Auto Insurance: Personal Or Driver-Specific Coverage?

Auto insurance is a complicated topic, and it can be challenging to determine whether a policy covers the car or the driver. In general, auto insurance follows the car rather than the driver, but there are exceptions and special cases to consider. For example, if you lend your car to a friend or family member with your permission, known as permissive use, and they have an accident, your insurance will typically cover the damages. However, if someone borrows your car without your permission, or non-permissive use, your insurance may not cover the damages. It's important to carefully review your policy documents and understand the coverage provided, as well as any state-specific insurance laws that may apply.

When is car insurance on the driver?

Car insurance typically follows the car, but there are times when it follows the driver. Here are some scenarios where car insurance follows the driver:

When the driver is listed on the car owner's insurance policy

If a driver is specifically listed on the car owner's insurance policy, they will usually be covered by that policy when driving the car, even if they are not the primary driver. This is often the case when a driver is added to a spouse or family member's policy.

When the driver has permission to use the car

In most cases, car insurance will cover a driver who has been given permission to use the car by the owner. This is known as "permissive use" and typically extends to drivers who are not listed on the policy. However, it's important to note that some policies may have restrictions on permissive use, such as requiring the driver to have a valid license or excluding certain individuals.

When the driver is renting a car

If a driver rents a car from a rental company or a car-sharing service, their personal car insurance will typically cover them during the rental period. This means they don't need to purchase additional rental car insurance, although it's always a good idea to check with their insurance provider to confirm the extent of their coverage.

When the driver is using a borrowed car

If a driver borrows a car from a friend or family member, their personal car insurance may provide coverage in the event of an accident. This is especially true if the driver has permission from the car owner and is listed on their policy. However, it's important to note that the coverage may be limited, and the driver's policy would typically be secondary to the car owner's policy.

When the driver has liability coverage

Liability coverage always follows the driver, regardless of the vehicle they are driving. It protects the insured driver by paying for the medical bills and vehicle repairs of the other person in the event of an accident. This means that if a driver has liability coverage on their own car insurance policy, it will typically extend to any vehicle they drive, whether borrowed or rented.

While these are some general guidelines, it's important to note that car insurance policies can vary widely, and it's always best to review the specific terms and conditions of a policy to determine what is covered and what is not. Additionally, insurance laws and regulations can vary by state, so it's essential to stay informed about the requirements in your particular location.

When is car insurance on the car?

In most cases, car insurance follows the car, not the driver. This means that if you give someone permission to use your car, your policy will cover them if they are in an accident or experience any kind of vehicle mishap. This is known as "permissive use". However, it's important to note that every policy is unique and is based on multiple factors, including state insurance laws, the policy type, and the coverage within the policy.

Your car insurance typically covers other drivers operating your vehicle if they are listed on your policy. This may include your spouse, parents, siblings, or children. It may also include other household members. For others not listed on your policy, such as friends or extended family members, coverage typically depends on consent. If you have given them permission to drive your car, then they should be covered under the terms of your policy.

There are some scenarios in which your policy will not cover another driver operating your vehicle. These include:

• The driver is paying to use the car, such as in the case of a car-sharing company.
• The driver has been specifically excluded from your policy, typically due to being a high-risk driver.
• The driver is using the vehicle for commercial purposes, such as delivering pizzas or ride-sharing.

In these cases, you may need to purchase additional coverage or a separate insurance policy to protect yourself and your vehicle.

It's important to carefully review your policy documents and understand the specific coverages and exclusions to know when your car insurance will and will not apply.

What is permissive use?

Permissive use is a clause in most auto insurance policies that allows infrequent use of a vehicle by an unlisted driver. This means that the policyholder gives a person who is not listed on their insurance policy permission to operate their vehicle. Permissive use typically applies to drivers who do not live at the same address as the policyholder, such as a family friend or neighbour, and does not include immediate family members or household members.

Permissive use is intended for short, infrequent trips and usually covers a driver using the vehicle up to 12 times per year. It is important to note that permissive use may not be included in all insurance policies, particularly those from smaller or non-standard companies. Some policies may also have exceptions or exclusions, such as not covering business use or unlicensed drivers.

In the event of an accident, the policyholder's auto insurance may pay for damages and injuries, up to the coverage limits. However, if the unlisted driver is also insured, their auto insurance policy could also pay out, depending on its details.

When is permission to drive another car implied?

Permission to drive another person's car can be either express or implied. Express permission is granted when the owner of the car gives direct, clear consent to use their vehicle, such as by handing over the keys. Implied permission, on the other hand, is assumed based on past experiences, such as having driven the car before.

Implied permission is a tricky area, and it is always better to seek express permission to avoid any legal complications. However, there are some situations where implied permission to drive another car may be assumed:

• Valet parking: When you hand over your car keys to a valet, you are implicitly giving them permission to drive your car.
• Spare car keys: If your best friend or significant other gives you their spare car keys, it is implied that you have permission to drive their car.
• Past experience: If you have been allowed to drive someone's car in the past, it may be assumed that you still have permission to do so, unless expressly revoked.
• Family members: In some cases, implied permission may be assumed for family members, especially if they have regular access to the car. However, this may vary depending on the insurance policy and state laws.

It is important to note that the specific permissions and coverages can vary by state and insurance provider. Therefore, it is always recommended to check with the vehicle owner's insurance coverage details and applicable state laws before driving their car.

What happens when an uninsured driver borrows your car?

Generally, car insurance follows the car, not the driver. This means that if you give an uninsured driver permission to drive your car, your insurance policy will cover them if they get into an accident. However, there are a few important things to keep in mind in this situation.

First, it's crucial to check the terms of your specific insurance policy. While most policies cover drivers who have been given permission to drive the insured car, some policies may have exclusions or limitations. For example, some policies may require you to list any regular drivers of your car, and failure to do so could result in denied claims or even policy cancellation. It's also important to understand the extent of the coverage provided to the uninsured driver. Standard liability coverage will cover damage to other cars and property, as well as injuries to other drivers and passengers, but it won't cover damage to your own car or the uninsured driver's injuries. For that, you would need collision and comprehensive coverage.

Second, if an uninsured driver gets into an accident while driving your car, your insurance policy will typically cover the costs up to your coverage limits. However, if the costs exceed those limits, the uninsured driver's insurance policy may be used as secondary coverage. In this case, you and the uninsured driver could be held liable for any damages or injuries beyond your policy limits. Additionally, both your and the uninsured driver's insurance rates are likely to increase as a result of the accident.

Third, it's important to consider the legal and financial risks involved in lending your car to an uninsured driver. If the uninsured driver is at fault in an accident, you could be held responsible for damages not covered by your insurance policy, including medical bills, property damage, and legal fees. These costs could be significant, and you may want to consider requiring the uninsured driver to obtain temporary insurance coverage before lending them your car.

Finally, it's worth noting that the laws and regulations regarding insurance coverage and uninsured drivers can vary by state. Therefore, it's always a good idea to consult with your insurance agent before lending your car to anyone, especially an uninsured driver. They can help you understand the specific coverage provided by your policy, as well as any potential risks or consequences.

Frequently asked questions