Overlapping Auto Insurance: Is It A Smart Move?

Auto insurance overlap occurs when an individual has two active insurance policies for a specific period of time, usually when switching to a new plan or changing insurance providers. While it may be legal in some states, it is generally not recommended as it can lead to complications in claims processing, increased costs, and potential delays or disputes over coverage. In the event of an accident, individuals are only eligible to file one claim, and only one insurance company can process that claim. To avoid overlap, it is important to strategically determine the activation and cancellation dates of insurance policies and communicate any changes to the insurance providers.

Overlapping insurance can lead to complications in claims processing

Secondly, filing claims with two insurance companies can be complicated, and claim approvals may become more difficult. The previous insurance carrier may be required to reimburse damages in the event of an accident, but they have the right to reject a claim if certain conditions have been violated. Having two active insurance plans can benefit the policyholder, but it goes against the primary purpose of insurance, which is to cover losses.

Thirdly, in the case of overlapping insurance, the "other insurance clause" comes into play. This clause dictates which policy would cover the loss, and it can result in coordination issues and disagreements between the insurance providers. The primary policy will compensate up to its coverage limit, and the secondary policy will cover the difference if needed. However, it may not be clear which policy is primary and which is secondary, leading to further delays and confusion.

Finally, overlapping insurance can result in increased costs for the policyholder. They will be paying premiums for two insurance policies, and if a claim is filed, the renewal price may increase significantly for both policies. Additionally, the policyholder may lose any no-claims bonus or discounts they were previously entitled to.

It is possible to have two car insurance policies

Overlapping insurance policies can occur for several reasons. It may be a deliberate attempt to commit fraud by making multiple claims. However, most of the time, it happens accidentally. This can happen due to a mistake with renewal dates, resulting in two policies overlapping by a few days or more. Automatic renewal of policies can also lead to overlap if the previous insurer automatically takes payment for the next period and you have already taken out a new policy with a different insurer.

To avoid overlapping insurance policies, it is important to carefully review the terms and conditions of your policy and be aware of any auto-renewal dates. If you intend to switch insurance providers or plans, you can prevent overlap by strategically determining the activation and cancellation dates of the policies.

Auto insurance overlap can happen accidentally

Another common cause of accidental auto insurance overlap is the automatic renewal of policies. When signing up for insurance, the insurer may offer automatic renewal, which may be hidden in the small print. If the current insurer takes payment for the next period and the individual have already taken out a new policy with a different insurer, they may unintentionally be covered by two policies.

While it may be legal in some states, having overlapping auto insurance is generally not recommended as it can lead to complications and disputes in the event of a claim. In the case of an accident, both insurance companies may refuse to pay, leaving the individual without coverage despite paying double the premiums. Additionally, making claims to two different insurance companies for the same accident is considered unjust enrichment and is illegal.

Having two insurance policies doesn't provide additional coverage

Having two auto insurance policies is not a good idea, even if it is legal in your state. This is because, in the event of an accident, you can only file one claim, and only one insurance company can process that claim. This means that you will be paying double the premium for no added benefit.

In the case of an accident, both insurance companies may try to prove why they should not be held liable for the loss, leading to delays in the claims being resolved. This usually happens when one plan provides more comprehensive coverage than the other. The dispute between the two insurance companies can add to the stress of an already stressful situation.

Additionally, having two insurance policies can result in higher premium costs from both insurers after a claim. You could also lose any no-claims bonus from both providers. Therefore, it is important to strategically determine the activation and cancellation dates of your insurance policies to avoid overlap.

While it may be tempting to overlap policies to ensure your car is well-insured, it is illegal in some states and will not provide any additional coverage. Instead, it is recommended to sit down with your insurance agent and discuss adding more coverage to your existing policy. Most insurance companies can add more coverage to your policy at a minimal cost, providing you with extended coverage without the need for a second policy.

Overlapping insurance is not illegal but is also not recommended

Overlapping insurance can also make the claims process more complicated and lengthy. If there are two current insurance policies, both insurers may try to demonstrate why they should not be held liable for the loss. This can result in delays in the claims being resolved and cause additional stress in an already stressful situation.

Additionally, having two insurance policies can be costly. You will be paying premiums for both policies, which can significantly increase your insurance costs without providing any additional benefits or coverage.

To avoid overlapping insurance, it is essential to carefully monitor the start and end dates of your policies. Be sure to cancel your previous policy on the day your new policy starts. Communicate with both your old and new insurance companies to ensure a smooth transition and avoid any gaps in coverage.

In summary, while overlapping insurance may be legal in some states, it is generally not recommended due to the potential complications, increased costs, and lack of additional benefits. It is best to have a single policy that meets your coverage needs or to use multiple car insurance policies if you have more than one vehicle.

Frequently asked questions