The Art Of Negotiation: Navigating Low Bids From Insurance Adjusters

Insurance adjusters are often incentivized to give low bids to save money for their employer, the insurance company. This is known as lowballing and is a common practice in the insurance industry.

When an insurance adjuster gives a lowball bid, they are trying to pay out as little as possible on a claim. This can be problematic for the claimant, who may not receive sufficient compensation to cover their losses.

Lowballing can take several forms, including a quick settlement offer, pressuring the claimant to accept, ignoring or dismissing evidence, questioning injuries, refusing to explain the math behind the offer, and abruptly ending communication.

It is important for claimants to be aware of these tactics and to know their rights when dealing with an insurance adjuster. By understanding the claims process, seeking multiple bids, and being prepared to negotiate, claimants can help ensure they receive a fair settlement.

Insurance adjusters' first offers are typically low as they save money for their employer

When it comes to insurance claims, the first settlement offer from an adjuster is typically low. This initial offer is part of a negotiation strategy, and adjusters often have the authority to negotiate a final settlement amount. One of their primary goals is to save money for their employer, the insurance company. By starting with a low offer, they can control costs and attempt to minimise the potential compensation. This tactic can be beneficial for the insurance company's bottom line, but it may not adequately cover all the costs incurred by the claimant.

After an accident, an insurance adjuster will investigate the claim by gathering evidence, reviewing documentation, and assessing the chances of the claimant's success at trial. They will then make an initial settlement offer, which is usually a percentage of what they believe is the final value of the case. This offer may be presented as a quick settlement to tempt the claimant into accepting it without further negotiation. However, it is important to remember that this first offer is not set in stone and can be negotiated.

Claimants should be aware of their rights and carefully consider the initial offer. It is advisable to have a good understanding of their policy, the applicable state laws, and the extent of their losses. This includes considering not only the immediate costs but also any future expenses that may arise due to long-term injuries or ongoing treatment. By seeking legal advice and negotiating with the adjuster, claimants can aim for a settlement that more accurately reflects the true cost of their losses.

While insurance adjusters aim to save money for their employers, claimants should also be cautious of insurance companies using delay tactics or denying claims outright. It is essential to be informed, patient, and persistent when dealing with insurance companies to ensure a fair outcome.

Initial offers are open to negotiation, so don't feel pressured to accept

When it comes to negotiation, the first offer is a crucial moment that can set the tone and direction of the entire process. While traditional wisdom suggests that waiting for the other party to make the initial offer is advantageous, recent research on the "anchoring effect" has nuanced this strategy. This effect demonstrates that the first offer can strongly influence how both parties perceive the value of what is being negotiated, pulling judgments towards the initial number.

In the context of insurance claims, it is common for adjusters to make lowball settlement offers, and there are several signs that this may be happening. Firstly, a quick offer is often a lowball tactic, as it doesn't allow enough time for a thorough evaluation of your damages. Secondly, if the adjuster ignores or dismisses evidence of your damages or liabilities, they may be trying to minimise their company's payout. Thirdly, adjusters may pressure you to accept their offer quickly, implying that it is as high as they will go. Fourthly, they may question or downplay your injuries, trying to attribute them to pre-existing conditions or arguing that the accident wasn't serious. Finally, they may try to get you to forgo legal representation, as they know that experienced attorneys can effectively challenge lowball offers and secure fair compensation.

If you suspect you are receiving a lowball offer from an insurance adjuster, there are several steps you can take:

• Don't accept the first offer: Initial offers are open to negotiation, so don't feel pressured to accept. Remember, you only have one chance to get a fair settlement.
• Review the policy: Go over the terms of the policy you are claiming against to ensure the adjuster isn't leaving out anything that should be covered.
• Ask for specifics: Inquire about the adjuster's offer, what they've included and excluded, and why.
• Gather evidence: Provide the adjuster with additional evidence such as X-rays, photographs, police reports, and other proof of liability and damages.
• Negotiate: Instead of simply rejecting the offer, send a counteroffer with complete documentation of your damages and why the insurance company is liable.
• File a lawsuit: If the insurance company refuses to raise their offer, you can take legal action to pursue a fair settlement.
• Hire a personal injury lawyer: An attorney can assist you in all the above steps and more. They will fight for your rights and guide you through the complex insurance claims process.

Remember, insurance companies are not looking out for your best interests. They aim to pay out as little as possible to maximise profits. By understanding their tactics and knowing your rights, you can better position yourself to receive a fair settlement offer.

Adjusters may ignore evidence, downplay injuries, or dismiss your emotional damages

While emotional distress is a valid reason to seek compensation, it can be challenging to prove. This is because mental injuries are "invisible", and the experience of emotional distress is deeply personal and varies from person to person. However, it is not impossible to prove, and there are steps you can take to strengthen your case.

Firstly, it is important to understand what constitutes emotional distress. Emotional distress is mental suffering caused by someone else's actions, either on purpose or accidentally. Symptoms can include insomnia, uncontrollable crying, anxiety, depression, and other types of mental illness. Emotional distress can occur alongside physical harm, in which case it is known as pain and suffering. It is also possible to experience emotional distress without any physical injury, for example, in cases of sexual abuse, harassment, or defamation.

