Understanding Life Insurance Agents: Are They Fiduciaries?

Life insurance agents are not always considered fiduciaries. Fiduciary duty requires that a representative in a position of trust must act in good faith and honesty on behalf of a client, and put their interests ahead of their own. In the US, insurance agents are only required to obtain the insurance that the customer requested within a reasonable time. However, a special relationship can be established between an agent and a customer, which expands the agent's duty to the customer and requires them to offer advice regarding the insurance necessary to fulfil the customer's needs. This can occur when the agent misrepresents the nature of the coverage, voluntarily assumes the role of selecting coverage for the customer, or offers advice related to the type of coverage available.

Insurance brokers, on the other hand, are representatives of the consumer and typically owe a higher level of fiduciary duty than agents. They work directly for the client and are required to act in their best interests.

Fiduciary duty lawsuits: agents vs brokers

The classification of an insurance professional as an agent or broker is pivotal in fiduciary duty lawsuits. While the terms are often used interchangeably, they carry significant weight in the context of legal proceedings.

Agents

Insurance agents are employees and representatives of an insurance company. They assist customers with policies and claims involving their employer and, as such, their fiduciary duties typically default to the insurer. According to Professor Peter Kochenburger of the University of Connecticut's Insurance Law Center, an agent, whether independent or captive, primarily represents the insurance company they work for. In a fiduciary duty lawsuit, if the agent is found to have a special relationship with the client, they may be held liable. However, in most cases, the liability falls on the insurer. Insurance agents have a relatively low level of duty compared to other professionals, and they are generally not legally required to proactively search for a client's needs.

Brokers

Insurance brokers, on the other hand, represent the consumer or the party seeking insurance. They do not work for insurers but work closely with individuals to help them shop for insurance coverage from various providers. Brokers owe their fiduciary duties to the client and are held to a higher standard of care. According to Kochenburger, if a policyholder can establish a special relationship with a broker, such as a long-term working relationship where the client relies on the broker for advice, the broker may have an even higher duty of care. Ultimately, it is the courts that determine whether a special relationship exists and whether an insurance professional is acting as an agent or broker, regardless of their official job title.

Fiduciary Duties

Fiduciary duties refer to legal obligations requiring one party to act in the best interests of another. In the insurance context, these duties encompass relationships between the insurer and the insured, industry standards of care, and professional conduct. While insurance agents have basic fiduciary duties to customers, brokers generally owe a higher level of fiduciary duty to insured individuals due to their representative role.

The role of insurance brokers

Insurance brokers act as intermediaries between insurers and businesses or individuals seeking insurance. They are licensed professionals who work directly for the client, not the insurance company, and have a fiduciary duty to act in the client's best interests. This means brokers must act in good faith and put the client's interests ahead of their own.

Brokers help clients understand their insurance needs and find suitable policies within their budget. They can provide advice on different types of insurance, such as property, casualty, health, and life insurance, and can assist with compliance and claims submissions. They are typically paid through commissions by the insurance company, but it's important for clients to understand how their broker is paid to avoid potential conflicts of interest.

In contrast to insurance agents, who are employees of insurance companies, brokers do not have a stake in the policies they sell and are not beholden to a particular insurance company. This allows them to offer impartial advice and help clients shop for the best coverage from different providers.

Brokers can save clients money by negotiating better rates and coverage than clients could find on their own. They can also act as an extension of a company's human resources team, providing ongoing support and assistance with policy changes and claims.

To maintain their fiduciary responsibilities, brokers must avoid conflicts of interest and disclose any potential issues that may arise. Fiduciary certifications and licenses can be revoked by the courts if a broker neglects their duties.

While the specific duties of insurance brokers and agents can vary depending on the circumstances and relationships involved, it is essential to understand the roles and responsibilities of these professionals when seeking insurance advice and coverage.

Fiduciary duty defined

A fiduciary is a person or entity that acts on behalf of another person or group of persons, taking on a legal or ethical relationship of trust. Typically, a fiduciary prudently takes care of money or other assets for another person. They are expected to be extremely loyal to the person to whom they owe the duty, known as the "principal".

A fiduciary duty is the highest standard of care in equity or law. The nature of fiduciary obligations differs among jurisdictions. In the financial sense, fiduciary duties exist to ensure that those who manage other people's money act in their beneficiaries' interests, rather than serving their own.

A fiduciary has a duty of care, loyalty, good faith, prudence, and confidentiality. They must not be in a situation where personal interests and fiduciary duty conflict, nor should they profit from their position as a fiduciary unless the principal consents.

