Misrepresentation: Understanding The Fine Line Between Inaccuracy And Fraud In Insurance

Misrepresentation in insurance refers to giving false statements or untrue accounts or claims. This can be perpetrated by either the insured or the insurer. Misrepresentation can be accidental or intentional, and it occurs when a party makes a false statement that is vital to the acceptance or approval of the risk. For example, a homeowner installing a pool but telling their insurer they do not have one. This type of misrepresentation can void an insurance contract if discovered by the insurer. Misrepresentation can also occur when an insurer misrepresents the details of a policy or claim, which is considered acting in bad faith. To avoid misrepresentation, it is important to be honest and transparent with your insurance company and carefully review all the details of your insurance policy.

Misrepresentation by an agent

Misrepresentation by an insurance agent occurs when an agent provides false information or makes misleading statements about an insurance policy to a prospective client, leading them to purchase a policy that may not be suitable or provide the coverage they believe they have. This can happen during the sales process or when a client is filing a claim.

Insurance agents have a duty to use reasonable care, diligence, and judgment when selling insurance policies, ensuring that they meet the needs and requests of their customers. However, in their eagerness to make a sale, some agents may misrepresent the terms, provisions, or requirements of a policy, intentionally or negligently. For example, an agent might claim that a policy includes certain benefits or covers specific risks when, in reality, it does not. This misrepresentation can lead to a client purchasing a policy that does not adequately meet their needs.

In some cases, misrepresentation can also occur during the claims process. When a client files a claim, insurance companies investigate and determine the appropriate amount of coverage based on the policy's terms and the specific circumstances. Insurance agents and adjusters are expected to explain the complex and legal jargon-filled policies honestly and transparently. However, some agents may misrepresent the extent of coverage or make false statements to persuade clients to accept lower settlements or deny legitimate claims.

If you believe you have been a victim of misrepresentation by an insurance agent, you may have legal recourse. State laws impose specific responsibilities on insurance agents to protect consumers from abuse or misrepresentation. You may be entitled to damages, statutory penalties, and attorney's fees if an agent's negligence or intentional misrepresentation has caused you harm or financial loss. It is essential to seek legal advice from a qualified attorney who can review your case and guide you through the process of filing a claim or seeking compensation.

Misrepresentation by an adjuster

Misrepresentation in insurance refers to giving false statements or untrue accounts or claims that sway a party into making a decision. In the case of insurance, this can occur when an insurance company misrepresents the details of a policy being sold or a claim being filed. This is considered acting in bad faith, and the insured can pursue a bad faith insurance claim to recover benefits.

Adjusters may also be liable for intentional infliction of emotional distress if their actions cause emotional harm to the insured. In the Bock v. Hansen case, one of the homeowners cut her hand while cleaning up the debris, which the court considered as part of the adjuster's misrepresentation.

Insurance adjusters are expected to act with reasonable care, diligence, and judgment in handling insurance claims. When an adjuster fails to do so, they may be found negligent and held liable for any damages caused. In some cases, adjusters may be personally liable for their tortious conduct, as seen in the Bock v. Hansen case, where the adjuster was sued individually for negligent misrepresentation.

To prove negligent misrepresentation, the plaintiff must show that the adjuster made a false representation, knew it was false or made it recklessly, intended for the plaintiff to rely on it, and caused harm to the plaintiff by relying on the false representation.

It is important to note that specific duties and laws governing insurance adjusters may vary by state. However, the general principle of acting in good faith and providing accurate information applies across the industry.

Types of misrepresentation

Misrepresentation in insurance refers to giving false statements and untrue accounts or claims, which can void an insurance contract. This can occur in a few different ways, including when an insurer misrepresents the details of a policy or claim, or when an insured individual provides false information.

There are three types of misrepresentation: innocent misrepresentation, negligent misrepresentation, and fraudulent misrepresentation.

Innocent Misrepresentation

Innocent misrepresentation is the most common type of misrepresentation. It occurs when an individual accidentally provides their insurance provider with incorrect information. For example, giving the wrong first licensed date, forgetting a traffic ticket or accident, or forgetting to pay the balance on a prior insurance policy. In most cases, an insurance provider will deny a claim or cancel a policy if innocent misrepresentation is discovered.

