Auto Insurance Overcharge: What To Do?

It is possible to be overcharged for auto insurance. In fact, data shows that most people are overcharged by an average of $368 per year. There are several signs that you may be paying too much for car insurance. For example, if you have additional fees on top of your premium, or if your rates don't decrease after improving your driving record. The issue of overcharging is exacerbated by the fact that the insurance industry is not transparent, making it difficult for customers to compare rates across carriers. During the COVID-19 pandemic, many insurance companies were accused of charging excessive premiums by failing to account for the drop in driving and crashes.

Auto insurance companies overcharging loyal customers

Auto insurance companies have been accused of overcharging loyal customers. This is done through a tactic known as "price optimization", which involves using analytics to identify customers least likely to compare prices and charging them higher premiums. This practice is alleged to be widespread, with insurance companies using Big Data to focus on customers' shopping habits rather than risk-related factors such as driving records, which have traditionally been used for insurance pricing.

Insurance companies argue that their practices are fair and that consumer groups are misunderstanding their rating practices. They claim that advanced analytical techniques are used to supplement traditional actuarial tools and help make marketing decisions within their risk-based pricing programs. However, critics argue that price optimization is "terribly unfair", particularly to low-income drivers who may not shop around as often for car insurance.

There are a few signs that you may be overcharged for car insurance. One sign is if your insurance has fees on top of your premium. Some companies charge a convenience fee for monthly payments, which can add up to a significant amount over a year. Another sign is if your driving record improves but your rates do not. If you have marks against your driving record, your insurance rates will be higher. However, if these marks are cleared and your provider does not offer you a lower rate, this is a sign that you may be overcharged.

Additionally, if you have an average driving record but are paying more than the national average, you may be overcharged. While factors such as age, marital status, type of car, and gender can affect your insurance quote, if you are paying well over the average, it is likely that you are being overcharged. Finally, if you are not offered any discounts by your insurance company, this may be a sign that you are being overcharged. Many auto insurance companies offer surprising discounts for things like having a safer-rated car.

Overcharging during the pandemic

During the pandemic, auto insurance companies have been accused of overcharging their customers. This is despite the fact that there were fewer drivers on the road and, consequently, fewer accidents.

In March 2021, Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara found that auto insurance companies had overcharged drivers as accidents plummeted during the pandemic. Lara's review included the top 10 insurance groups, representing 80% of the private passenger automobile insurance market. He found that, over seven months, from March to September, insurance company groups returned on average 9% of auto premiums, but his department's analysis found they should have refunded nearly double—17%—over the seven-month period. Lara ordered insurance companies to report how they would return additional premiums to policyholders.

In August 2020, the Consumer Federation of America (CFA) and the Center for Economic Justice (CEJ) called on insurers and insurance regulators to provide ongoing auto premium relief as auto claims remained up to 50% below normal levels due to the pandemic and related restrictions. Despite a couple of states taking action to order premium relief, most state insurance commissioners did not. As a result, auto insurers reported windfall profits. For example, Allstate reported a $1 billion reduction in claims for the second quarter of 2020 compared to the same period in 2019, despite an increase in vehicles insured and premiums. Its second-quarter profits were $1.22 billion, compared to $821 million in the second quarter of 2019. Progressive also reported increased profits, with $2.268 billion for the second quarter of 2020 compared to $1.243 billion for the same period in 2019.

Class action lawsuits were filed in Nevada against 10 major auto insurance companies, contending that the companies charged excessive insurance premiums during the pandemic by failing to account for a drop in driving and crashes. The lawsuits acknowledged that some insurers provided discounts, but these did not offer "any meaningful relief that actually reflects the reduction in cars on the road and reduced driving during the pandemic". The rates that were charged violate state law against excessive premiums, the lawsuits argued. The lawsuits were filed on behalf of Nevada insurance customers against State Farm, USAA, Geico, Acuity, Liberty Mutual, Farmers, Progressive, Travelers, Nationwide, and Allstate.

Some insurance companies have defended their practices, arguing that consumer groups are misunderstanding rating practices. Robert Hartwig, president of the Insurance Information Institute, rejected the claim that carriers are using analytics to unfairly price risk as "patently false and utterly nonsensical". He argued that some insurers may use advanced analytical techniques to help them make marketing decisions within their risk-based pricing program.

