Trusts And Life Insurance: Beneficiary Considerations

Whether a trust should be the beneficiary of life insurance depends on the individual's personal situation and goals. One of the main reasons people consider this option is to minimise taxes on their life insurance benefits. However, this process can be complex and comes with legal and tax implications.

In most cases, it makes more sense to name beneficiaries individually on life insurance policies. If your estate exceeds your state's estate tax exemption threshold, it may be wise to place your ownership of any life insurance in an irrevocable life insurance trust (ILIT). This ensures that proceeds from a death benefit payout are not included in your taxable estate.

Another benefit of naming a trust as a beneficiary is efficient asset transfer and immediate financial relief for expenses and debts post-death. It also offers tax advantages and protection against probate. Trustees play a critical role in managing life insurance proceeds within a trust, overseeing policy premiums, and disbursing benefits according to the grantor's instructions.

However, there are also drawbacks to consider. Setting up a trust can be costly and time-consuming, and it may require additional estate planning measures, such as creating a will. Additionally, naming a trust as a beneficiary can result in more red tape and delays in receiving the payout.

Pros of listing a trust as beneficiary

There are several advantages to listing a trust as the beneficiary of your life insurance policy. Here are some pros of taking such an approach:

Probate Avoidance

Probate is a lengthy and expensive process that can delay the distribution of your estate to your heirs. By listing a trust as the beneficiary, you can avoid probate altogether. This ensures that the money intended for your children or other beneficiaries is not delayed or reduced by legal fees and outstanding debts or taxes.

Control Over Cash Flow to Children

If you want to control how much money goes to your children and when they receive it, a trust can help you achieve that. You can adjust the trust to cover specific costs for your children while they are minors and create stipulations for them to receive the remaining funds when they reach a certain age. This flexibility is especially beneficial for young and growing families, allowing you to modify the revocable trust as your children get older and your financial needs and wishes change.

Tax Advantages

In some cases, listing a trust as the beneficiary can help minimize estate taxes. For example, creating an Irrevocable Life Insurance Trust (ILIT) can exclude life insurance proceeds from your taxable estate, resulting in reduced or eliminated estate taxes. This ensures that your beneficiaries receive a larger portion of your wealth.

Protection Against Creditors

In most states, life insurance policies are protected from creditors. However, if you have concerns about your beneficiaries' creditor issues, listing a trust as the beneficiary can provide an extra layer of protection.

Complex Distribution Plans

If you have a complex plan for distributing your life insurance proceeds, such as specific gifts to multiple friends and family members or unequal percentages to various beneficiaries, listing a trust can help you achieve this. The proceeds will be distributed according to the terms of your trust, allowing for more detailed control over the distribution.

Cons of listing a trust as beneficiary

• Cost and time: Setting up a revocable living trust can be expensive and time-consuming. Costs may include expenses related to setting up deeds and transferring ownership, as well as legal fees.
• Additional estate planning: You need a will to set up a trust, and heirs can contest a trust for longer than a traditional will.
• Red tape: There is more paperwork involved in receiving the payout of the death benefit when a trust is named as the beneficiary. If an individual is named, they will typically receive a check from the life insurance company within a week. If a trust is named, the trustee will have to provide certain paperwork to the life insurance company, and the process can take a few weeks to a month.
• Taxes: Trusts are not considered individuals, so proceeds paid to trusts are generally subject to estate tax.
• Unfavorable conditions: Trusts may be bound to unfavorable conditions, such as retirement plan assets being subject to required minimum distribution payouts based on the life expectancy of the oldest beneficiary.
• Irrevocability: Once an irrevocable trust is set up, it cannot be changed, even in the case of divorce or a change in preference for the beneficiary.

Estate tax considerations

In terms of estate tax, the primary advantage of naming a trust as the beneficiary is the potential exclusion of the life insurance proceeds from the taxable estate. This exclusion can significantly reduce estate tax liabilities, ensuring that a larger portion of the estate is passed on to the intended beneficiaries. It is worth noting that the tax implications may vary depending on the type of trust, such as irrevocable or revocable trusts.

