Farmers Insurance Subscription Agreement: Understanding The Fine Print

Farmers Insurance Exchange is an insurance organisation that operates similarly to other insurance companies, but with some differences. It was established under a provision in the California Insurance Code, which allows insured individuals to exchange policies with other insured people. When customers sign up for insurance with Farmers Insurance Exchange, they are asked to sign a subscription agreement, which is a document that appoints a third party, known as an attorney-in-fact (AIF), to handle tasks like policy issuance and collecting premiums on their behalf. This agreement also specifies the AIF fee, which is usually 20% of the premium but can be less.

What is an Exchange?

Farmers Insurance Exchange is an insurance organisation that operates similarly to other insurance companies but with some differences. It was organised under a provision in the California Insurance Code, which allows insured individuals to "exchange" policies with other insured individuals.

Because insured individuals cannot be involved in issuing policies, collecting premiums, paying commissions to agents, etc., they appoint a third party, called an "attorney-in-fact" (AIF), to perform these duties on their behalf for a fee. This appointment is made through a document called a "Subscription Agreement". When an individual applies for insurance with Farmers Insurance Exchange, they are asked to sign a Subscription Agreement, and this is how they become a member or subscriber.

As a member of Farmers Insurance Exchange, individuals have the right to vote for representatives of the Exchange Board of Governors. The Exchange is owned by its subscribers (insured individuals) until such time as they no longer have insurance from the Exchange. The subscribers elect a Board of Governors, which oversees the financial affairs of the Exchange and the performance of the AIF, ensuring conformity with the Subscription Agreement terms.

The AIF fee is specified in the Subscription Agreement, which is 20% of the premium, although the Farmers Underwriters Association (FUA) has taken less than that amount. FUA is the business name used by Farmers Group, Inc. (FGI) to describe its functions as the AIF for Farmers Insurance Exchange. FGI is part of the Zurich Insurance Group, Ltd (ZIG), a Swiss company. Neither FUA, FGI, nor ZIG has any ownership interest in Farmers Insurance Exchange.

Who owns the Exchange?

The Truck Insurance Exchange is owned by its subscribers (insureds). Subscribers of the Exchange are owners until such time as they no longer have insurance from the Exchange. They elect a Board of Governors to supervise the financial affairs of the Exchange and the performance of the attorney-in-fact (AIF) in conformity with the Subscription Agreement terms.

The Exchange is an insurance organization that operates similarly to any other insurance company but with some key differences. It was organized under a provision in the California Insurance Code, which allows insureds to "exchange" policies with other insureds. As the insureds cannot be involved in issuing policies, collecting premiums, paying commissions to agents, etc., they appoint a third party, the AIF, to carry out these tasks for a fee. This appointment is made through a Subscription Agreement, which subscribers sign when they apply for insurance with the Truck Insurance Exchange.

While Truck Insurance Exchange is owned by its subscribers, it is important to note that Truck Underwriters Association (TUA), the AIF appointed by the subscribers, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Farmers Group, Inc. (FGI), which is part of the Zurich Insurance Group, Ltd (ZIG), a Swiss company. However, neither TUA, FGI, nor ZIG has any ownership interest in the Truck Insurance Exchange.

Why is an AIF fee paid to Farmers Underwriters Association (FUA)?

An AIF fee is paid to Farmers Underwriters Association (FUA) because members appoint FUA to perform certain tasks involved in running an insurance operation. These tasks include policy issuance and the collection of premiums. The FUA is appointed through a document called a Subscription Agreement, which is signed when a customer applies for insurance with Farmers Insurance Exchange.

The Subscription Agreement specifies an AIF fee of 20% of the premium, although FUA has taken less than that amount. In 2022, the AIF fee was 12.3% of the premium dollar, which included an AIF profit of 6.59% of the premium dollar for that year.

FUA is the business name used by Farmers Group, Inc. (FGI) to describe its functions as the AIF for Farmers Insurance Exchange. FGI is part of the Zurich Insurance Group, Ltd (ZIG), a Swiss company. It is important to note that neither FUA, FGI, nor ZIG has any ownership interest in Farmers Insurance Exchange, which is owned by its subscribers (insureds).

How was your premium dollar spent by Farmers Insurance Exchange in 2022?

Farmers Insurance Exchange is one of the insurers that make up Farmers Insurance Group. It provides automobile, homeowners, personal umbrella, and business owners insurance.

In 2022, your premium dollar covered Exchange costs, including losses incurred, acquisition costs, taxes, license fees, the AIF (attorney-in-fact) fee, and any contributions to surplus. The AIF fee was 12.3% of the premium dollar, which included an AIF profit of 6.59%. This is lower than the specified AIF fee of 20% of the premium in the Subscription Agreement.

The premium dollar spent by Farmers Insurance Exchange in 2022 is broken down as follows:

• Losses Incurred: This includes claims payments made to policyholders for covered losses.
• Acquisition Costs: Costs associated with acquiring new policies, such as agent commissions and marketing expenses.
• Taxes: Taxes levied by state and local governments on insurance premiums.
• License Fees: Fees paid to regulatory bodies for the privilege of conducting insurance business.
• AIF (Attorney-in-Fact) Fee: The fee paid to the Farmers Underwriters Association (FUA) or Truck Underwriters Association (TUA) for performing tasks such as policy issuance and collection of premiums. The AIF fee is specified in the Subscription Agreement as 20% of the premium, but FUA and TUA have taken less than that amount.
• Contributions to Surplus: If premiums collected exceed claims payments and expenses, the excess is retained as contributions to surplus to pay future losses.

Can the Exchange lose money?

Sure! Here is an explanation of the term "Farmers Insurance Subscription Agreement" with a focus on the question "Can the Exchange Lose Money?":

The Farmers Insurance Exchange is a unique and longstanding arrangement in the insurance world, and it is important to understand how it functions and the potential risks involved. So, can the Exchange lose money? The short answer is yes. The Exchange's unique structure as a reciprocal or inter-insurance exchange means it is essentially owned by its policyholders, and they share in the risks and profits. While this model has benefits, it also comes with inherent risks.

The Exchange's profitability is directly linked to the performance of its investments and the accuracy of its risk assessments. If the Exchange underwrites risky policies or invests its funds poorly, it can lead to significant financial losses. Policyholders essentially become investors in the Exchange, and their premiums are used to pay claims and expenses and generate profits. If the Exchange miscalculates risk and finds itself unable to pay claims, it can result in assessments being levied on the policyholders to cover the shortfall.

The subscription agreement that policyholders enter into with the Exchange outlines the understanding that policyholders are liable for any losses incurred. This means that in the event of substantial losses, policyholders could be required to contribute additional funds beyond their premiums to cover these losses. This is a key difference between traditional insurance companies and the Exchange, as policyholders essentially share in the risks and rewards of the enterprise. While this shared risk model can keep premiums competitive, it also means policyholders are exposed to potential financial liabilities.

Another factor to consider is that the Exchange's investment strategies may not always pay off. Like any insurance company, the Exchange invests the funds it receives from premiums to generate returns. However, there is no guarantee that these investments will perform well, and poor investment decisions or market downturns could lead to financial losses. These losses would ultimately be shouldered by the policyholders, further emphasizing the shared risk nature of the Exchange. Overall, while the Farmers Insurance Exchange offers a unique and longstanding approach to insurance, it is important for policyholders to understand the potential risks involved.

Frequently asked questions