The inconvenience of switching providers

Switching car insurance providers can be inconvenient, and there are some factors that might make you hesitant to do so. Firstly, it can be a hassle to switch providers, especially if you have to do it multiple times. While it's not a complicated process, it does require some research and communication with both your old and new insurers. You'll need to compare quotes, research companies, and go through the steps of cancelling your current policy and setting up a new one. This can take time and effort, which some people may not have or prefer not to spend.

Another inconvenience is the potential for cancellation fees. While many insurers don't charge cancellation fees, some may, especially if you cancel your policy before the end of the policy period. These fees can be a deterrent, especially if you're not sure whether the savings from switching will outweigh the cancellation cost. Additionally, if you switch before your policy runs out, you may be entitled to a refund for the remaining coverage period, minus any cancellation fee. However, this process can be a bit cumbersome, and you'll need to contact your insurer to find out the details.

Loyalty discounts can also play a role in the inconvenience of switching providers. If you've been with the same insurer for a long time, you may be eligible for loyalty discounts, which can result in competitive rates. By switching providers, you'll lose out on these discounts and may end up paying more, even with a new provider. It's important to carefully consider the potential savings of switching versus the benefits of staying with your current insurer.

Finally, switching providers can be inconvenient if you have an open insurance claim. While it is possible to switch providers in this situation, your current insurer will still handle the claim. This means they will be responsible for investigating and closing out the claim, which can take time and effort on your part to facilitate. Additionally, your rates may increase to account for the cost of the claim, and you'll need to be honest with your new provider about the open claim to avoid even higher rates.

Overall, while switching car insurance providers can provide benefits such as lower rates or better customer service, there are also inconveniences and potential drawbacks to consider. It's important to weigh these factors before making a decision to switch.

Overcharging lower-income drivers

The CFA's analysis of 81,000 premium quotes from top insurance companies found that none offered basic auto insurance to safe drivers in 50 large urban regions for less than $500 per year. In lower-income zip code areas, these insurers often charged over $500 for basic yearly premiums, with car insurance prices in some cities exceeding this amount in all lower-income areas analysed. This pricing structure disproportionately affects lower-income drivers, who may already be struggling financially.

The issue of overcharging lower-income drivers is not just about higher premiums. It's about denying economic opportunities and contributing to the problem of uninsured drivers on the road. As Tom Feltner, CFA's director of financial services, pointed out, high insurance premiums can prevent lower-income Americans from owning a car, impacting their ability to get to work or school. This creates a vicious cycle where those who can't afford insurance are forced to drive without it, putting themselves and others at risk.

To combat this issue, some states have introduced government-sponsored automobile insurance programs specifically aimed at helping low-income drivers. For example, California, Hawaii, and New Jersey offer state-sponsored insurance policies with different eligibility requirements and coverage options. Additionally, low-income families can take advantage of discounts, state-specific programs, or reduce their coverage to save on car insurance. Shopping around for the best rates and maximizing discounts can also help lower auto insurance costs.

While these steps can provide some relief, the systemic issue of overcharging lower-income drivers persists. It is essential for state and federal regulators to continue addressing this problem and ensuring that auto insurance remains accessible and fairly priced for all drivers, regardless of their socioeconomic status.

The lack of transparency in the insurance industry

The insurance industry is notoriously opaque, making it challenging for customers to compare rates across different providers. This lack of transparency gives auto insurers the upper hand when setting rates and allows them to keep their pricing information hidden from customers. This is in stark contrast to other industries, such as health insurance, where consumers can easily compare plans and prices before making an informed decision.

The inconvenience of switching insurance providers also contributes to the lack of transparency. Many customers are likely to stick with their current insurer even if they suspect they are being overcharged, reducing the incentive for insurers to compete on price. As a result, customers may end up paying higher premiums than necessary.

Furthermore, insurance companies have been accused of engaging in "price optimization," an analytical technique that allows them to identify customers who are unlikely to compare prices or switch providers and charge them higher premiums. This practice is illegal in some states, as it is considered "terribly unfair" to consumers, particularly low-income drivers.

To address these concerns, some states have taken action to protect consumers. For example, the insurance commissioner of Washington state warned carriers against using certain personal information, such as shopping habits, to determine auto rates. Additionally, class-action lawsuits have been filed against major insurance companies, alleging that they charged excessive premiums during the COVID-19 pandemic by failing to account for reduced driving and accidents.

Frequently asked questions