Irrevocable Life Insurance Trusts (ILITs) are specifically designed to exclude life insurance proceeds from the taxable estate. By transferring ownership of the policy to an ILIT, individuals can minimise or even eliminate estate taxes. This strategy is particularly beneficial for high-net-worth individuals or those with substantial wealth, as it helps preserve family wealth for future generations. Additionally, in states like Illinois, creating separate revocable living trusts for each spouse can effectively double the estate tax exemption through the AB Trust strategy. This strategy allows couples to combine their individual exemptions and raise their overall threshold.

On the other hand, revocable trusts offer more flexibility and control to the grantor. They can be altered, amended, or terminated at any time, providing the advantage of changing the trust according to evolving circumstances. However, revocable trusts do not provide the same level of tax benefits as irrevocable trusts and are still considered part of the taxable estate. As a result, beneficiaries may be subject to estate taxes.

It is important to consult with estate planning attorneys and tax advisors to navigate the complex legal and tax landscape surrounding life insurance and trusts. They can provide guidance based on individual circumstances and goals, ensuring that the chosen strategy aligns with long-term financial objectives and estate planning needs.

Control over how proceeds are managed

When a trust is the beneficiary of a life insurance policy, trustees play a critical role in managing the proceeds. They are responsible for overseeing policy premiums and disbursing benefits according to the grantor's instructions. This allows for detailed control over the distribution of funds to beneficiaries, including minor children or individuals with special needs.

One of the key advantages of naming a trust as a beneficiary is the ability to control how the proceeds are managed and distributed after your death. If an individual inherits the death benefit, the payout will typically be made directly to them or their legal guardian. However, if a trust inherits the death benefit, the trustee will have discretion over how the money is handled, following the terms outlined in the trust. This ensures that the funds are used in accordance with the grantor's wishes and can provide peace of mind, especially when dealing with complex distribution plans or beneficiaries who may not be able to manage large sums of money responsibly.

For example, if you have minor children when you pass away, you may not want the life insurance proceeds to be paid directly to their guardian. By naming a trust as the beneficiary, you can set restrictions on how and when the funds are accessed, ensuring that the money is used for the child's care and safeguarding their inheritance. Similarly, if your children are young adults, you may not want them to receive the entire death benefit all at once. A trust allows you to stagger the distribution of funds, providing access to a portion of the assets at different ages, while still giving the trustee discretion to pay out more if it is in the beneficiary's best interests.

In addition to control over distribution, naming a trust as a beneficiary can also help to protect assets from creditors and legal disputes, minimize estate taxes, and avoid the probate process, which can be costly and time-consuming. However, it is important to carefully consider the potential drawbacks, such as the additional costs and complexity involved in setting up a trust, as well as the potential for unfavorable tax consequences.

Complex plans for distribution

If you want your life insurance death benefit to be distributed according to a complex plan, such as specific gifts to friends and family or unequal percentages to nieces and nephews, you will likely not be able to accomplish this by naming direct beneficiaries on your life insurance policy. However, if you make a trust the beneficiary of your life insurance policy, the policy will be distributed according to the terms of your trust, which can be as complex and specific as you like.

For instance, if you want your life insurance death benefit to go first to your spouse and then to your children in equal shares, this is easy enough to accomplish directly through your life insurance policy. However, if you have a more complex plan for distribution, you will likely not be able to accomplish this through naming direct beneficiaries on your life insurance policy.

There is one downside to making a trust the beneficiary of your life insurance policy: there is more red tape involved in receiving the payout of the death benefit. If an individual is named as the beneficiary, they will typically receive a check from the life insurance company within a week, without having to jump through many hoops. If a trust is named as the beneficiary, the trustee will have to provide certain paperwork to the life insurance company and the process can take longer, typically a few weeks to a month.

For this reason, a married person will typically name their spouse as the direct beneficiary of the life insurance policy and name the trust as the successor beneficiary. We want the payout to the spouse to be as quick and painless as possible. However, when the payout is going to other heirs, we are often willing to sacrifice speed to ensure that your wishes are executed properly.

Frequently asked questions