Insurance Overpayment: What To Do?

Overpayments from insurance carriers are a common occurrence in the healthcare sector. They can happen due to a variety of reasons, including wrong estimations, coordination of benefits issues, duplicate claims, or even unintentional mistakes made by the billing staff. When an insurance carrier overpays, it is important to first determine if it is indeed an overpayment. This can be done by contacting the carrier and asking for clarification on how they calculated the payment amount. If an overpayment has occurred, the provider must take prompt action to return the excess funds to the appropriate person or payer. Failing to do so can result in legal consequences and negatively impact the provider's revenue and reputation. To avoid legal troubles and ensure compliance, providers should document all phone calls, correspondence, and checks related to the overpayment.

Notify the insurance carrier and ask for clarification on the payment sum and claim processing

When handling an overpayment from an insurance carrier, it is important to notify the insurance carrier promptly and ask for clarification on the payment sum and claim processing. Here are the steps to take:

Firstly, contact the insurance carrier that made the overpayment. Call them to discuss the payment and seek an explanation of how they determined their payment amount and if they processed the claim correctly. This step is crucial to understanding whether an overpayment has indeed occurred.

If, after the discussion, the insurance carrier confirms that they made an overpayment, request them to reprocess the claim to show the correct payment amount. At this stage, it is essential to ask the insurance carrier to send a formal, written request for the provider to return the overpaid amount. Having a written request ensures a clear paper trail and provides protection for both parties.

Once you receive the written request for the overpayment, prepare a check for the overpayment amount and attach it to the request. Send this to the address indicated in the insurance carrier's request. If they do not provide a specific address, address the envelope to the claims department and mark it as "Attn: Overpayments" to ensure it reaches the right department.

In some cases, you may receive a payment from an insurance carrier that is entirely wrong or not rightfully owed to the provider. In such instances, write "void" on the check and return it to the insurance carrier, providing a clear explanation of why the payment was not due. For example, if the payment is for a patient who was never seen by the provider, include a note with a statement such as "This patient was not seen in our office."

It is important to remember that, in some situations, what appears to be an overpayment may not actually be one. For instance, if a patient has two insurance plans, and the secondary insurance carrier pays a higher amount than the primary insurance carrier, it creates a credit balance. However, this is not an overpayment, and no money needs to be returned. Instead, the patient's balance simply needs to be adjusted to offset the credit.

Always take a meticulous and proactive approach when dealing with potential overpayments. Determine if it is a true overpayment, identify whom the overpayment needs to be returned to, and then take the necessary steps to return the funds promptly.

Document all phone calls, correspondence, and checks

When dealing with insurance overpayments, it is crucial to document all communication and financial transactions. This includes phone calls, letters, notes, checks, and other correspondence with both the patient and the insurance company.

Keeping detailed records of phone conversations is essential. Note down the date and time of the call, whom you spoke to, what was discussed, and any decisions or requests made by either party. If your practice keeps records of telephone conversations, ensure these are included with your other documentation.

For letters and other written correspondence, always keep copies. If you send a letter, make a copy before sending, and if you receive one, scan or photocopy it for your records. Keep these copies on file with any notes or letters you send or receive via email.

When sending or receiving a check, make a copy of the front and back of the check before it is cashed. Note the check number, the date, the amount, and the name of the sender/recipient. If the check is sent with a letter, ensure you have documented that letter as well.

By maintaining comprehensive documentation, you protect yourself and your practice from potential future legal action. It also provides valuable insight and guidance for handling similar situations in the future.

If the overpayment is valid, ask the insurance company about their refund process

If the overpayment is valid, the next step is to ask the insurance company about their refund process. It is important to remember that each insurance company will have its own process for handling overpayments and refunds, so it is crucial to contact them and understand their specific requirements. Here are the steps to follow:

Firstly, send a letter to the insurance company to inform them of the overpayment. It is important to never send a refund before contacting the insurance company, as mentioned by sources. Allow the insurance company at least 30 days to respond to your letter. Their response should include instructions on how to submit the refund and where to send it. This information is critical to ensure that the refund is properly processed and credited.

