Golf Course Homes: Insured?

Living on a golf course may be a dream for some, but it comes with a unique set of risks. From stray golf balls hitting houses, cars, or even people, to the potential for noise disturbances, there are a number of considerations when it comes to insurance for golf course homes. The responsibility for damage caused by a stray golf ball is not always clear-cut and can vary depending on the location and specific circumstances. In some cases, the golfer may be held liable, but only if they can be identified and proven to have acted negligently or without reasonable care. More often, it is the homeowner who is responsible for covering the cost of repairs, either through their insurance or out-of-pocket.

Golfers liable for damage

Golf is a game of skill and precision, but even the most experienced players can have an off day. Sometimes, a wayward shot can result in broken windows or damaged property. So, what happens when a golfer accidentally causes damage to a house on a golf course? Is the golfer liable for the repairs, or does the responsibility lie with the homeowner or the golf course itself?

The law regarding liability for property damage caused by stray golf balls is not always clear-cut and can vary depending on the location and specific circumstances of the incident. In some cases, courts may hold the golfer responsible for any damage they cause to personal property while playing. This means that if a golfer breaks a window, they may be expected to pay for the repairs. However, the law does not always side with the homeowner, and there are several factors that can influence liability in these situations.

One important consideration is the level of care exercised by the golfer. If a golfer is negligent or reckless in their actions, they may be held liable for any resulting damage. For example, if a golfer tees off in the wrong direction or intentionally aims for a house, they could be considered liable. In such cases, the golfer's actions would be considered unreasonable, and they may be expected to bear the cost of any damage caused.

On the other hand, some courts have ruled that homeowners assume a certain level of risk when they choose to live near a golf course. In these cases, the homeowner may be held responsible for any damage caused by stray golf balls. Additionally, the golf course itself may be found at fault if it is deemed to have been constructed too close to existing homes or if the design of the holes and tee boxes places houses in unnecessary danger. In these situations, the golfer may be absolved of liability, even if the golf course posted signs stating that players are responsible for any damage caused.

It is worth noting that proving liability in these cases can be challenging, especially if the golfer does not take responsibility for the damage and leaves the scene without providing their contact information. Homeowners may find it difficult to identify the individual responsible for the damage, particularly if they do not witness the incident themselves. As a result, homeowners may have to bear the cost of repairs themselves, either by paying out of pocket or by claiming on their insurance policy.

To summarise, while golfers may be held liable for damage caused by their wayward shots, the specific circumstances of each case will determine the allocation of responsibility. Golfers are generally advised to exercise reasonable care and avoid reckless behaviour to minimise the risk of causing damage and being held liable. Similarly, homeowners living near golf courses should be aware of the potential risks and consider the limitations of their insurance coverage in the event of any golf-related incidents.

Homeowner's insurance

Living on a golf course can be an ideal setting for many, but it comes with certain risks. If you decide to live on a golf course, you should take a close look at your insurance policies. The risk of being hit by a golf ball will be higher than average, and whether that stray golf ball hits a houseguest, your home, or your car, it can cause damage or injury.

Homeowners Insurance

When you choose to live on a golf course, you assume a certain amount of risk for potential damage from slices and hooks. Depending on where your house is located relative to the tee box or the fairway, your home is probably the most likely to be hit by an errant ball. Roofs, windows, and siding are all vulnerable, so knowing what your deductible is will be a determining factor in whether filing a homeowners insurance claim makes sense. If you've gone with a high deductible to reduce your premiums, consider what that will mean for your out-of-pocket costs to replace windows. Large, picture windows can be costly.

If you live in a golf course community and a golf ball hits and injures one of your houseguests, your homeowners insurance will usually cover the injury. This is an injury that happened on your property, and your personal liability coverage will often cover this up to your coverage limits on your policy. However, some policies may have exclusions, so it is important to know what is covered and what might not be.

Auto Insurance

If you live in a golf course community, there's also a chance that your car might be hit by a golf ball. State laws vary regarding the golfer's responsibility, and it may be challenging to determine who hit the ball that struck your car. Review your auto insurance policy and see what kinds of limits there might be for damage to the vehicle that was not caused by a collision. If your windshield was hit and was either cracked or shattered, review your policy to see if you have a separate glass damage deductible; if the damage exceeds the deductible, your claim may be covered. If a stray ball left a dent in your hood and you have comprehensive coverage, the amount of damage will come into play here too. If the damage is less than your deductible, you will probably be paying for the repair out of pocket.

Golf course insurance

Golf Course and Property Coverage

Golf Course Property and Buildings Coverage

This aspect of golf course insurance covers the buildings and structures present on the golf course premises. It includes protection for the clubhouse, retail spaces, and any other structures essential to the course's operations.

Golf Cart Coverage

Golf carts are an integral part of the golf course experience, and golf course insurance policies provide coverage for these vehicles. This coverage can include protection against damage to the carts, liability coverage in case of accidents, and even enhancements for specific risks associated with golf cart operations.

