Muslims And Life Insurance: Beliefs And Compatibility

Muslims' beliefs about life insurance vary. Some Muslims believe that life insurance is unacceptable because it involves uncertainty, gambling, and interest, which are prohibited by Islamic law. However, others argue that life insurance is permissible, especially if it is provided by an employer. Takaful, a type of Islamic insurance, is widely accepted by the Muslim community. It is based on the idea of shared risk and mutual support, where everyone contributes to a shared pool of money. This type of insurance avoids the gambling and uncertainty associated with traditional insurance.

Is term life insurance halal?

There are two types of life insurance: term insurance and whole life insurance. Term insurance is a protective insurance policy that covers lost income when the insured dies, including mortgage costs. Whole life insurance, on the other hand, guarantees a payout to the insured person's family when they die. Whole life insurance is also known as life assurance.

Term life insurance is considered halal by some Muslims. This is because it is equivalent to other kinds of protective insurance. The arguments for its permissibility include:

• The kind of gharar (uncertainty) forbidden in the Quran is not the same as that in modern insurance.
• The positives of insurance outweigh the negatives.
• If takaful (a form of insurance compliant with Sharia law) is Shariah-compliant, then conventional insurance must also be compliant as there is little difference between the two.

However, some Muslims argue that term life insurance is haram because it involves gharar and riba (interest). They also argue that life insurance encroaches on the domain of Allah, who is in charge of life and death and providing sustenance.

Muslims seeking life insurance policies that comply with Sharia law should look for policies based on the concept of takaful, which involves the pooling and investment of funds. Takaful policies are considered halal and provide financial protection and long-term savings.

Is whole life insurance haram?

Whole life insurance is often considered haram because most policies have an investment component, which is forbidden by Islamic principles. This is because policyholders would technically be participating in gambling and making money from uncertainty. However, there are some arguments that support the idea that whole life insurance is not haram.

Firstly, let's consider the nature of whole life insurance. This type of insurance is best characterised as an investment, and the permissibility of the investment depends on the underlying assets that are invested in. In the Middle East, this is not an issue if individuals opt for a takaful operator, who will only invest in halal assets. However, in Western countries like the UK and the US, finding insurers that offer Shariah-compliant policies can be challenging.

One argument for the permissibility of whole life insurance is that individuals are not buying and selling their lives but rather mitigating the risk of loss of life. Additionally, the Quran states that Allah has given believers a degree of ownership over their lives, implying that they have some agency in how they use their lives.

Another perspective is that whole life insurance can be permissible if one can control the investments to ensure they are Shariah-compliant. This may involve choosing policies where one can dictate the underlying investments or selecting policies with largely Shariah-compliant investments and donating any non-compliant portions as charity. However, this latter option may not be ideal as whole life insurance is not as necessary as other investment options.

In summary, while whole life insurance may be considered haram due to the investment component, there are arguments that support its permissibility, especially if individuals can ensure Shariah-compliant investments. Ultimately, it is essential to consult Islamic scholars and experts for guidance on this matter.

What is Sharia-compliant life insurance?

Sharia-compliant life insurance, also known as Takaful, is a form of insurance that adheres to the principles of Islamic law, or Sharia. Takaful is derived from the Arabic word "kafalah," which means "joint guarantee," reflecting the underlying characteristic of "sharing." It embodies the spirit of caring within Islam and is based on the principles of cooperation, mutuality, joint interests, and solidarity. Takaful is the only option for Muslims when available.

In Takaful, policyholders pool their premiums together to support one another in times of need. This is done through a shared responsibility and collective assurance model, where policyholders are considered joint investors with the insurance operators. The vendors and policyholders share the pooled monies and any losses, with no guarantee of a positive return on investment. This mutual undertaking ensures that financial protection is provided to the policyholder's family in the event of their death.

Takaful is different from modern life insurance in that it does not involve investing in bonds, which are considered haram in Islam. Additionally, Takaful is not-for-profit, while most life insurance companies are for-profit, which may be seen as taking advantage of people's deaths.