Once you have received the instructions, make sure to submit the refund promptly, including all the required information. Some insurance companies may prefer to recoup the overpayment from future remittances, so be sure to properly notate this in your accounts to reflect the transaction. If your practice is not financially able to accommodate such an arrangement, negotiate an alternative agreement.

If you do not receive a response from the insurance company within 30 days, it is important to take the initiative and follow up with a phone call. Remember, it is the responsibility of your practice to complete the refund process, so don't leave this step undone. Keep in mind that if the refund is due to Medicare or Medicaid, the process may differ, so be sure to follow the guidelines provided by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) for Medicare and check with your state's Medicaid office for specific instructions.

In addition, be aware of the time constraints for refunds. Compliance rules require that all refunds, regardless of size, be made within 60 days of discovering the overpayment. This helps to maintain billing compliance and avoid any potential issues with regulators.

If the insurance company cannot or will not refund, request that they reprocess the claim

If the insurance company is unable or unwilling to refund an overpayment, you can request that they reprocess the claim. This involves asking the insurance company to explain how they arrived at the payment amount and whether they processed the claim correctly. It is within your rights to ask for a formal explanation of the overpayment in writing.

If the insurance company confirms that they made an overpayment, they should reprocess the claim to reflect the correct payment amount and send a request for the overpaid amount to be returned. It is important to promptly return overpayments to the appropriate person or payer to maintain compliance and avoid legal consequences.

In the case of a patient overpayment, providers should investigate to ensure the credit is correct. If there are no outstanding services, the patient should be refunded immediately. Some providers may choose to contact the patient to explain the overpayment and offer the option of a refund or account credit. It is important to note that providers cannot legally retain overpayments indefinitely, and patient permissions must be obtained before applying credits to future visit charges.

Overpayments can occur due to wrong estimations, coordination of benefits issues, duplicate claims, or copay policies. It is advisable to document all communication, including phone calls, correspondence, and checks, with both the patient and the insurance company for future reference and protection.

Send a cheque to the insurance provider with a request for a refund

If you receive an overpayment from an insurance carrier, it's important to take prompt action to rectify the mistake and avoid any penalties. Here's a detailed guide on how to handle this situation:

Step 1: Determine if it's an Overpayment

Before taking any further steps, it's crucial to confirm whether the payment you received is indeed an overpayment. Contact the insurance carrier and ask them to explain their payment amount and how they processed the claim. This step is important because sometimes a patient may have two insurance plans, and the apparent overpayment could be due to a credit balance rather than an actual overpayment.

Step 2: Confirm the Overpayment

If the insurance carrier confirms that they made an overpayment, they should send you a request to return it. Ask them to provide a written explanation and instructions on how to return the funds. This step ensures that you have proper documentation and a clear understanding of their request.

Step 3: Prepare the Cheque and Request for Refund

Once you have received the written request from the insurance carrier, prepare a cheque for the overpayment amount. Attach this cheque to the request form and send it back to the insurance carrier. Make sure to include a clear indication of "Attn: Overpayments" on the envelope if a specific address is not provided.

Step 4: Communicate and Document

Throughout this process, it is essential to maintain clear communication with the insurance carrier. Notify them of the steps you are taking to rectify the overpayment and keep detailed records of all correspondence. This documentation will help protect you and the insurance carrier in case of any discrepancies or disputes.

Step 5: Follow Up

If you do not receive a response or written instructions from the insurance carrier within a reasonable amount of time (around 30 days), take the initiative to follow up with them. Contact them by phone or email to ensure they have received your communication and cheque. This step demonstrates your diligence in resolving the overpayment issue.

Remember, it is your responsibility to promptly return any overpayments to the appropriate party. By following these steps, you can effectively handle an overpayment from an insurance carrier and maintain a good relationship with the insurance company.

Frequently asked questions