Assisted Death And Life Insurance: What's The Impact?

Assisted death, also known as medically assisted death, medical assistance in dying (MAID), doctor-assisted death, physician-assisted death, doctor-assisted suicide, or physician-assisted suicide, is a complex and controversial issue that raises ethical, legal, and practical questions. From an insurance perspective, the primary question is how assisted death affects life insurance policies and payouts to beneficiaries.

In general, life insurance companies treat assisted dying differently from suicide. While suicide within the first two years of a policy typically results in the insurance company refusing to pay out and only returning the paid premiums, assisted death is often treated as a regular death, with the policy paid out in full. This is because assisted death is usually carried out for individuals with terminal illnesses or irremediable conditions, and so the death was reasonably foreseeable. However, this varies by jurisdiction and insurance company, and there may be specific clauses or exclusions related to assisted death in some policies.

When it comes to assisted death, insurance companies will investigate claims to determine if there was any misrepresentation or fraud, such as undisclosed pre-existing conditions or mental health issues. If fraud or misrepresentation is found, the insurance company may deny the claim or void the policy. It is important for individuals to carefully review their life insurance policies and understand the specific terms and conditions related to assisted death, as well as the laws in their jurisdiction.

Suicide clause: If the insured commits suicide within the exclusionary period, the policy is void

Suicide clause provisions in life insurance policies are designed to discourage people from purchasing a policy and then committing suicide to enable their beneficiaries to collect the death benefit. If the insured commits suicide within the exclusionary period, typically two years, the policy is void. In this case, the insurance company will not pay out the death benefit to the beneficiary, but they will return the premiums that were paid for the policy. After the exclusionary period, the insurance company will pay out the full death benefit to the beneficiaries.

The exclusionary period is a safeguard for insurance companies to protect themselves from insurance fraud. For example, if the insured had a terminal illness, was a smoker, or had depression, these issues would increase the chances of them dying and, therefore, make it more likely that the insurer would have to pay out the death benefit.

In the case of assisted death, which is when a qualified doctor or physician provides the means for a patient to end their life, life insurance companies treat it differently than suicide. If the insured dies by physician-assisted suicide, life insurers generally do not pay out a death benefit to the beneficiary. However, if the insured had a policy in place for more than two years, insurers will typically treat suicide cases like any other death and will pay the death claim.

It is important to note that each policy and state may have specific terms and conditions, so it is crucial to review the policy details and consult with the insurance provider.

Exclusionary period: Insurers won't pay out if death occurs within this time frame

The exclusionary period, also known as the contestability period, is a crucial factor in determining whether life insurance policies will pay out in cases of assisted death. This period typically lasts for two years after the policy is purchased, during which insurers can contest claims and refuse to pay the death benefit if the insured dies by suicide or if there is any misrepresentation or fraud.

If the insured dies within the exclusionary period, their beneficiaries may not receive the full death benefit. Instead, the insurer may only refund the premiums that were paid for the policy. This clause is designed to discourage people from purchasing life insurance with the intention of committing suicide soon after.

However, each insurance company, state, and policy may have specific terms and conditions regarding the exclusionary period. For example, some group life insurance policies offered through employers may pay out a death benefit even if the insured dies by suicide within the exclusionary period. Therefore, it is essential to carefully review the specific terms of your policy and consult with your insurance provider to understand how the exclusionary period applies in cases of assisted death.

In the context of assisted death, the exclusionary period serves as a safeguard for insurance companies to investigate and ensure that no fraud or misrepresentation took place. This investigation period allows insurers to determine if the insured had any pre-existing conditions, such as terminal illnesses or mental health issues, that were not disclosed at the time of purchasing the policy.

It is worth noting that the laws and regulations regarding assisted death and life insurance can vary between provinces or states. While some jurisdictions legally allow medical assistance in dying or euthanasia, others may have different requirements and protocols in place. Therefore, it is important to be aware of the specific laws and guidelines in your location to understand how they may impact your life insurance policy and any potential payouts.

MAID: Medical Assistance in Dying is not considered suicide by insurers

Medical Assistance in Dying (MAID) is not considered suicide by insurers, provided that the guidelines set out in federal legislation are followed. This means that MAID will not be subject to the same restrictions as suicide, which typically includes a two-year exemption period for insurance payouts. Instead, MAID will be treated as any other death, and insurers will pay out the policy in full.

This position is supported by the Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association (CLHIA), which represents 99% of Canada's life and health insurance businesses. The CLHIA has stated that as long as the legislated process for MAID is followed, it will not be considered suicide for policy purposes. This decision is in line with the wishes of the Canadian population, as expressed by the head of the CLHIA, Frank Zinatelli.

