Disputing Life Insurance Denials: What's The Time Limit?

Life insurance is meant to provide financial security for your loved ones after you pass away. However, the claims process can sometimes be challenging for beneficiaries, especially if the insurance company denies the claim. Understanding the reasons for denial, the available recourse options, and the time limits involved is crucial for beneficiaries seeking to dispute a life insurance denial and secure their rightful benefits.

Reasons for denial: policy delinquency, misrepresentation, contestable circumstances, documentation failure

Life insurance claims may be denied for several reasons, including policy delinquency, misrepresentation, contestable circumstances, and documentation failure. Understanding these reasons can help beneficiaries navigate the claims process and potentially dispute denials. Here is a detailed explanation of each of these common reasons for denial:

Policy Delinquency

Policy delinquency occurs when a policyholder fails to pay their life insurance premiums on time, causing their coverage to lapse. As a result, the life insurance policy will not be in force at the time of the insured's death, and the beneficiaries will be left without the death benefit. This is a common reason for claim denials, as policyholders may unintentionally let their coverage lapse without informing their beneficiaries.

Misrepresentation

Misrepresentation refers to providing false or incomplete information during the application process. This includes lying about medical history, smoking status, occupation, or hobbies. Non-disclosure of another life insurance policy or providing false or incomplete information about medical history can also be considered misrepresentation. Lying on a life insurance application carries serious consequences, including potential claim denial for beneficiaries.

Contestable Circumstances

Contestable circumstances typically involve a death outside the scope of coverage due to timing. A contestability period, usually lasting two to three years after the policy becomes effective, allows insurers to deny claims under certain circumstances. Common exclusions during this period include suicide, dying while performing an illegal act, military service, aviation, and specific health conditions.

Documentation Failure

Documentation failure occurs when the family or heirs fail to provide the necessary paperwork to receive the death benefit. This can include not providing a certified copy of the death certificate, lack of the original policy document, absence of proof of identity or relationship, omission of medical records, and failure to provide evidence of insurable interest. Additionally, not meeting the time limit for notifying the insurer of the insured's death or incorrectly filling out the claim form can also result in documentation failure.

It is important to note that the time frame for disputing a life insurance denial may vary depending on the specific circumstances and the state in which the policy was purchased. In some cases, beneficiaries may have a limited window of time, such as 60 days, to appeal the denial. Seeking legal advice or consulting with the state's department of insurance can be helpful in understanding the options for disputing a denial.

Appeal to the insurance company: ask for a review, provide evidence, remain polite

If your life insurance claim has been denied, you may be able to appeal the claim by presenting evidence and asking the insurance company to review their decision. Here is a step-by-step guide on how to do this:

Step 1: Understand the denial reason

Firstly, it is important to understand why your claim was denied. Insurers are required to inform you of the reason for denial and how you can dispute their decision. Common reasons for denial include policy delinquency, material misrepresentation, contestable circumstances, and documentation failure. Understanding the reason for denial will help you gather the necessary evidence and build your case for an appeal.

Step 2: Gather evidence

To support your appeal, you should gather relevant evidence to address the reason for the denial. This may include medical records, autopsy reports, insurance payment receipts, or other documentation that proves your case. For example, if the denial was due to policy delinquency, you may be able to disprove this by providing receipts of timely premium payments.

Step 3: Write an appeal letter

You will typically need to submit a written appeal letter to the insurance company. This letter should include the patient's name, policy number, and policyholder name, as well as accurate contact information for both the patient and the policyholder. It should also include the date of the denial letter, specifics on what was denied, and the cited reason for the denial. You should also include your detailed case, explaining why you believe the plan should cover the claim and citing relevant plan language. Additionally, you can ask your medical provider to prepare a letter of medical necessity, explaining prior treatments and the reason for the treatment in question. Published journal articles or treatment guidelines from industry-recognized groups or institutions can also be referenced to demonstrate outcome benefits and treatment success.