If you are experiencing emotional distress due to the actions of another person, you may be able to sue for compensation. This could be based on negligent infliction of emotional distress or intentional infliction of emotional distress. In most states, you would need to have some kind of physical reaction to successfully sue for emotional distress, even if there was no physical contact. However, some states have removed this requirement in recent years. It is also worth noting that bystander lawsuits, where you were not directly involved in the incident but witnessed it, are typically limited to family members.

To prove emotional distress, you will need to provide evidence. This can include medical records, mental health records, witness statements, and your own personal journal detailing the impact of the incident on your daily life. Any physical symptoms you are experiencing as a result of your emotional distress, such as changes in eating or sleeping patterns, chronic pain, or headaches, can also be used as evidence. It is also helpful to have documentation of any diagnoses or medication changes since the incident.

When determining the amount of compensation for emotional distress, there is no rigid formula. It often involves multiplying your economic damages (such as medical bills and lost wages) by a factor of 1.5 to 5, depending on the severity of your injuries. In some cases, you may even receive punitive damages, which are meant to punish the defendant for particularly egregious behavior.

It is important to note that insurance companies may be reluctant to pay compensation for emotional distress, especially if there is no physical injury. They may view it as a ploy to get more money. However, emotional distress is a real injury that deserves to be compensated. If you are having difficulty getting the insurance company to pay, it may be necessary to involve an attorney, especially if your injuries are severe or permanent. An attorney can help you navigate the legal process and ensure you receive fair compensation.

They may also delay communication to pressure you into accepting a low offer

It is not uncommon for insurance companies to try to settle as cheaply as possible. One of the signs that an insurance company is lowballing a claim is when they suddenly stop communicating. They want the claimant to call them, panicked and ready to accept whatever offer the insurance company makes.

In the context of job offers, delaying a response can be a good course of action to take in the business world at certain times. For example, if a candidate thinks they could do better elsewhere or is still considering other options. However, the risks grow with each day of deferral. The candidate could end up losing the first offer and a better one may not materialize at all.

When delaying a response to a job offer, it is important to do so professionally, graciously, and with a clear, compelling reason. It is also important to be polite and professional in the communication with the employer, express gratitude for the job offer, and explain that some additional time is needed to carefully consider it.

You can dispute a low offer by providing additional evidence and requesting a re-evaluation

Dealing with a low offer can be frustrating, but it's important to remember that it doesn't have to be. In fact, low offers can often turn into reasonable offers and even perfect sales. The key is to keep your emotions in check and approach the negotiation process calmly and strategically.

• Control your emotions: Selling a home can be emotional, especially if you have a lot of memories attached to the place. However, it's important to approach the negotiation process calmly and professionally. Don't let your emotions get the better of you, as this may cause you to make impulsive decisions that could hurt your chances of getting a good deal.
• Understand the market: The definition of a lowball offer depends on the current state of the housing market. In a buyer's market, an offer 10% less than the asking price could be considered low, while in a seller's market, constant bidding wars and homes selling over the asking price are common. Understanding the market trends will help you determine if the offer you received is truly a lowball or if it's just the nature of the market.
• Review the terms: The purchase price isn't the only important factor in a real estate transaction. There are other terms that could make one offer more appealing than another. For example, a buyer who is willing to close quickly, has a rock-solid mortgage pre-approval letter, is making a larger down payment, or has fewer inspection contingencies could be more attractive to a seller. Consider your goals and decide if it's worth accepting a lower price for more favourable terms.
• Look at the comps: Just because an offer seems low doesn't mean it's not reasonable. Compare the offer you received to recent sales of similar homes in the area (known as "comps"). If the offer is in line with what other homes have been selling for, it may not be a lowball offer after all.
• Provide additional evidence: If you believe the buyer's offer is too low, you can dispute it by providing additional evidence to support your asking price. This could include recent sales data, market trends, or comparable properties in the area. Present this information to the buyer and their agent to demonstrate why your asking price is fair and reasonable.
• Counter with something minimal: Instead of countering over the asking price or doing nothing at all, a better strategy is to counter with something minimal. This shows the buyer that you are willing to negotiate but also sends a clear message that you are not desperate and that your asking price is fair.
• Get your agent involved: This is what you hired a real estate agent for! They have experience negotiating these types of deals and can provide valuable advice on how to handle lowball offers. They can also communicate with the buyer's agent to try to understand the buyer's perspective and see if there is room for compromise.
• Be prepared to walk away: Sometimes, despite your best efforts, you may not be able to get the buyer to come up to your asking price. In this case, you need to be prepared to walk away from the deal. It's better to wait for an offer that meets your expectations than to settle for less than what you believe your home is worth.

Remember, every real estate transaction is different, and there is no one-size-fits-all approach to handling lowball offers. By keeping your emotions in check, doing your research, and seeking the advice of a skilled real estate agent, you can make informed decisions and increase your chances of getting the best possible deal for your home.

Frequently asked questions