Fiduciary duties include:

• Duty of care: The responsibility to be well-informed and make sound judgments that protect a beneficiary's interests.
• Duty of loyalty: Acting in the best interests of the beneficiary at all times and putting their well-being first.
• Duty to act within the law: Always acting within legal constraints to advance the interests of the beneficiary.
• Duty of confidentiality: Maintaining the confidentiality of all information relating to the beneficiary and not using it for personal gain.
• Duty of disclosure: Being forthright and disclosing all relevant information that could impact their duties as fiduciaries or the well-being of the beneficiary.

A breach of fiduciary duty occurs when a fiduciary fails to act responsibly in the best interests of a client. This can lead to various consequences, including reputational damage, loss of clients, monetary penalties, industry discrediting, and removal from service.

In the context of insurance, the classification of an insurance professional as an "agent" or "broker" can make a significant difference in a fiduciary duty lawsuit. An "agent" is primarily an agent of the insurance company they represent, while a "broker" owes their allegiance to the client and is an agent of the insured.

While every financial professional should act in the best interest of their clients, not all are required to be fiduciaries. Financial advisors, investment advisors, and insurance professionals may be fiduciaries depending on their qualifications and licenses.

Fiduciary duty of insurance agents

A fiduciary is a person or entity that acts on behalf of another person or persons to manage their assets with their best interests in mind. It is the highest legal duty that one party can have to another, and fiduciaries are legally and ethically bound to act in their client's best interests.

Insurance agents are employees and representatives of an insurance company. They help customers with policies and claims involving their employer. In this capacity, insurance agents generally have fiduciary duties to their employer. There is also a basic level of fiduciary duty between the agents and customers. However, it is important to note that insurance agents are not considered fiduciaries if they only hold an insurance license.

Insurance agents are generally required to act with reasonable prudence and adhere to some basic fiduciary duties when processing claims and dealing with insured individuals. For example, they must abide by standard industry procedures, processes, and timelines. They may also have a special relationship with a customer, which expands their fiduciary duty and requires them to offer the customer advice regarding their insurance needs. This can occur when the agent misrepresents the nature of the coverage, voluntarily assumes the role of selecting coverage, offers advice related to the type of coverage, holds themselves out as a specialist, has a longstanding relationship with the customer, or is paid for their advice.

Breaches of fiduciary duty by insurance agents can include negligent interactions, wrongful denials, the use of misleading information, and post-claim underwriting. If insurance agents fail to abide by their fiduciary duties, they can be sued, fined, and face disciplinary action.

Breach of fiduciary duty

A breach of fiduciary duty can occur in various ways, and such breaches can derail claims and deny injured parties the compensation they deserve. While this can be the basis of new lawsuits, a breach of fiduciary duties can also give rise to challenging claims.

In the context of insurance, fiduciary duties generally focus on the relationship between the insurer and the insured. A breach of fiduciary duty can occur when an insurance agent fails to act in the best interests of the customer. This includes situations where the agent negligently fails to take out requested coverage, wrongfully denies valid claims, or uses misleading information to manipulate customers.

For example, in the case of Gibson v. Government Employees Ins. Co., the court addressed the issue of whether an insurer owed a fiduciary duty to advise its insureds about the availability of additional coverage and the inadequacy of their current policy limits. The court concluded that, absent conduct by the insurer assuming broader duties, the insurer's fiduciary duties are limited to those arising from the insurance contract itself.

Another example of a breach of fiduciary duty in the insurance context is illustrated in the case of Powers v. United States Auto. Assoc'n and USAA Cas. Ins. Co. In this case, the insured sued the insurer for breach of fiduciary duty, alleging that the insurer refused to allow him to be present during the investigation of his boat sinking, refused to seal the boat to protect evidence, and refused to provide him with photographs taken during the investigation. The Supreme Court of Nevada ultimately held that the insurer's duty is "akin" to a fiduciary relationship, but that this duty does not give rise to an independent tort.

It is worth noting that the specific duties and standards applicable to insurance agents can vary depending on their classification as agents or brokers. According to Professor Peter Kochenburger of the University of Connecticut's Insurance Law Center, insurance agents primarily represent the insurance company they work for, while brokers owe their allegiance to the client. This distinction is crucial, as it determines who can be held liable in a fiduciary duty lawsuit.

While there may be basic fiduciary duties that insurance agents must adhere to, it is important to understand that these duties may not rise to the level of "formal fiduciary duties." For instance, Texas law and case law establish that there is no general fiduciary duty between an insurer and its insured. However, insurance agents are still expected to act with reasonable prudence and adhere to standard industry procedures when processing claims.

In summary, a breach of fiduciary duty in the insurance context can have significant consequences and give rise to legal action. Insurance professionals must be mindful of their duties and act in the best interests of their clients to avoid such breaches.

Frequently asked questions