Farmers Insurance Financial Woes: Is The Industry Giant In Hot Water?

Farmers Insurance is one of the largest insurance companies in the United States, offering a wide range of insurance products, including auto, home, renters, life, business, and general liability insurance. The company has received mixed reviews, with some customers praising its quick and efficient claims process and affordable rates, while others complain about delays in the claims process and slow roadside assistance response times. In terms of financial trouble, there is no indication that Farmers Insurance is in financial distress. However, the company has been criticised for its handling of car accident claims, with reports suggesting that it focuses on maximising profits by avoiding payouts. Overall, Farmers Insurance appears to be a reputable company with a strong financial standing, but customers should be aware of potential issues when filing claims.

Farmers Insurance is one of the largest insurers in the US, offering a wide range of insurance products

For instance, the company offers homeowners insurance, protecting your home and property from disasters such as fires or other covered causes of loss. Farmers also provides landlord and rental property insurance, safeguarding landlords from unforeseen tenant troubles and rental property investments. Additionally, they offer life insurance, enabling individuals to secure their family's financial future, and business insurance, helping small businesses navigate the complexities of selecting the right coverage.

Farmers Insurance also specializes in recreational insurance, ensuring that customers can enjoy their outdoor adventures without worrying about insurance. This includes coverage for boats, travel trailers, ATVs, and motor homes. Furthermore, they offer umbrella insurance, providing added protection above and beyond the liability limits of auto or home insurance policies.

The company also provides various specialized insurance options, such as earthquake insurance, flood insurance, and second home insurance, ensuring that customers can find tailored coverage for their unique circumstances. With a network of over 48,000 independent agents across the country and availability in all 50 states, Farmers Insurance is a prominent and accessible choice for individuals seeking comprehensive insurance solutions.

The company has been accused of focusing on maximising profits by avoiding paying car accident claims

Farmers Insurance Group is one of the largest insurance companies in the United States, offering a wide range of insurance products and services, including auto, home, life, and business insurance. While the company has a strong financial standing and a history of profitability, it has also been the subject of criticism and legal action for its claims handling practices.

There have been several accusations and reports of Farmers Insurance focusing on maximising profits by avoiding paying car accident claims. Here are some key points and examples to support this:

• In recent years, Consumer Reports gave Farmers Insurance a "Worse" rating for "Problems with Claims" and "Delayed Payments." They were also listed as one of the "poorest performers" in terms of paying off automobile claims promptly.
• The American Association for Justice (AAJ) ranked Farmers on its "Ten Worst Insurance Companies in America" report due to their strategies to increase premiums and policies that limit payouts.
• There are reports and testimonials of Farmers Insurance denying or delaying valid claims, using various tactics to minimise payouts. For example, they may challenge the severity of injuries, dispute the cause of injuries, or try to shift blame and claim that the policyholder contributed to the accident.
• Farmers Insurance has been criticised for using the Colossus software to analyse and settle claims. This program is designed to minimise payouts and may not adequately consider the unique circumstances of each accident victim.
• Farmers Insurance adjusters have been accused of having incentives to lowball claimants. There are reports of adjusters receiving rewards and positive evaluations for keeping claim payments low, regardless of the validity of the claims.
• Farmers Insurance has faced legal action and been ordered to pay significant amounts in some cases where they were found to have handled claims in bad faith or denied valid claims.
• In one notable case, Farmers Insurance denied coverage to a 60-year-old policyholder who was in a coma for nine days following a car accident, claiming that the accident was due to road rage and not covered as an "accident".

Farmers Insurance has received poor ratings from Consumer Reports and JD Power for its handling of claims

Consumer Reports

Consumer Reports gave Farmers Insurance a "Worse" rating for both "Problems with Claims" and "Delayed Payments". They also stated that Farmers was one of the "poorest performers" among major insurance companies in terms of paying off automobile claims in 30 days or less.

