Auto Insurance Fraud: What Deceptive Practices To Avoid

Auto insurance fraud is a costly issue that impacts both insurance companies and consumers. It occurs when someone lies or omits information to obtain a better insurance rate or a larger claim payout. This can take the form of soft fraud, such as exaggerating a claim or providing false information on an application, or hard fraud, such as faking an accident or abandoning a vehicle and claiming it was stolen. Fraudulent activities can be committed by individuals, organized criminal groups, or even insurance professionals themselves. The cost of auto insurance fraud is significant, with estimates ranging from $29 billion to over $300 billion annually in the United States. As a result, insurance companies and law enforcement agencies have implemented various measures to combat this issue, including establishing special investigation units and utilizing advanced technologies for fraud detection.

Soft fraud: Exaggerating a claim or omitting details on an application to obtain a lower premium

Soft fraud is a type of insurance fraud that is unplanned and occurs when a policyholder exaggerates a claim or omits details for a larger payout or a lower premium. Soft fraud is usually harder to prove than hard fraud as it stems from a legitimate claim. Soft fraud is also significantly more common than hard fraud.

An example of soft fraud in the context of auto insurance would be exaggerating the severity of injuries from a car accident to collect a larger payout. Another example would be claiming that expensive art was destroyed in a home burglary when, in reality, only prints were damaged. This type of fraud is harder to get away with because insurance companies often ask for proof of big-ticket items.

Soft fraud also includes omitting or misrepresenting important information on an insurance application to obtain a lower premium. For instance, individuals may provide a false address from a lower-premium area when registering their vehicles. Another example would be deliberately failing to add a new driver to the household, such as a teenager, to avoid increased rates.

Soft fraud is considered a "victimless crime" by many, but this is far from the truth. Soft fraud hurts consumers much more than insurance companies. Insurance companies combat the losses from soft fraud by hiring and expanding a fraud department, which is expensive. They then need to make up for these costs by raising prices. Ultimately, fraud results in higher premiums for consumers.

Hard fraud: Deliberately destroying property to collect on the insurance policy

Hard fraud is the rarest form of insurance fraud. It occurs when a criminal deliberately destroys property or causes damage for the purpose of collecting on the insurance policy. Criminal rings are sometimes involved in hard fraud schemes that can steal millions of dollars.

One common form of hard fraud is when the insurance policy amounts to a greater value than the value of the insured property. In this situation, the policyholder has the incentive to commit insurance fraud by destroying the property and making it look like an accident. In 2006, authorities estimated that fraudsters swindled insurance companies out of $766 million in this manner.

Another example of hard fraud is when claimants falsely report their vehicle as stolen. This occurs by reporting a vehicle as stolen to an insurance company when it has not been stolen with the intent of receiving compensation for its purported loss.

Hard fraud can also occur when claimants fake or exaggerate injuries. For example, a motorist in front of you may suddenly hit the brakes in the hopes that you'll hit them. If you do, they'll then fake an injury.

Insurance fraud poses a significant problem, and governments and other organizations try to deter such activity. Detecting insurance fraud is difficult because of the surreptitious nature of the criminal's actions.

Staged accidents: Strategic crashes to receive a fraudulent insurance payout

Staged accidents are a type of auto insurance fraud that is unfortunately common, with an estimated 10% of all property-casualty claims being fraudulent. Criminals will strategically crash into unsuspecting motorists in order to make false insurance claims. These fraudulent claims cost insurance companies billions of dollars each year, and honest drivers end up footing the bill through increased premiums.

Staged accidents are more common in urban areas with a higher volume of vehicles and in wealthier communities, as drivers there are perceived to have better insurance coverage. Criminals often target new, rental, or commercial vehicles, as well as women driving alone and senior citizens, as these individuals are thought to be less confrontational.

There are several common schemes that criminals use to stage accidents. One such scheme is the "swoop and squat", where two vehicles trap a victim and force them into a rear-end collision. Another scheme is the "drive down", where a victim is tricked into turning early by an oncoming driver who waits to lure them forward, only to collide with them. The "wave down" is another tactic used by criminals, where they wave a victim forward to pull out of a parking lot or side street, only to crash into them.

To protect yourself from becoming a victim of a staged accident, it is recommended that you watch out for suspicious driving behavior, record everything with a dashcam, and call the police and your insurance company as soon as it is safe to do so. If you suspect fraud, be sure to communicate your suspicions to the police and your insurance company.

Premium diversion: An agent stealing your premiums and pocketing them

Premium diversion is a severe and widespread type of insurance fraud that can affect policyholders. It occurs when an insurance professional or someone posing as an insurance professional embezzles policyholders' insurance premiums. In other words, the agent takes the premium payments for personal financial gain instead of passing them to the underwriter, leaving the policyholder without valid insurance coverage.

This type of fraud is considered one of the most common, with the FBI deeming it a "major league crime". It can have serious ramifications, as evidenced by a case where the owner of an insurance agency diverted premiums to fund his congressional campaign, ultimately serving three years in prison.

To avoid becoming a victim of premium diversion, it is advisable to work with trusted agents and always verify coverage directly with the insurer. When choosing an agent, consider asking for references, confirming their license, comparing advice from multiple agents, and researching any complaints against them.

Additionally, be cautious of agents who promise rates far below the competition and companies that are difficult to contact or unknown to you and independent sources. It is also wise to contact your state insurance department, maintain records of payments, and confirm that the insurer receives your payments.

Fraudulent car repairs: Mechanics charging top dollar for substandard parts

Auto repair fraud is a significant issue, with consumers losing tens of billions of dollars annually due to faulty or unnecessary repairs. While most mechanics and repair shops are honest, there are dishonest operators in the industry who take advantage of car owners' lack of knowledge about their vehicles. This makes auto repair fraud challenging to prove, and many victims are unsure of how to proceed with their case.

One common scam involves charging top dollar for substandard parts. Unethical mechanics may recommend replacing parts that are not actually faulty, or they may install cheap, counterfeit, or used parts while charging customers for new, premium parts. In some cases, mechanics have been known to charge for parts that weren't even used in the repair.

To avoid falling victim to this type of fraud, it's important to ask for a parts invoice and to get a second opinion from another mechanic if you have any doubts about the recommended repairs. It's also a good idea to perform a background check on the repair shop by checking their history with the Better Business Bureau and registering with the state. Getting multiple repair quotes from different shops can also help you identify discrepancies and avoid being overcharged.

If you believe you've been a victim of auto repair fraud, it's crucial to notify your state attorney general's office, local consumer protection agency, and file a complaint with the Better Business Bureau. Collecting and organizing all relevant paperwork, receipts, work orders, and warranty information will help strengthen your case.

Frequently asked questions