Life Insurance And Islam: Halal Or Haram?

Life insurance is a contentious issue in the Islamic faith. While some scholars argue that it is haram, or forbidden, because it involves deceit, others contend that it is permissible and even necessary to protect one's family. The debate centres around the presence of elements such as gharar (uncertainty), maysir (gambling), and riba (interest) in life insurance policies, which are considered haram in Islam. Islamic scholars have proposed alternatives such as the Takaful model, which is a Shariah-compliant insurance system based on cooperation and shared profit/loss.

Is term life insurance halal?

Term life insurance is considered halal in Islam, provided that the underlying investments are permissible according to Islamic law. Term life insurance is a protective insurance policy that covers lost income when the insured dies, including costs such as mortgage payments.

Term insurance policies are generally permissible because they do not involve interest, gambling, or deceit, all of which are prohibited in Islam. Interest, or riba, is forbidden in Islam, and it is not usually present in term life insurance plans. Gambling is also prohibited, and while conventional insurance policies can be seen as having a gambling element, term life insurance policies do not have a profit element, and so this argument is weak. Finally, deceit, or gharar, is also forbidden in Islam, and while this is more applicable to term life insurance due to the uncertainty of death, it is argued that modern insurance policies are less speculative than they may seem, as insurance companies undertake due diligence to ensure risks are measurable and contained.

However, it is important to note that the permissibility of term life insurance depends on the specific details of the policy and the underlying investments. Muslims seeking term life insurance should ensure that the policy does not include any elements that are prohibited by Islamic law, such as interest, gambling, or deceit. Additionally, the investments made with the policy funds should be permissible and compliant with Sharia law.

In summary, term life insurance is generally considered halal in Islam, but it is the responsibility of the individual to ensure that the specific policy and its underlying investments comply with Islamic principles.

Is whole life insurance halal?

Whole life insurance is a form of life assurance that guarantees a pay-out to loved ones when the insured person dies. These types of policies continue to provide lifelong protection by the operators of the insurance policy. Whole life insurance is also known as life assurance. It essentially operates to ensure that whenever you die, your family is protected financially. There is no uncertainty about the monies being paid out, but you do have to maintain premium payments on an ongoing basis.

Whole life insurance is deemed permissible in Islam if the underlying investments are permissible. In the Middle East, this is not a problem if you opt to go with a takaful operator who will be restricted by their internal policies to invest only in halal assets. In the UK, however, it is more difficult as standard insurers will almost certainly put large amounts of the policy amount into fixed-income (interest-based) products.

There are two ways to deal with this: either one gets a policy where one can dictate what underlying investments the policy is invested in (and then opt for all Shariah-compliant assets), or one chooses a policy where the underlying assets are largely Shariah-compliant, and then gives away as charity the portion that is not.

In summary, whole life insurance is considered halal if the investments are permissible. This is more difficult to achieve in the West, but not impossible.

What is the Islamic perspective on gharar?

Gharar is an Arabic term that refers to uncertainty, ambiguity, deception, or risk in a transaction. In Islamic finance, it is considered prohibited as it goes against the principles of fairness, justice, transparency, certainty, and openness in business dealings. The concept of gharar is significant in ensuring fair and just transactions, fostering an ethical financial environment.

Islamic scholars have provided guidelines to avoid gharar, emphasising the need for clear terms and conditions, absence of ambiguity, and disclosure of critical information. This includes transparent and well-defined details about the subject matter, price, delivery terms, and conditions. The quantity, quality, and specifications of goods or services must be explicitly defined, leaving no room for uncertainty. Both parties involved should also be aware of any hidden defects or potential uncertainties that may impact the outcome of the transaction.

In the context of life insurance, the presence of gharar has been a subject of debate. Some argue that life insurance policies, particularly term insurance policies, contain elements of gharar due to the uncertainty surrounding the timing of death and the potential for the insurance company to profit from premiums if the insured does not die within the specified term. However, modern insurance policies are based on due diligence, health assessments, and historical data, making them less speculative. Additionally, Islam has permitted some gharar in transactions that provide significant benefits.

