Earthquake Insurance: Admitted Carrier?

Admitted and non-admitted insurance carriers differ in the way they are licensed to operate. Admitted insurance carriers are licensed by the state in which they provide coverage, whereas non-admitted carriers are only licensed in the state where they are domiciled. This means that admitted carriers must follow strict form and rate regulations set by the state's department of insurance, while non-admitted carriers are free from these restrictions. As a result, non-admitted carriers can offer coverage for atypical dangers and higher-risk levels, and charge higher premiums.

In the context of earthquake insurance, non-admitted carriers are commonly used to provide coverage. This is because the risk of earthquakes is considered a catastrophic exposure, and very few admitted carriers are willing to take on the risk of providing coverage at a fixed price. Non-admitted carriers can offer the necessary flexibility in terms of rates and coverage to insure against earthquakes.

Admitted carriers are licensed by the state of California, which controls their operations

Admitted carriers are licensed by the state of California, which controls several aspects of their operations. This means that these insurance carriers are subject to the regulations of the state and are required to comply with them.

The state controls and verifies the financial requirements, policy forms used, rate approvals, and claims handling of admitted carriers. Admitted carriers must submit their rates to the California Department of Insurance and obtain approval. They are not permitted to alter their rates without repeating the application process. Additionally, each admitted carrier is mandated to participate in the California Insurance Guarantee Act (CIGA). This acts as a safety net, ensuring that claims are paid out even if the carrier goes bankrupt. The fund will cover claims of up to $500,000. Admitted carriers are also required to file their rates with the state of California, allowing customers to request an investigation from the California Department of Insurance if there are any concerns about the carrier's claims practices.

The state's control over admitted carriers provides benefits such as guaranteed coverage for small businesses and the option to appeal decisions to the state department of insurance if there are issues with claim handling. However, the stringent regulations may also result in a lack of flexibility in coverage options, making it challenging for businesses with unique or specific risks to obtain tailored insurance.

In contrast, non-admitted carriers operate with more flexibility, as they are not bound by the same state regulations. They are allowed to sell insurance without submitting their rates to the California Department of Insurance, but they must demonstrate their solvency and maintain reserves to pay claims. Non-admitted carriers are included in the List of Available Surplus Lines Insurers (LASLI) to assure customers that the state has reviewed them.

Non-admitted carriers are free from state-imposed form and rate regulations

Non-admitted carriers are not bound by most of the rate and form regulations imposed on standard market companies. This means they are free from state-imposed form and rate regulations. They can change the coverage offered and the rate charged without the time constraints and financial costs associated with the filing process. This is beneficial for both the company and the policyholder.

Non-admitted carriers are not required to be licensed by the state, but they are allowed to do business in that state. They are often referred to as E&S or unlicensed carriers. However, despite not being licensed, E&S carriers are financially stable companies that are regulated in other ways.

Unlike admitted carriers, non-admitted carriers are not backed by the state. They are not required to sell policies that adhere to the same standards as admitted carriers. However, they are still regulated by the states in which they operate.

The less rigid standards of non-admitted carriers give them more flexibility when designing coverage, selling policies, and writing risks. This means they can insure complicated, specific risks that the standard insurance market won't cover. For example, a business owner may struggle to find an admitted insurer to cover property damage from a hurricane or wildfire. In such cases, non-admitted carriers provide a valuable service.

Non-admitted carriers are particularly relevant when it comes to earthquake insurance. Earthquake insurance is commonly written through non-admitted carriers. With catastrophic exposures like earthquakes, very few carriers operate with admitted status as it is too risky for them to be committed to providing coverage at an inflexible price. By operating with non-admitted status, carriers can create the flexibility they need to offer earthquake insurance.

Admitted insurance products are state-guaranteed, while non-admitted products are not

Admitted insurance products are those that are approved and regulated by the state. Admitted insurance providers are licensed by the state insurance departments and must adhere to the regulations regarding policy forms, rate approvals, and claims handling. The state insurance fund will also step in to pay the claims if an admitted insurance company fails. Admitted insurance policyholders have the right to appeal to the state insurance department if they believe their claim has been mishandled.