Step 4: Submit the appeal

When submitting your appeal, be sure to track the submission. If sent by mail, send it via certified mail with a return receipt requested. Keep a copy of all submitted materials and correspondence in a safe and organized place. You should receive an official notice within 7-10 days that your appeal has been received. If you do not receive confirmation, contact the insurance company to confirm that they have received your appeal.

Step 5: Remain polite

Throughout the appeal process, it is important to remain polite and professional. This will help ensure that your case is given fair consideration and that you have the best chance of a successful outcome.

Remember that the process and timeline for appeals can vary by insurer, so be sure to carefully review the information provided by your insurance company and follow their specific guidelines. If you need further assistance, you may also want to contact your state's department of insurance or attorney general, as some states employ insurance appeals specialists who can provide additional support.

File a complaint with your state insurance department

If you feel your insurer has denied your claim unfairly, you can file a complaint with your state's insurance department. This option may be best if you want the insurance department to investigate the situation and confirm whether the insurance company is in the right.

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners has a list of each state's Department of Insurance, which should have information on how to file a complaint in your state. Having the state insurance department on your side may give you some leverage in negotiations. However, state insurance departments may not always have the power to resolve certain disagreements between insurers and policyholders.

When you contact the department, you may also be made aware of additional resources you didn't realise were an option. For example, you may be able to appeal to an external third party for an independent review of your case.

Mediation: hire an impartial mediator to help reach an agreement

When a life insurance claim is denied, it can be an incredibly emotional and stressful time. If you are a beneficiary, you may wish to dispute the denial. The first step is to carefully review the denial letter and coverage details to make sure you understand the reason for the denial and confirm that you are entitled to what you believe you are.

If you decide to move forward with a dispute, you can consider mediation. Mediation involves hiring an impartial third party, or mediator, to work directly with you and a representative from the insurance company to help you come to an agreement. The mediator can be court-appointed, or both sides can agree on a private professional. You can also go through a state-sponsored mediation program, which you can usually find through your state's department of insurance website.

Mediation is typically a fast process, but it is non-binding, meaning that either side can walk away and pretend the process never happened if they don't like the outcome. It's also important to keep in mind that the insurance company representative will likely be trained for the process, whereas it will be brand new to you. The insurance company might also use mediation to feel out the strength of your case, so there is a chance you could end up wasting time and money without getting any closer to a resolution.

If you decide to pursue mediation, you and the insurance company may split the cost unless your policy or state law states that the insurer must pay.

Lawsuit: suing the insurance company is a last resort

Suing an insurance company is a last resort, but it is an option if you feel that your claim has been unfairly denied. Before you get to that stage, there are several steps you can take to dispute a denial.

First, carefully review the denial letter and coverage details to understand why your claim was denied. If the reasons are unclear, request more specific information from the insurance company.

Next, gather and assemble any additional supporting documentation that may help you contest the denial, such as medical records, autopsy reports, or insurance payment receipts.

If you still believe the denial was incorrect, you can appeal the claim by presenting evidence according to the process established by the insurer. This process and timeline will vary depending on the insurer. You may also want to consult a qualified attorney who can advise you on your legal options and help you navigate the process.

If your appeal is denied, you can contact your state's department of insurance or attorney general for assistance. They may have insurance appeals specialists who can provide expertise and carry substantial weight with the insurer.

If you feel that your insurance company has engaged in bad faith practices or unethical practices, you may be able to file a bad faith lawsuit. This is typically an option when the insurer refuses to pay a claim without a reasonable basis or proper investigation. You may also have a case for breach of contract or negligence if the insurer has broken the terms of the agreement or failed to fulfill the policy terms.

Keep in mind that suing an insurance company can be a complex, time-consuming, and expensive process. It is always best to be prepared and keep detailed records of all correspondence, relevant documents, and expenses related to your claim.

Frequently asked questions