Gender And Insurance: Primary Driver's Impact

When it comes to auto insurance, there are a variety of factors that influence the cost of premiums, and gender is one of the most significant. While age, driving history, and location are also important considerations, insurance companies often use gender as a rating factor, resulting in variations in insurance rates for different genders. This practice has been contested, as it can lead to good male drivers paying inflated costs simply due to their gender. However, insurance companies argue that this is based on historical data, which shows that male drivers tend to be involved in more accidents and make more claims than female drivers. As a result, women often pay less for car insurance than men, especially in younger age groups.

Male drivers are more likely to file claims

Male drivers are more likely to file insurance claims than female drivers. This has been observed by almost all insurance companies and is reflected in their pricing. Male drivers are statistically more likely to get into accidents and engage in risky driving behaviours, including not wearing seat belts, driving under the influence of alcohol, and speeding. As a result, insurers often view male drivers as higher-risk, especially young men.

Historical data shows that men, particularly young men, tend to be involved in more accidents and file more costly claims. This is supported by studies that show a higher number of male crash deaths than female crash deaths. For example, a National Highway Transportation Safety Administration survey found that males are nearly twice as likely as females to report falling asleep while driving, which can lead to reckless driving and accidents.

The difference in insurance rates between genders has been a controversial topic, with consumer advocates arguing that the varying rates are unfair. They argue that if gender were strongly tied to the likelihood of filing a claim, there would be more consistency across insurers and locations. In response to these concerns, some states in the US have outlawed the use of gender as a rating factor, including California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Michigan, Montana, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania.

While gender is a significant factor in insurance rates, it is not the only consideration. Insurance companies also look at other factors such as age, driving history, credit score, and safety features of the vehicle when calculating policy rates. Additionally, as technology evolves, insurance companies are finding new ways to evaluate driver habits that are not based solely on gender.

It is worth noting that, despite males being more likely to file claims, women pay more for their car insurance premiums on average. However, this is reversed when comparing young drivers, with young males paying more than their female counterparts due to their higher risk profile.

Women are less likely to be in accidents

When determining insurance rates, insurance companies consider several historical factors, including the tendency of male drivers to get into more accidents. Male drivers are statistically more likely to file claims than female drivers. This is especially true for younger men, who are the most at-risk group for making a claim due to their lack of experience and tendency to engage in riskier behaviours.

According to data from the US Department of Transportation's Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS), the number of driver fatal crash involvements per 100 million miles driven in 2016-17 was 63% higher for males than for females. Per capita passenger vehicle occupant death rates during 1975-2022 were about twice as high for males as for females. Men are more likely to engage in risky driving practices, such as not wearing seat belts, driving under the influence of alcohol, and speeding. Crashes involving male drivers tend to be more severe, and male drivers are more likely to be driving heavier vehicles, which can offer more protection in a crash.

However, it is important to note that gender is not the only factor considered when setting insurance rates. Other factors include a driver's age, driving history, credit score, safety features of the vehicle, location of the vehicle, and homeowner status. Additionally, as technology evolves, insurance companies are finding new ways to evaluate driver habits that are not based solely on behavioural data.

While women are generally less likely to be in accidents, they are more likely to suffer injuries and fatalities in similar crashes due to spinal differences and the size and weight of their vehicles. Women are more vulnerable to neck injuries, chest injuries, abdominal injuries, and injuries to the limbs. They are also more likely to be driving smaller, lighter cars, which offer less protection in a collision.

Gender X drivers and insurance rates

Gender has long been a factor in determining insurance rates, with men paying more than women due to their higher likelihood of filing claims and getting into accidents. However, the introduction of the "X" gender option on driver's licenses in Ontario, Canada, and other places has raised questions about how insurance rates should be set for these individuals.

In Ontario, insurance providers can set rates for gender "X" customers at their discretion, and rates may vary between companies. Some insurers may offer rates similar to those of female drivers, while others may use an average of male and female rates. There are currently no Canada-wide guidelines on how insurance companies should set rates for gender X drivers, so it is essential for these individuals to shop around and compare quotes from multiple providers.

In Alberta, some companies have embraced the gender "X" identification marker and charge lower premiums, typically in line with female rates. In British Columbia, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba, auto insurance is provided through a public system that does not consider age or gender when setting rates. Similarly, insurers in New Brunswick and Newfoundland are banned from using gender as a rating factor.

While gender has been a significant factor in insurance rates, other factors such as age, driving history, credit score, safety features, and vehicle type also play a role. As technology advances, insurance companies are finding new ways to evaluate driver habits that are not solely based on gender. This shift towards behaviour-based assessments can help ensure that good drivers are not penalised with higher rates due to their gender.

Age and gender combined influence insurance rates

Age and gender are two of the most significant factors influencing car insurance rates. While not all states allow insurers to use these factors, most permit them to be part of the equation.

Younger drivers, regardless of gender, pay more for their car insurance premiums than any other demographic. This is because, as a population, they are more likely to be high-risk drivers, speeding, forgetting to wear seat belts, and breaking other driving laws. Young male drivers are statistically the most at risk of making a claim, with men aged 16 to 19 almost twice as likely to cause an accident as females of the same age. As a result, the average rates for a 20-year-old male driver are 14% higher than for a 20-year-old female driver. However, by age 30, this difference decreases to just 2%, and by age 35, average rates for men and women are the same.

As drivers get older, the gender gap in rates widens again. This is because men are generally riskier to insure. They tend to drive more miles and are more likely to engage in risky driving behaviours like speeding, driving under the influence of alcohol, and not wearing seat belts. From ages 50 to 60, assuming a good driving record, insurance rates are at their lowest. After age 65, rates begin to increase again, with an average 9% increase for females and 12% for males.

In certain states, such as California, Massachusetts, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania, it is illegal for insurers to factor gender into their premium calculations. In these cases, other factors, including age, can significantly influence the cost of car insurance.

Insurance rates for transgender and non-binary people

Insurance rates are influenced by a variety of factors, including age, gender, location, homeowner status, type of vehicle, driving history, credit score, and safety features on the vehicle. While gender is a significant factor in determining insurance rates, with men generally paying more than women due to a higher number of accidents and claims, the impact of gender on insurance premiums for transgender and non-binary individuals is less clear.

In the United States, insurance companies in most states are permitted to use gender as a rating factor, and disparities exist in the rates that male and female drivers pay. However, the available data does not provide a clear understanding of how gender influences insurance rates for transgender and non-binary drivers. Some states, including California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Michigan, Montana, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania, do not allow gender-based auto insurance ratings, and some major insurance companies, such as State Farm and Shelter Insurance, have discontinued the use of gender as a rating factor.

Transgender and non-binary individuals may face challenges in obtaining accurate and affordable insurance rates due to a lack of clear guidelines for insurance providers. While some insurers may offer rates similar to those of female drivers or use an average between male and female rates, others may charge intermediate rates. For example, in a study conducted in Colorado, Progressive quoted non-binary drivers an average of $55 per month, compared to $53 for male drivers and $57 for female drivers.

To find the best insurance rates, transgender and non-binary individuals can work with independent insurance agents or brokers who can shop around and compare rates from multiple providers. It is essential to compare rates and quotes from top companies to find the most inclusive and affordable option. Additionally, individuals can consider combining home and auto coverage to save money on car insurance. When applying for health insurance, transgender individuals should use the name and sex that appear on their Social Security card and other legal documents to avoid complications. Unfortunately, many health plans still use exclusions related to "sex change" or "gender reassignment surgery" to deny coverage for transgender individuals.

Frequently asked questions