Non-admitted insurance products, on the other hand, are not approved or regulated by the state. Non-admitted insurance carriers are not required to follow the same state regulations as admitted carriers. If a non-admitted insurance company fails, the state will not step in to make payments on claims. Non-admitted insurance carriers are considered riskier because there are no state-backed protection mechanisms in place.

In the context of earthquake insurance, non-admitted carriers are commonly used to provide coverage. This is because the risk of catastrophic exposures like earthquakes is too high for most admitted carriers. Admitted carriers are committed to providing a certain amount of coverage at a fixed price, which can lead to over-exposure and a lack of flexibility in protecting their investments. By operating as non-admitted carriers, insurance companies can create the necessary flexibility to manage the risks associated with earthquake insurance.

Admitted insurance is usually less expensive than non-admitted coverage

Non-admitted carriers, on the other hand, do business through wholesale brokers in states where they do not have insurance licenses and are not required to follow the same state regulations as admitted carriers. They are, however, regulated by the state surplus lines office. Non-admitted carriers have more flexibility in the risks they insure, which helps them offer coverage for business risks that the regular insurance market won't cover. For example, if your business is located in an area that's high-risk for natural disasters like earthquakes, you may need to work with a non-admitted insurance company for property coverage.

One of the main benefits of buying insurance from an admitted insurance carrier is the avoidance of certain fees or taxes on the policy. Since the company follows state regulations, these expenses are unnecessary. In the case of admitted insurance, the state guaranty fund will step in and cover your claims if the insurance company fails. Admitted insurance companies are also required to participate in the California Insurance Guarantee Act (CIGA), which acts as insurance for insurance. If a carrier goes bankrupt and cannot pay out on a claim, CIGA provides a pool of money funded by participating carriers to pay claims up to a certain limit.

Non-admitted insurance carriers, on the other hand, do not have to operate under state insurance laws, and there is no guarantee that the state will step in to pay claims if the company becomes insolvent. This makes non-admitted insurance carriers riskier in the eyes of some. Non-admitted carriers are allowed to sell insurance without filing their rates with the California Department of Insurance, but they must prove to the state that they have a certain level of solvency and money set aside in reserves to pay claims.

When it comes to earthquake insurance specifically, it is commonly written through non-admitted carriers. Very few carriers operate with admitted status for catastrophic exposures like earthquakes because it is too risky for them to be committed to providing coverage at an inflexible price. Non-admitted status allows them to create the necessary flexibility in their pricing and coverage options.

Non-admitted carriers are overseen by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Non-admitted carriers are not approved or licensed by the state and are also known as "excess and surplus lines" carriers. They are overseen by the Surplus Lines Offices, which are far less strict than the Department of Insurance. Non-admitted carriers are also regulated by a state's Surplus Lines Office, but this oversight is less invasive than that of admitted carriers. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) is a regulatory support organisation created and governed by the main insurance regulators from all 50 states, the District of Columbia, and five US territories.

The NAIC was formed in 1871 and has evolved into the US standard-setting and regulatory support organisation for the insurance industry. It performs and provides various tasks and services, including accrediting national solvency standards, overseeing centralised processing for licensing, rate and form filing, facilitating peer review, and conducting regulatory oversight.

The NAIC's regulatory goals are to protect the public interest, promote competitive markets, facilitate fair and equitable treatment of insurance consumers, promote the reliability and financial solidity of insurance institutions, and support and improve state regulation of insurance. The association also offers programs, information, and online tools for insurance consumers.

Non-admitted carriers have greater flexibility in writing and designing policies to meet unique and specific underwriting risks. They are not bound by state-approved policies and can offer coverage for risks that admitted carriers cannot or will not insure, such as earthquake insurance or coverage for communities with significant loss histories.

While non-admitted carriers are not backed by the state guaranty fund, they must still prove to the state that they have a certain level of solvency and money set aside in reserves to pay claims. This information is made available to consumers through the List of Available Surplus Lines Insurers (LASLI), which provides confidence that the carrier has been reviewed by the state.

Frequently asked questions