Enhancements and Additional Coverages

• Hole-in-one promotions: Coverage for prize costs associated with hole-in-one contests, although there may be limitations based on award size or location.
• Landscape cleanup and repair: Increased coverage for debris and pollutant cleanup, as well as protection for landscape features such as trees, shrubs, and signage.
• Protection for golf course operations: Coverage for risks such as food spoilage, employee theft, golf pro replacement, credit card transactions, data loss, and other operational concerns.
• Off-premises coverage: Protection for course property used off-site and extended coverage beyond the premises, ensuring that golf course owners are protected even when their property is used or damaged off-course.

Considerations for Golf Course Communities and Homes

While golf course insurance primarily focuses on protecting the course itself, it's important to consider the implications for homes and communities located on or near golf courses. Golf course communities face the added risk of golf balls straying into residential areas, causing damage to properties and even injuring individuals.

Homeowners in these communities should carefully review their insurance policies, as they may be responsible for repairing damage caused by errant golf balls. While golfers are technically liable for any damage they cause, it can be challenging to identify the responsible party without a confession or witness. Homeowner's insurance will typically cover such incidents, but homeowners may need to pay a deductible out of pocket, which can be substantial.

Additionally, when purchasing a home in a golf course community, it is advisable to consider the orientation of the house relative to the golf course. Certain areas of the course, such as the "slice zone," may be more prone to errant shots, increasing the risk of damage. Materials used in construction and the presence of shatter-proof windows can also impact the susceptibility of homes to golf ball damage.

In summary, golf course insurance provides comprehensive protection for the course itself, while homeowners in golf course communities should be mindful of their insurance coverage and take steps to minimise the potential for damage from stray golf balls.

Risk of damage

If you live in a house on a golf course, your property is at a higher risk of being hit by a golf ball. This includes your house, your car, and even your houseguests.

The trajectory of a golf ball can be unpredictable, and even the most experienced golfer can accidentally hit a house. The risk of damage is higher if your house is located near a tee box or fairway. Roofs, windows, and siding are all vulnerable to damage from a stray golf ball.

If you live in a golf course community, it's important to review your insurance policies and understand your coverage and deductible. For example, if you have a high deductible to reduce your premiums, consider what that will mean for your out-of-pocket costs to replace windows or siding.

In terms of legal liability, the laws regarding responsibility for property damage caused by errant golf balls vary from state to state and are often decided on a case-by-case basis. Some courts hold the golfer responsible for any damage they cause, while others believe that homeowners bear responsibility since they assumed the risk by choosing to live near a golf course. Homeowner's insurance may also cover the damage.

In some cases, the golf course itself may be held liable, particularly if the course was built near existing houses or if the hole design and tee box placement put houses in obvious danger.

To prevent golf ball damage, golfers should take precautions such as checking their surroundings, using caution near residential areas, and using appropriate equipment. Golf courses can also implement safety measures such as warning signs, protective netting, and lighting to minimise the risk of damage to nearby properties.

Overall, living on a golf course comes with a higher risk of property damage, and it's important for homeowners to understand their insurance coverage and the legal liabilities involved.

Lawsuits against golf courses

Golf courses can be the subject of various lawsuits, ranging from contractual disputes to personal injury claims. Here are some examples of lawsuits involving golf courses:

Contractual Disputes

In the case of Conway Golf Club in Myrtle Beach, a shareholder filed a lawsuit against the club that impacted the contracted sale of the course to a home builder. The shareholder, Judy Edwards, argued that the club was insolvent due to its debts and liabilities and requested that the court order the dissolution of the corporation. The club denied the claims of insolvency but admitted to having debts and requested proof from Edwards. The lawsuit created uncertainty for the homebuilder, who was waiting for the outcome before proceeding with their plans for a single-family housing development.

Personal Injury Claims

Golf courses can also face lawsuits arising from personal injuries sustained by golfers or nearby residents. In one case, a couple living next to the Morgan Hill Golf Course in Eastern Pennsylvania sued the course after being repeatedly hit by errant golf balls that invaded their property. The couple testified that their safety and quality of life were severely impacted by the constant fear of being struck by stray golf balls. They were granted an injunction against the golf course, but they later returned to court, alleging that the course had failed to comply with the order as wayward shots continued to occur. The golf course denied any wrongdoing, citing the presence of a thick woods between the tees and the couple's home, which they argued made the situation impossible.

Discrimination Lawsuits

Golf courses have also been the subject of discrimination lawsuits. In one notable case, five Black women in York, Pennsylvania, faced discrimination while playing golf at Grandview Golf Club. The owners disrupted their round, claiming they were playing too slowly, and called the police twice. The women's club membership was also rescinded. The incident sparked outrage in the community, with several state legislators and residents rallying in support of the women. The Pennsylvania Human Relations Committee planned to hold a hearing to investigate the discrimination charges against the golf club.

Membership Deposit Disputes

Golf courses can also face legal disputes with their members over membership deposits and refunds. In a high-profile case, Trump National Golf Club in Jupiter, Florida, was sued by former members who claimed they were refused refunds of their deposits when they left the club. The dispute arose from a change in club rules implemented by Donald Trump in 2012. A judge ruled in favour of the former members and ordered the club to pay a settlement of $5.45 million to resolve the class-action lawsuit.

Frequently asked questions