However, it is important to note that insurers may still rely on other defences to avoid paying out the policy, such as misrepresentation or fraud when applying for coverage. Additionally, the policy should be reviewed to ensure that it does not specifically exclude the particular illness for which MAID is being sought.

In the context of life insurance, MAID refers to situations where a qualified or licensed doctor or physician provides a patient with the information and means to end their life. This is typically done to relieve the suffering of terminally ill individuals or to end a grievous and irremediable condition where death is reasonably foreseeable. MAID is different from euthanasia, which assumes a more active role by the doctor or physician in providing dying assistance.

The criteria for being eligible for MAID are complex and include having a grievous and irremediable medical condition that is in an advanced state of decline and cannot be reversed. The average age of individuals receiving MAID is 72, and the proportion of men and women is roughly equal.

Insurer investigation: Claims are typically investigated for misrepresentation

Insurers will typically investigate most claims to determine if any misrepresentations were made when taking out the policy. For example, if a policyholder had a history of depression or mental instability and did not disclose it, the insurer may decide not to pay the claim. This is because, in cases of assisted death, the insurer will need to prove that there was fraudulent misrepresentation when the application was underwritten.

In the case of medically assisted death, the criteria for eligibility are complex and include having a grievous and irremediable medical condition that is in an advanced state of decline and cannot be reversed. If a claim arises within the first two years of the policy, it will be reviewed to ensure there was no material misrepresentation at the time of application. After the contestability period has run, the insurer would need to prove that there was fraudulent misrepresentation. As long as all symptoms and investigations occurred after the policy was in force and there was no material or fraudulent misrepresentation, the insurer will pay out the claim as the client would have otherwise passed away imminently due to their medical condition.

In Canada, the Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association (CLHIA) has stated that, provided the legislated process is followed, medically assisted death will not be considered "suicide" and the policy will be paid out. However, insurers can still rely on other defences such as misrepresentation or fraud. If the insured had received a diagnosis but did not disclose it on their application, the insurer may not pay out. If the policy has been in effect for two years or more, it will pay out the proceeds unless the insurer asserts fraud.

In the United States, the situation varies by state. In states where death with dignity laws exist, such as Washington D.C., Maine, New Jersey, Hawaii, Oregon, and Washington, the rules concerning insurance payouts may be different. Insurers usually insert their own clauses in death with dignity cases, which can affect the distribution of death benefits. It is important to note that each insurance company and state may have its own specific terms and conditions.

Policy requirements: Insurers won't pay out if policy requirements aren't met

Policy requirements are crucial in determining whether insurers will pay out on life insurance policies, especially in cases of assisted death. Here are some key points to consider:

Exclusionary Period and Suicide Clause

The exclusionary period, typically lasting two years, is a standard clause in life insurance policies. During this period, if the insured individual dies by suicide or assisted death, the beneficiaries will not receive the death benefit. Instead, the insurance company may refund the premiums paid. This clause discourages people from buying policies with the intention of committing suicide to benefit their beneficiaries. After the exclusionary period, insurers generally treat suicide and assisted death as any other cause of death and pay out the full benefit.

Compliance with State/Provincial Laws

In the context of assisted death, it is essential to understand the laws of the state or province where it occurs. In some jurisdictions, such as certain states in the US and provinces in Canada, assisted death is legal under specific conditions. Insurers are more likely to honour claims if the assisted death complies with the legal framework and protocols of the jurisdiction. This includes following the legislated process and meeting health and legal preconditions, such as having a terminal illness or a grievous and irremediable medical condition.

Misrepresentation and Non-Disclosure

Insurers will investigate claims to determine if there was any misrepresentation or non-disclosure of relevant information when the policy was purchased. For example, if the insured had a history of mental health issues or a pre-existing medical condition that was not disclosed, the insurer may decide not to pay the claim. It is crucial for policyholders to be transparent about their health conditions to avoid issues with their beneficiaries receiving the payout.

Policy Exclusions and Specific Terms

Life insurance policies can vary significantly, so it is essential to carefully review the specific terms and conditions of your policy. Some policies may explicitly exclude assisted death or certain underlying conditions from coverage. Understanding your policy's exclusions and limitations is vital to ensure that your beneficiaries receive the intended benefits.

Industry Guidelines and Association Recommendations

In Canada, the Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association (CLHIA) plays a significant role in shaping the industry's approach to assisted death. The CLHIA has affirmed that member companies will not treat assisted death as suicide provided the legislated process is followed. However, insurers can still rely on other defences, such as misrepresentation or fraud, to deny claims. It is recommended to consult industry guidelines and seek advice from professionals to understand how your policy may be affected in cases of assisted death.

Frequently asked questions