Auto Insurance Pricing Secrets: Are Companies Sharing Data?

Auto insurance companies do not share pricing information directly with each other. However, they can access shared databases, such as CLUE (Claims Loss Underwriting Exchange), which contains data about drivers' policies, claims, driving histories, and other factors that influence insurance rates. This allows insurance companies to assess an individual's risk and determine their rates. Additionally, insurance companies obtain information from the same sources, such as driving records and credit reports, to make informed decisions about coverage and premiums.

Auto insurance companies don't share pricing information directly

While insurance companies don't directly share pricing information, they do communicate with each other, especially regarding risk assessment and pricing. They share data through shared insurance databases, such as the CLUE database, which contains information on drivers' policies, claims, and driving histories. This data exchange helps insurance companies make informed decisions about coverage and premiums, as well as prevent fraud.

Additionally, insurance companies may share information with each other in specific circumstances, such as for underwriting, claims handling, fraud prevention, and marketing purposes. However, they must comply with privacy laws and regulations, such as the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA), to protect your personal data.

It's important to note that insurance companies don't inform each other when you get new quotes. They focus on sharing information directly related to your driving record and how long you've been with your current insurer.

They use shared databases like CLUE to access information

Auto insurance companies do not share information directly with each other. However, they can access shared databases, such as CLUE (Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange), to view an individual's insurance history. CLUE is a database run by LexisNexis that records up to seven years of claims information. It provides a summary of a person's auto or home insurance claim history, including claims that were paid or denied, and serious inquiries made to an agent or adjuster. This allows insurance companies to assess an individual's risk and determine premiums.

More than 99% of auto insurance companies and 96% of home insurance companies contribute to the CLUE database, according to LexisNexis. When individuals apply for auto or home insurance, they authorise insurers to check their records at consumer reporting agencies, including LexisNexis, which will provide their CLUE report. This report helps insurance companies decide what an individual will pay for insurance and whether to offer them coverage. For example, a CLUE report showing multiple claims may result in higher premiums or limited coverage.

In addition to CLUE, there are other specialty consumer reporting agencies that collect information about insurance claims. These agencies may also collect driving records and other personal information. Individuals have the right to request free copies of their reports from consumer reporting agencies, including specialty agencies, at least once a year. This allows individuals to review and dispute any inaccuracies in their reports, helping to ensure they receive fair and accurate coverage options.

Companies may also use credit scores to determine rates

Auto insurance companies do not share information with each other, but they do have access to the same reports about you. These reports include your driving record, claims history, and credit score. While not all states allow insurance companies to use credit scores to calculate rates, some do.

Credit scores are a three-digit number that rates your creditworthiness. The higher the score, the more likely you are to get approved for loans and better rates.

A credit score is based on your credit history, which includes information such as the number of accounts, total debt, repayment history, and other factors. Lenders use credit scores to evaluate your creditworthiness, or the likelihood that you will repay loans in a timely manner. A higher credit score indicates that you are less of a financial risk, while a lower score suggests the opposite.

In addition to lenders, other businesses such as phone companies, auto insurance companies, and home insurance companies also use credit scores to decide whether to offer you a policy or service. Credit scores can also impact the terms of the credit offered, such as the interest rate.

It is worth noting that credit scores are not the only factor considered by auto insurance companies when determining rates. Other factors include age, the insured vehicle, and location. However, your credit score can still play a significant role in the overall calculation.

Driving records are also used to determine insurance rates

Driving records are a key factor in determining car insurance premiums. Insurance companies use driving records to assess the risk of insuring a driver and set insurance rates accordingly. A good driving record generally results in lower premiums, while a history of accidents, traffic violations, or claims will increase premiums as the driver is deemed higher risk.

When applying for car insurance, insurance companies will conduct a risk assessment to determine whether an applicant is low or high risk. They do this by reviewing the applicant's driving history, which includes moving violations, accidents (both at-fault and not-at-fault), and any criminal convictions associated with the driving record, such as DUIs. The frequency and severity of recent driving violations and collisions are used to estimate the level of insurance risk.

Insurance companies typically look back at the previous three to five years of a driver's history when setting insurance rates, although this can vary depending on state laws and the company. For example, in California, a DUI remains on the record for ten years and counts as an offense, while an accident has a look-back period of three years.

The impact of a driving record on insurance rates can vary. One accident can increase auto insurance rates by an average of $80 per month, while one speeding ticket can raise rates by $45 per month. However, this can differ between insurance providers, with some companies being more forgiving of minor offenses.

In addition to driving records, insurance companies consider other factors such as credit score, age, location, and vehicle type when determining insurance premiums.

Policyholders with bad records will face higher insurance premiums

Insurers consider people with a clean driving history and good credit to be low-risk drivers, and reward them with lower rates. Conversely, a driver with a poor credit score and several violations on their driving record is more likely to be considered high-risk. A handful of insurance risk factors are out of the driver's control, such as age, gender and location, but driving record and credit history are two important factors that can be controlled.

Insurance companies use a variety of factors to determine your risk level, and each company uses its own formula to set premiums. Therefore, the impact of a bad driving record on your insurance premium will vary depending on the company. Some companies, often called "non-standard" insurers, offer more affordable rates for people with poor driving histories.

If you have a bad driving record, it is important to shop around for coverage and compare quotes from multiple companies to find the best rates. You can also take advantage of discounts, improve your credit score, and drive more safely to lower your premiums.

Frequently asked questions