Flood Insurance: Federal Vs Private — Cheaper Option?

Flood insurance is a separate policy from homeowners insurance and is often overlooked by homeowners. However, it is an important consideration as 99% of counties in the U.S. are impacted by flooding, and the average payout on a flood claim is $52,000. The National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) is the most popular option for flood insurance and is backed by the federal government. However, private flood insurance has become an increasingly popular alternative due to its lower cost, higher protection limits, and additional coverages. This article will explore the differences between federal and private flood insurance and help you decide which option is best for you.

Private flood insurance is often cheaper than federal insurance

Private flood insurance can cover more expensive homes and provide better coverage. For example, federal insurance has a maximum coverage limit of $250,000 for the building and $100,000 for possessions. Private insurance can offer twice that or more, especially if your property is located in an area with a lower flood risk. Private insurance can also be tailored to the value of luxury possessions, whereas federal insurance limits the total value of covered jewellery, artwork, furs, and other collectibles to $2,500.

Private flood insurance also has shorter waiting periods than federal insurance. Federal insurance requires a 30-day waiting period for new policies, whereas some private insurers allow coverage to begin in as little as 10 or 14 days.

Private flood insurance can also be cheaper than federal insurance. The average annual premium for federal insurance is around $700, according to the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). Private flood insurance costs an average of $1,170 per year, or $98 per month. However, this can vary depending on the company and the value and flood risk of your home.

It's important to note that private flood insurance can be riskier than federal insurance. Private insurance companies can increase rates or drop coverage if they deem a property too risky, whereas federal insurance will always provide coverage. Additionally, federal insurance has more consistent rates, while private insurance rates can change each year.

Private policies can be written more quickly

Private flood insurance policies can be written more quickly than federal policies. The National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) requires a 30-day waiting period after first paying the premium for a new policy. On the other hand, some private insurers have the same requirement, but others allow you to be covered in as little as 10 or 14 days from opening and paying for the policy. This makes private flood insurance a preferred option during hurricane season for residents who need coverage right away.

However, it's important to note that private flood insurance is less dependable than federal policies. While the NFIP guarantees renewal of its policies, a private insurer may elect not to renew a policy or even cancel it. As private flood policies are newer products, there is uncertainty about what policies might cost in the future and which companies will continue to offer them.

When considering private flood insurance, it's crucial to shop around and compare rates from different companies. While private flood insurance is often cheaper than federal policies, there are times when the NFIP will cost less, especially in areas of low risk for floods. Additionally, private flood insurance rates can vary based on the company, as each company sets its own rates based on their assessment of the property's risk.

It's also worth noting that private flood insurance policies can be customised to meet specific coverage needs. They typically include coverage for additional living expenses, such as hotel stays and restaurant meals, if you're unable to live in your home after a flood. Private insurance also offers higher coverage limits and broader protection for personal belongings, including expensive items such as artwork, jewellery, and business equipment.

Private insurance covers possessions more flexibly

Private insurance offers more flexibility in covering possessions than federal flood insurance. While the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) offers a total of $100,000 for possessions, private insurance can allow for higher coverage limits. For instance, privatemarketflood, an online insurance broker, offers up to $500,000 in coverage for a residential building, double the NFIP limit.

The NFIP limits the total value of covered jewellery, artwork, furs, and other collectibles to $2,500. This limit could be easily reached or surpassed by art owners, and would be insufficient for serious collectors. Private insurance, on the other hand, allows for a policy to be tailored to the value of luxury possessions. It enables policyholders to specify higher coverage amounts for high-value items, ensuring adequate protection for their possessions.

Private insurance also offers reimbursement for living expenses if flooding renders a home uninhabitable. This feature, commonly found in homeowners insurance policies, is not provided by NFIP policies. Therefore, private insurance provides more comprehensive coverage for possessions and living expenses, making it a more flexible option for individuals with valuable assets or those facing displacement due to flood damage.

Additionally, private insurance can be purchased as an "excess" policy, providing additional coverage on top of a base NFIP policy. This allows individuals to customise their coverage based on their specific needs and the level of protection they require for their possessions.

Private insurance has higher coverage limits

Private flood insurance policies typically offer higher coverage limits than federal flood insurance. The maximum coverage limit for a federal policy is $250,000 for the building and $100,000 for its contents. This is often insufficient for more expensive homes, as the limit falls short of the median US home price.

Private flood insurance policies, on the other hand, can offer twice the coverage or more. For example, Flood Guard offers policies with up to $5 million in building coverage and Neptune Flood Insurance offers up to $4 million. Similarly, while federal policies limit the total value of covered jewellery, artwork, furs, and other collectibles to $2,500, private insurance allows for higher coverage limits for luxury possessions.

Private insurance policies also offer additional living expenses coverage, reimbursing living expenses in the event that flooding makes your home uninhabitable. This is another aspect of coverage that federal policies do not include.

Furthermore, private flood insurance policies can be purchased as "excess" coverage, providing additional coverage on top of a base federal policy. This allows homeowners to fill gaps between a base federal policy and their actual flood insurance needs.

Private insurance is less dependable

Private flood insurance is less dependable than federal policies. The National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) guarantees the renewal of its policies, but a private insurer may elect not to renew a policy or even cancel it. Private flood insurance is a new product, so there is uncertainty about what policies might cost in the future and which companies may still be writing them.

Since private flood policies are new, there is uncertainty about their future costs and which companies will continue to offer them. Private insurers can also choose not to renew a policy or cancel it if they deem a property too risky. This is not the case with the NFIP, which will always provide coverage regardless of a property's risk level.

Private flood insurance is also riskier than federal policies because insurance companies can increase rates or drop customers. In contrast, rates through the government are more stable and guaranteed. Private flood insurance companies also do not have to follow the government's coverage rules, so there is a possibility of reduced coverage.

While private flood insurance offers benefits such as lower prices, higher policy limits, and quicker coverage, it is less dependable than federal policies due to the uncertainties and risks mentioned above.

Frequently asked questions