American Insurance Industry: A Declining Service?

The insurance industry in America is facing a challenging time due to various factors, including the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, technological advancements, and the growing frequency and severity of extreme weather events driven by climate change. These challenges have disrupted the traditional business models of insurance companies, and they are having to adapt to stay afloat.

One of the main issues is the increasing cost of insurance, particularly for car and home insurance. The cost of car insurance has surged, with US car owners now paying a national average annual premium of $2,543 for full coverage. This rise is attributed to factors such as higher repair costs, escalating vehicle thefts, rising medical bills, and costly extreme weather claims. Home insurance premiums have also increased significantly, especially in states like Florida, California, and Louisiana, which are vulnerable to climate change impacts.

The insurance industry is also facing challenges due to the need to digitize and virtualize their operations, as well as the impact of the pandemic on their workforce and customer engagement. They are having to invest in technology and innovation to remain competitive and meet changing customer expectations.

Additionally, climate change is having a significant impact on the insurance industry, with extreme weather events making it harder to insure homes in certain parts of the US. The frequency and severity of disasters, such as hurricanes, floods, and wildfires, have led to insurers pulling out of high-risk markets and leaving residents struggling to find affordable coverage.

The insurance industry in America is at a crossroads, and how it adapts to these challenges will shape its future.

Rising inflation and supply chain issues

The impact of inflation on insurance rates has been a growing concern for both insurance companies and their customers. As inflation drives up the costs of goods and services across the economy, the insurance sector, due to its reliance on various other industries, is particularly vulnerable to inflation-related cost increases. This has led to a surge in insurance premiums across various types of insurance, including auto, health, and home insurance. The average full-coverage auto insurance premium in the United States, for example, has seen an increase of about 17% since 2020.

Housing and labour costs, as well as the microchip shortage, have also played a role in rising insurance rates. The increased cost of construction materials and labour has resulted in higher repair and replacement costs for damaged property, leading to higher claims payouts for property and casualty insurance. The microchip shortage has had a similar effect on the auto industry, with higher costs for new cars resulting in higher insurance premiums.

Supply chain disruptions have had a significant impact on businesses, leading to revenue losses and increased costs. This, in turn, has resulted in higher insurance claims as businesses seek to protect themselves from financial losses. The COVID-19 pandemic, for instance, highlighted major gaps in supply chain systems, with essential workers in manufacturing, distribution, warehousing, and trucking facing unsafe working conditions and labour shortages. This led to backlogs, perishable goods spoilage, and damage to goods due to rushed and understaffed handling.

Geopolitical tensions, such as the Russia-Ukraine conflict, have further exacerbated supply chain issues. The invasion of Ukraine affected maritime activities in and around the Black Sea, adding weeks to shipping times and creating knock-on effects such as cash flow difficulties and production line shortages. These disruptions have a domino effect on the interconnected web of suppliers, manufacturers, and retailers worldwide, ultimately resulting in increased costs that are passed on to consumers.

To navigate these challenges, the insurance industry has had to adopt a more dynamic and innovative approach. Insurance companies have had to re-evaluate their risk assessment models, revise coverage terms and conditions, and develop new products to address emerging risks. Collaboration and transparency between insurers and policyholders are also crucial to building trust and enhancing their ability to manage risks effectively.

Climate change and extreme weather events

The impact of climate change on the insurance industry is twofold. Firstly, there is the direct impact of extreme weather events causing widespread destruction and increasing the cost of insurance claims. For example, in 2023, damages from billion-dollar extreme weather events in the US reached $92.9 billion, with estimated insured property losses totalling $78.8 billion. This has led to insurance companies hiking premium prices and even pulling back coverage for certain high-risk areas. The increasing frequency and severity of claims have put pressure on the profitability of insurance companies, leading to concerns about their long-term viability.

Secondly, climate change is causing a shift in risk profiles, making it harder to insure homes in certain parts of the US. This is particularly evident in areas vulnerable to climate change, such as California, Florida, and Louisiana. The combination of rising sea levels and the increased frequency of extreme weather events, such as hurricanes, floods, and wildfires, has made these states too costly for insurers. As a result, many insurance companies have pulled out of these states, leaving residents struggling to find affordable coverage.

The abandonment of these high-risk areas by insurance companies has created a protection gap, with an estimated 1 in 13, or 6.1 million, homeowners now uninsured. This gap disproportionately affects low-income communities and communities of colour, who are most likely to live in climate-vulnerable geographies. The lack of insurance coverage in these areas can have systemic risks, as consumers forced to foot the bill for natural disasters may be unable to continue payments on mortgages or other loans, creating a cascade of financial risks throughout the economy.

Insurance regulators and government entities are calling for greater transparency from insurance providers in how they account for climate risks. There is a push for more effective disclosure to assess the effectiveness of insurers' actions to mitigate climate-related risks. Additionally, there is a growing recognition that addressing climate change and its impact on the insurance industry requires a collaborative effort between insurers, government entities, and policyholders. For example, investing in residential dwelling resiliency measures can help fortify homes against severe weather, reducing weather-related claims losses for insurers.

In conclusion, climate change and extreme weather events are significantly impacting the insurance industry in the US, leading to increased insurance costs, reduced coverage, and a widening protection gap. Addressing these challenges will require innovative solutions, regulatory reforms, and collaboration between the public and private sectors to build a more resilient and equitable insurance system.

Insurers' response to risk

Insurers are facing a multitude of risks, from financial risks to non-financial risks. These include shifting interest rates, changing costs, inflation, supply chain issues, and climate change. In response, insurers are taking a variety of actions to mitigate these risks and remain resilient.