Leading Islamic scholars permit Takaful and term life insurance, especially in countries like the United States where Takaful is not available. They emphasize the importance of ensuring financial security for families due to the necessity and need to protect one's family.

When considering a Sharia-compliant life insurance policy, it is essential to ensure that the policy does not contain any elements of interest, gambling, uncertainty, risk, or investments in areas deemed haram by Islam, such as alcohol, gambling, or pornography. Whole life insurance policies, also known as life assurance, are generally compliant with Sharia laws as there is no element of risk or uncertainty, and the payout is guaranteed upon death.

What is the Islamic perspective on life insurance?

Muslims' perspectives on life insurance vary. Some believe that it is haram (not allowed) because it may involve three key forbidden factors: uncertainty (gharar), gambling (maysir), and interest (riba). However, others argue that it is permissible, or even obligatory, to ensure Muslims can provide for their families after their death.

Takaful

There is a life insurance concept in Islam called Takaful. This is a form of Shariah-compliant insurance where everyone contributes to a shared pool, and when anyone in that group dies, the others pay the family as financial support. This is absolutely halal. It has nothing to do with "gambling on one's life", but it is an indemnification against uncertainty.

Arguments against life insurance

Some Muslims believe that life insurance is haram because it involves gharar (buying/selling something where it is unclear whether what is being bought/sold will be achieved/delivered, thus putting one's money at risk of being lost) and riba (interest).

Arguments for life insurance

Some Muslims believe that life insurance is halal because it is a way to be responsible and care for your family after your death. This aligns with Islamic teachings. Additionally, some argue that by taking out life insurance, one is not encroaching on the domain of Allah. While Allah is in charge of life and death, he doesn't want Muslims to take no precautions.

Islamic life insurance in the West

Muslims in the West may find it difficult to find life insurance that is compliant with Islamic law. This is because standard insurers will almost certainly put large amounts of the policy amount into fixed-income (interest-based) products, which are haram. However, there are a couple of potential ways around this:

• Get a policy where you can dictate what underlying investments the policy is invested in and choose Shariah-compliant assets.
• Choose a policy where the underlying assets are largely Shariah-compliant, and then give away as charity the portion that is not.

What is the difference between takaful and modern life insurance?

Takaful is a Shariah-compliant insurance option based on Islamic Muamalat (Islamic transactions). It is grounded in the concept of mutual cooperation, where both risks and funds are shared between the insured and the insurer. Takaful is relatively new and is often referred to as "Islamic" insurance. It is marketed as an alternative to conventional insurance.

Takaful is a form of mutual insurance, but only when the mutual insurer's investments are Shariah-compliant. In the case of Takaful, the operator provides capital to start the operation and establishes the governance and operating model. The operator also bears the expense risk.

In contrast, conventional insurance involves the pricing of insurance risk, expense risk, and investment risk. The insurance company is the risk-bearer in this case. The investment units of conventional insurance will invest based on their assessment of what fits their profiles, whereas Takaful investments follow strict principles and cannot involve anything Haram.

Another difference lies in the distribution of profits. In Takaful, if there is extra money due to low claim rates, it is distributed to the participants. The operators make money through performance fees or by sharing the surplus, but the total amount they receive cannot exceed the payouts to Takaful participants. In conventional insurance, extra money and profits belong to the shareholders of the insurance companies.

Additionally, Takaful is free from Riba (interest), Gharar (uncertainty), and Maysir (gambling), while conventional insurance may contain these elements.

In terms of pricing, Takaful insurance may be more cost-effective as its fund rates are generally fixed, and people with higher risks are not typically charged more. Conventional insurance, on the other hand, often charges higher premiums for those with extra foreseen risks.

Both Takaful and conventional insurance offer a range of products, including motor, health, life, home, and travel insurance. However, Takaful may offer additional products catering to special Islam-related activities, such as Hajj and Umrah travel plans.

Frequently asked questions