Life Insurance Agreements: What's Discoverable?

Life insurance is a legally binding contract between an insurance company and an insured party. The insured agrees to pay small periodic payments in exchange for a payout from the insurance company if the covered event specified in the agreement occurs. The existence of insurance is often key to a lawsuit and is usually one of the first orders of business in discovery. There are statutory provisions allowing for the discovery of the existence and contents of insurance agreements, as well as limits on them. For example, in California, discovery is permitted under CCP §2017.210, but insurance applications are not discoverable unless the application is incorporated into the policy.

The existence of insurance is often key to a lawsuit and one of the first orders of business in discovery

The existence of insurance is often a critical factor in a lawsuit and one of the first things to be addressed in the discovery process. Discovery is a formal process in litigation through which each party can obtain evidence from the other party or parties. This process is governed by California law, which expressly provides for discovery about insurance agreements under which an insurer may be liable to satisfy a judgment or to indemnify or reimburse payments made to satisfy a judgment.

The discovery process allows for the examination of the existence and contents of insurance agreements, as well as any disputes over coverage of the claim in question. However, it's important to note that information about insurance is typically not admissible as evidence at trial, as it may not be relevant to the underlying subject matter of the case.

In the context of insurance agreements, discovery can include the following:

• The insured's policy limits, although this information is generally not available before a lawsuit is filed.
• The insurance application, but only if it is incorporated into the policy.
• The existence of a policy, as there is no privilege regarding the existence of an insurance policy.
• Reinsurance agreements, but only if they meet the general relevancy standards.
• The declaration page, which summarizes the coverage, limits, premiums, and deductibles of the policy.
• The insuring agreement, which outlines the major promises and commitments of the insurance company.
• Endorsements and riders, which are amendments or modifications to the original insurance contract.

Insurance agreements are discoverable under CCP §2017.210

However, CCP §2017.210 includes cautionary language stating that information about insurance is not admissible as evidence at trial, as the existence of liability insurance may not be relevant to the underlying subject matter of the action. Additionally, CCP §2017.210 does not authorise the discovery of reinsurance agreements or information related to the financial condition of a defendant's non-party reinsurer.

Reinsurance agreements are not automatically discoverable

However, the existence of insurance is often key to a lawsuit and one of the first orders of business in discovery. There are statutory provisions allowing for the discovery of the existence and contents of insurance agreements, as well as limits on it. For instance, discovery is permitted under CCP §2017.210, which expressly provides for discovery about insurance agreements under which a carrier may be liable to satisfy all or part of a potential judgment or to indemnify or reimburse payments made to satisfy the judgment.

Insurance applications are not discoverable unless the application is incorporated into the policy

In California, insurance applications are not discoverable unless the application is incorporated into the policy. This means that, in the context of a personal injury action, a party can obtain relevant insurance policies but not the insurance application unless it is part of the policy. This is outlined in CCP §§2017.010 and 2031.010.

However, the existence of an insurance policy is not privileged, and a party cannot knowingly conceal the existence of a policy and claim privilege. This is outlined in CC §47(b)(3).

The existence of a policy is not privileged

The existence of a life insurance policy is not privileged information. In other words, a party cannot knowingly conceal the existence of a life insurance policy and claim that the existence of such a policy is privileged. This means that the existence of a life insurance policy can be discovered through legal proceedings.

The discovery of insurance agreements is often key to a lawsuit and one of the first orders of business in legal discovery. In California, discovery law expressly provides for discovery about insurance agreements under CCP §2017.210. This statute allows for the discovery of the existence and contents of insurance agreements, as well as whether coverage of the claim involved in the action is disputed. However, it's important to note that information about insurance may not be admissible as evidence at trial, as it may not be relevant to the underlying subject matter of the case.

Insurance agreements, including life insurance policies, are legal contracts between the insurance company and the insured party. These contracts allow the insured to transfer the risk of a significant financial loss to the insurer in exchange for periodic payments called premiums. Life insurance policies specifically provide financial protection for the insured's beneficiaries in the event of their death.

It is important to understand the basic parts of an insurance contract, which typically include a declaration page, an insuring agreement, exclusions, conditions, and endorsements or riders. The declaration page identifies the insured, the risks or property covered, policy limits, and the policy period. The insuring agreement summarises the major promises of the insurance company and states what is covered. Exclusions refer to specific perils, losses, or property that are not covered by the policy. Conditions are provisions that qualify or place limitations on the insurer's promise to pay or perform, and if these conditions are not met, the insurer can deny the claim. Endorsements and riders are amendments that add to, delete, or modify the original insurance contract.

Frequently asked questions