Financial Risks

In response to financial risks, insurers are focusing on capital management and balance sheet management. They are also controlling costs, repricing, and sourcing alternative capital. For Property and Casualty (P&C) companies, capacity is a significant challenge due to increased demand for insurance coverage. Reinsurance and insurance-linked securities (ILS) are being utilized to manage this challenge. Life and annuity carriers are shifting their focus to capital-light businesses and optimizing their capital positions.

Non-Financial Risks

In response to non-financial risks, insurers are working to enhance their understanding and management of climate risk. This includes investing in advanced climate analytics and integrating climate risk into their organizational strategies. Additionally, they are navigating the complex world of generative AI (gen AI) by establishing ethical guardrails and ensuring responsible use. Insurers are also prioritizing cyber risk management by implementing robust cybersecurity practices and investing in targeted capabilities.

Operational Changes

Insurers are also making operational changes to enhance efficiency and agility. This includes improving core processes, clarifying roles and responsibilities, and investing in analytics and automation. They are also shifting their focus to the left, becoming an integral part of product and policy development to foster a healthy risk-based decision-making culture.

Customer-Centric Approach

Insurers are recognizing the importance of putting the customer first. They are working to rebuild goodwill with stakeholders, provide transparency, and ensure fairness in their use of machine learning and AI. By modernizing infrastructure and business models, insurers can develop a forward-looking approach to risk modeling and assessment, making the insurance safety net more reliable and accessible.

Strategic Partnerships

Insurers are also forming strategic partnerships and acquiring new products and capabilities to meet customer and distributor demands. This allows them to adapt more efficiently to economic, geopolitical, and climate-related challenges.

Regulatory Compliance

Insurers are navigating an evolving regulatory landscape with increased scrutiny from consumers, investors, and regulators. They are focusing on compliance, reporting, and scenario planning to address new tax rules and changing requirements.

Overall, insurers are taking a proactive approach to managing risks and ensuring the long-term sustainability and resilience of their businesses. They are adapting to changing industry dynamics, embracing technological advancements, and prioritizing customer satisfaction and protection.

The impact on consumers

The insurance industry in the US is facing a challenging time, with a number of factors contributing to a difficult environment for consumers. Climate change is a significant issue, with extreme weather events making it harder to insure homes in certain areas. This has led to a rise in insurance premiums and, in some cases, insurance companies withdrawing from certain states altogether. The impact of climate change is also affecting the wider economy, with rising costs for vehicle repairs and medical bills contributing to an increase in insurance premiums.

The COVID-19 pandemic has also played a role in the current situation. During the pandemic, many insurers digitised their operations and moved to remote working, which may have long-term effects on the industry's talent structure and customer experience. Additionally, the pandemic has led to a greater awareness of the need for insurance, particularly life insurance. This has resulted in a surge in applications and is expected to drive further growth in the industry.

However, the impact on consumers has been mixed. On the one hand, insurance premiums have been rising, making it more difficult for people to afford coverage. In some cases, people may be reducing their coverage or increasing their deductibles just to stay insured. This is particularly true for car insurance, where premiums have surged by more than 50% since 2021. The cost of home insurance has also been rising, with some states, such as Florida, California, and Louisiana, seeing dramatic increases.

On the other hand, the pandemic has also led to some positive changes in the industry. Insurers have become more proactive and aggressive in their strategic choices, with many investing in technology and innovation. This has resulted in a more agile and customer-centric business model, which may benefit consumers in the long run. Additionally, the focus on digital transformation has opened up new talent pools and reduced the need for office space, which may lead to lower operating costs for insurers.

The regulatory landscape is also evolving, with a greater focus on Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) issues. This includes addressing the impact of climate change on insurance risks and prices, as well as social equity in underserved markets. Insurers are also being held to higher standards of transparency and fairness in their use of advanced technologies, such as machine learning and AI, to assess risks and set premiums.

Overall, while the insurance industry in America is facing challenges, there are also opportunities for growth and improvement. The impact on consumers has been mixed, with some facing higher premiums and reduced coverage, while others may benefit from the industry's digital transformation and focus on ESG issues.

The role of government

The US government plays a role in the insurance industry at both the federal and state level. While states play the primary role in regulating the insurance industry, the federal government exerts control over the insurance market in four areas. These include:

• The Internal Revenue Code and its special tax treatment of insurance products. Taxes provide incentives and disincentives, and changes in tax policy can significantly impact the evolution of the insurance market.
• Health insurance and pension legislation, such as HIPAA and ERISA. The federal government enacted Medicare and Medicaid, and the insurance industry responded with products that work in conjunction with this framework.
• Regulation of insurance products considered securities by the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC). The federal government, through the SEC, has increasing influence in the licensing and product registration of securities products, including new insurance products that have a dual character as insurance and investment products.
• The powers reserved to the federal government under the McCarran-Ferguson Act. This law was passed in response to a 1945 Supreme Court decision that declared insurance to be "interstate commerce" subject to federal jurisdiction. The Act overturned that decision, leaving most insurance regulation to the states but retaining federal jurisdiction over issues of national concern.

At the federal level, the Federal Insurance Office (FIO) was established under the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act. The FIO has the authority to monitor all aspects of the insurance sector, including access to affordable non-health insurance products for underserved communities. It also represents the US on international insurance matters and advises the Secretary on national and international insurance matters.

In recent years, there has been a focus on the role of government in addressing the rising cost of car insurance, which has been impacted by inflation, supply chain issues, and increased claims and thefts. The insurance industry is also facing scrutiny over its approach to sustainability and ESG (environmental, social, and governance) concerns, particularly in relation to climate-related risks.

Frequently asked questions