, and tire replacement, as well as rust damage, interior damage, worn-down mechanical parts, and problems with electronics.

Most car insurance policies explicitly exclude coverage for wear and tear through a "wear and tear exclusion" clause. This provision states that the ordinary deterioration of a vehicle is expected and not covered by the insurance policy. This exclusion allows insurance companies to deny claims related to wear and tear.

The rationale behind excluding wear and tear from coverage is that if insurance policies covered these predictable costs, insurance prices would be significantly higher for everyone. By excluding wear and tear, insurance companies can keep premiums lower for all customers.

While standard auto insurance does not cover wear and tear, some companies offer additional coverage options, such as mechanical breakdown insurance (MBI), which can provide protection for certain repairs related to mechanical breakdowns. MBI is similar to an extended car warranty and covers repairs to key engine components and other essential parts in the event of a breakdown. However, MBI does not cover the replacement of wear-and-tear items like brake pads, spark plugs, filters, or tires.

Frequently asked questions