Negligent Misrepresentation

Negligent misrepresentation is the act of providing inaccurate information without attempting to confirm its accuracy before signing an insurance policy. For instance, not calculating annual mileage before signing a policy. This breaches the notion of "reasonable care" that a policyholder must take. As with innocent misrepresentation, an insurance provider will typically deny a claim or cancel a policy if negligent misrepresentation is discovered. In severe cases, the provider may charge the policyholder with insurance fraud.

Fraudulent Misrepresentation

Fraudulent misrepresentation is the act of knowingly providing untrue information to an insurance provider. For example, lying about driving experience, address, or age. It can also include providing false information about an accident when making a claim. Canadian insurance companies take fraudulent misrepresentation very seriously, and individuals found guilty may face difficulties obtaining coverage through traditional channels.

Examples of misrepresentation

Misrepresentation in insurance refers to giving false statements or untrue accounts or claims. It is a breach of contract and can void an insurance policy. Misrepresentation can occur in a few different ways, including:

Innocent Misrepresentation

Innocent misrepresentation is when someone accidentally provides their insurance provider with incorrect information. This can include giving the wrong first licensed date, forgetting about a traffic ticket or accident, or forgetting to pay the balance owing on a prior insurance policy. In most cases, an insurance provider will deny a claim or cancel a policy if innocent misrepresentation is discovered.

Negligent Misrepresentation

Negligent misrepresentation is when someone provides inaccurate information without attempting to confirm it beforehand. For example, not calculating annual mileage before signing a policy. This breaches the notion of "reasonable care" that a policyholder must take. As with innocent misrepresentation, an insurance provider will likely deny a claim, cancel a policy, or charge the policyholder with insurance fraud in cases of negligent misrepresentation.

Fraudulent Misrepresentation

Fraudulent misrepresentation is when someone knowingly provides untrue information to their insurance provider. For example, lying about driving experience, address, age, or providing false information about an accident when making a claim. This is taken extremely seriously by insurance companies and can result in a cancelled policy, denied claim, and insurance fraud charges.

Material Misrepresentation

Material misrepresentation involves omitting necessary information from an insurance provider. For example, not disclosing that there is another licensed driver in the household. This is important because it affects the risk level of the insured's vehicle.

Misrepresentation by an Adjuster

In some cases, insurance adjusters may deliberately deceive policyholders by denying claims or making low settlement offers written in complex jargon to confuse the policyholder. This is considered bad faith and should be addressed with legal assistance.

Misrepresentation by an Agent

Insurance agents may mislead policyholders into purchasing unnecessary provisions that raise rates without providing adequate protection in an emergency.

How to protect yourself from misrepresentation

Misrepresentation in insurance refers to the provision of false or inaccurate information, either deliberately or inadvertently, which can influence an insurance company's decision-making process. This can lead to severe consequences such as denied claims, policy cancellation, and even criminal charges for insurance fraud.

• Choose an insurance plan you can afford: Opt for a plan that fits within your budget and covers your essential needs. Avoid unnecessary provisions that raise your rates.
• Conduct thorough research: Before purchasing a plan, research the insurance company's stability and reputation. Ensure they have a good track record of handling claims fairly and providing accurate information.
• Avoid unnecessary plans: Only purchase insurance plans that you truly need. Don't be pressured into buying additional coverage that may not be relevant to your situation.
• Seek a second opinion: Consult with multiple insurance agents or advisors to get a clearer understanding of the policies and their exclusions. This can help you make a more informed decision.
• Thoroughly review your policy: Take the time to read the fine print and understand all the terms, conditions, and exclusions of your policy. Don't hesitate to ask questions if anything is unclear.
• Understand withdrawals and penalties: Be aware of the consequences of making withdrawals from your policy or plan. Know the punishments and penalties associated with early withdrawals or cancellations.
• Stay informed and organised: Keep track of your investments and regularly review your policies. Stay updated on any changes in the industry or your specific plan.
• Provide accurate information: When applying for insurance, double-check all the details you provide, including personal information, vehicle information, annual mileage, etc. Be transparent and honest to avoid any unintentional misrepresentations.
• Maintain open communication: Foster a good relationship with your insurance company by maintaining open and transparent communication. Clarify any questions or concerns you may have, and keep them updated on any changes in your circumstances.
• Seek legal advice: If you suspect misrepresentation or encounter issues with your insurance company, consult with an attorney who specialises in insurance law. They can provide personalised advice and help protect your rights.

Frequently asked questions