According to scholars, gharar can be categorised into two types: gharar fahish ("excess" gharar) and gharar yasir ("light" gharar). Gharar fahish, also known as gharar-e-kathir or "too much" gharar, is considered haram and is discussed in ahadith. On the other hand, gharar yasir, or "nominal" gharar, refers to small or trivial amounts of gharar that are tolerated and deemed halal.

In summary, the Islamic perspective on gharar emphasises the importance of transparency, fairness, and certainty in financial transactions. While gharar is generally prohibited, scholars acknowledge that some degree of gharar is acceptable, particularly when it is trivial and does not exploit the other party. In the case of life insurance, the debate centres around the level of uncertainty and the potential for exploitation, with whole life insurance policies being seen as more compliant with Sharia laws due to the guaranteed payout upon death.

What is the Islamic perspective on riba?

The Arabic word 'riba' means 'to increase' or 'to exceed' and is used to refer to excessive charges for borrowing money. Charging interest on loans is deemed riba and is forbidden under Islamic law. It is considered both illegal and unethical or usurious.

Riba is prohibited under Sharia law to ensure equity in commerce. Islam aims to encourage charity and helping others through kindness, and discourages acting upon motives of selfishness and self-centredness. By making riba illegal, Sharia law creates opportunities and contexts in which people are encouraged to act charitably by loaning money without interest.

Riba is mentioned and condemned in several verses in the Quran. Allah has forbidden all transactions that are based on riba, and all transactions that involve deceit.

There are two forms of riba: riba al-nasiyah (riba in a loan contract) and riba al-fadl (riba in a sale or exchange contract). In both types, the transaction must be a fair exchange, with neither party exploiting the other.

While Muslims agree that riba is prohibited, there is debate over what precisely it is and whether it is against Sharia law or only discouraged. Some modern Islamic scholars believe that interest should be permitted up to the value of inflation to compensate lenders for the time value of their money without creating excessive profit.

Islamic banking has provided workarounds to riba, including a profit-sharing system in which borrowers agree to return a portion of their profits as payment for the loan.

What is Takaful?

Takaful is a type of Islamic insurance based on the values of social solidarity and cooperation. It is derived from the word 'kafalah', which means joint guarantee in Arabic. Takaful is based on sharia or Islamic religious law, which explains how individuals are responsible for cooperating and protecting one another.

Takaful insurance companies were introduced as an alternative to those in the commercial insurance industry, believed to go against Islamic restrictions on riba (interest), al-maisir (gambling), and al-gharar (uncertainty) principles—all of which are outlawed in sharia.

Takaful is a mutual agreement where members contribute money to a pool or fund that guarantees each other against loss or damage. This is different from traditional insurance, where the risk is transferred from the insured to the insurer. Takaful participants contribute to a takaful fund instead of paying premiums, and the amount is based on the type of coverage required and their personal circumstances.

A takaful contract specifies the nature of the risk and the length of the coverage, similar to a conventional insurance policy. The takaful fund is managed and administered on behalf of the participants by a takaful operator, who charges a fee to cover costs. Claims made by participants are paid out of the takaful fund, and any remaining surpluses, after provisions for future claims and reserves, are returned to the participants.

Takaful insurance policies cover health, life, and general insurance needs. Takaful operators and contributions are found mostly in the Middle East, North Africa, and Southeast Asia, including countries like Bahrain, Brunei, Egypt, Indonesia, and Malaysia.

In summary, Takaful is a form of Islamic insurance that provides financial protection based on mutual cooperation and compliance with Sharia law. It involves pooling funds to guarantee against losses and is managed by a takaful operator, with any surpluses returned to the participants. Takaful is available in various regions and offers a range of insurance coverage, including life insurance.

Frequently asked questions