JD Power

In the 2023 Auto Insurance Study by JD Power, Farmers scored below average in every region where it was scored. However, in the 2023 Auto Claims Satisfaction Study, Farmers came in at exactly average.

In the 2022 U.S. Insurance Shopping Study, Farmers earned 862 points out of 1,000, just one point below the segment average for large insurers.

In the 2022 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, Farmers scored 809 points out of a possible 1,000, which falls below the industry average of 820 points.

Other Ratings

In the 2023 Property Claims Satisfaction Study by JD Power, Farmers was ranked in the bottom two slots.

In the 2020 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, Farmers was rated 835 out of 1,000, unchanged from the year before.

The company has also been criticised for its use of a computer program called Colossus to determine settlement offers, which often results in lowball offers

Farmers Insurance is one of many insurance companies that uses a computer program called Colossus to determine settlement offers. Colossus is designed to minimize personal injury claims, and Farmers claim adjusters are forced to use the program's calculations due to company policies. The program analyzes medical records and financial statements and then recommends a settlement for medical costs, lost wages, and pain and suffering. However, this amount is often much lower than the true value of the claim.

Colossus's system has a hidden and secret rules-based system to convert a series of inputs about the nature and severity of injuries into a relative numeric score of conscious pain and suffering. Colossus contains approximately 600 injury codes representing various injury types, each with a "severity value" that assigns money for each severity point the claimant "earns". After considering the attorneys involved and the venue, the system counts the points and computes a dollar value. Colossus also identifies attorneys who are less likely to file a lawsuit and are more willing to settle for a lower offer.

While the premise behind Colossus is not inherently flawed, the problem lies in its execution. Insurance companies do not understand the 10,000 rules used by Colossus or simply do not care. They know that Colossus calculates insurance payouts in a way that advances their mission of paying out as little as possible. By using this system, insurance companies will try to decrease the value of claims by not taking into account X-factors such as stress, pain, inconvenience, loss of enjoyment of life, and other intangible impacts that juries and judges would consider.

Additionally, Colossus does not account for the fact that every accident victim will have a unique experience. Even two people who suffer traumatic brain injuries in car accidents will likely differ in the length of hospitalization, medical concerns, recovery time, effects on their ability to work, types of rehabilitative therapy required, and emotional effects of living with their injuries. When determining an insurance settlement, adjusters should evaluate each claim on an individual basis, considering the specific short-term and long-term effects of the injury on the victim.

Farmers Insurance has been criticized for using Colossus to automatically cut 20% from what they know they owe on a claim. Leaked internal memos revealed that the salaries and bonuses of adjusters like Robert Dietz, a former Senior Claims Adjuster for Farmers, were tied to practices that encouraged the delay, denial, underpayment, and forced litigation of claims. One document instructed adjusters to settle small claims below their value and learn to say "sorry, no more" with a toothy grin.

Farmers Insurance offers a variety of coverage options and add-ons, including rideshare insurance, accident forgiveness, and new car replacement coverage

Farmers Insurance offers a wide range of coverage options and add-ons, including rideshare insurance, accident forgiveness, and new car replacement coverage.

Rideshare Insurance

Rideshare insurance is an optional add-on to a personal car insurance policy for customers who use their personal vehicle to drive for a rideshare company. Farmers rideshare insurance provides more coverage than the insurance offered by Uber and Lyft. It covers you by your personal auto policy while the app is on but before you accept a ride request.

Accident Forgiveness

Farmers Insurance offers accident forgiveness to eligible customers, which can help drivers avoid the steep insurance rate hike that can follow an at-fault accident. Farmers accident forgiveness prevents a single at-fault accident per policy from increasing premiums once every three years.

New Car Replacement Coverage

Farmers Insurance offers new car replacement coverage, which pays to replace a totaled car with a brand-new vehicle of a similar make and model. This coverage is available if your car is two model years old or newer and has fewer than 24,000 miles.

Frequently asked questions