Understanding Auto Insurance Tiers: What's The Difference?

Car insurance tiers are a relatively new concept, allowing drivers to receive different premiums based on their personal information and driving history. The number of tiers varies depending on the insurer, and each company has its own criteria for placing drivers into these tiers. The three most common tiers are high-risk or non-standard, standard, and preferred. Factors that influence a driver's placement within these tiers include age, driving record, credit score, insurance history, and claims frequency. It is important to research the different insurers and their tier systems to find the best rates and coverage options.

High-risk or non-standard tier

The high-risk or non-standard tier of auto insurance is for drivers who are considered more likely to file a claim. This could be due to a variety of factors, including a history of accidents, traffic violations, or claims, as well as a poor credit score and a lack of previous insurance coverage. Drivers in this tier will typically face significantly higher insurance premiums.

Insurers use the tier system to determine auto insurance rates, with each tier representing a different level of risk. The high-risk tier does not mean drivers are unable to shop for car insurance, but they will not be eligible for the standard rate until they can provide additional information to give better context to their driving history. This could include demonstrating safe driving over an extended period, improving their credit score, or taking driver education courses.

It is important to note that every insurer uses its own calculations and tier system, so drivers should research and compare quotes from different insurers to find the best rates for their tier. Additionally, the number of tiers and specific criteria for placing drivers into these tiers can vary between companies.

Being placed in the high-risk tier can significantly impact a driver's insurance premiums and coverage options. It is crucial for drivers to understand their tier placement and work on improving their driving record and insurance score to qualify for lower tiers and, consequently, lower insurance rates.

Preferred tier

The "preferred tier" in auto insurance refers to customers who insurers generally prefer to insure. These customers tend to have clean driving records, no lapses in coverage, excellent credit scores, and a low number of claims filed. Being in the preferred tier means that these customers will usually get better rates on their insurance premiums.

To be considered for the preferred tier, drivers typically need to meet several criteria. Firstly, they should have a clean driving record with little to no moving violations. This clean record also makes them eligible for the good driver discount offered by many large insurance carriers. Additionally, they need to have maintained insurance coverage for at least six months without any lapses.

Another important factor is the driver's credit score. A very good or excellent credit score can positively impact their tier placement. Insurance companies view customers with high credit scores as less risky, which can lead to lower premiums. It's worth noting that age can also play a role in tier determination. Some insurance companies automatically bar drivers under the age of 25 from the preferred tier due to the tendency for younger drivers to exhibit riskier behaviour and have less experience on the road.

The preferred tier is part of a tiered rating system used by auto insurance companies to assess and categorise drivers based on their risk profiles. This system allows insurers to offer more sophisticated rates to individual customers. By using this system, insurers can determine how much of a risk a driver poses and set their insurance premiums accordingly. It's important to note that every insurer uses its own calculations and tier system, so it's beneficial for customers to research and compare quotes from different companies.

Standard tier

The standard tier is for drivers with a moderate risk profile, who will pay slightly higher premiums than those in the basic tier. Drivers in the standard tier have an average credit score, previous insurance coverage, and one or two minor traffic violations, with one at-fault accident.

Drivers in the standard tier are considered to be getting good rates, but they can still improve their rate. They may only need to work on one area of their driving to be bumped up to the preferred tier. For example, a driver with an excellent credit score but one traffic violation could still get a good rate.

The standard tier is not to be confused with the basic tier, which includes drivers with a standard risk profile and results in average premiums. The standard tier is also distinct from the high-risk or non-standard tier, which includes drivers with no previous insurance coverage, a poor credit score, numerous accidents, and several claims.

Insurance company criteria

Insurance companies use a tier system to assess the risk associated with a driver and their vehicle, and this, in turn, determines the insurance premium. The tier system is based on several factors, including the driver's history, age, credit score, type of vehicle, and location.

Insurance companies use different criteria to place drivers into their respective car insurance tiers, but some common factors include:

• Driving record: A clean driving record with no or few moving violations will generally place a driver in a lower-risk tier, resulting in lower premiums. Conversely, a history of accidents, traffic violations, or DUI/DWI convictions will likely result in a higher-risk tier placement and higher premiums.
• Age: Younger and less experienced drivers are often considered riskier and placed in higher tiers. Some insurance companies automatically place drivers under 25 in a higher-risk tier due to their tendency to exhibit riskier behaviour.
• Credit score: A good or excellent credit score can help drivers secure lower insurance premiums, while a poor credit score can lead to significantly higher rates.
• Insurance history: Drivers with consistent insurance coverage and no lapses are generally preferred by insurance companies and may qualify for lower tiers.
• Claims history: The number of claims filed also affects tier placement. Multiple claims can result in a high-risk tier classification and higher premiums.
• Type of vehicle: Driving a high-risk vehicle, such as a sports car or a luxury vehicle, can increase the insurance premium as these vehicles are more expensive to insure.
• Location: Living in an area with higher traffic accident statistics, often an urban area, can result in a higher-risk tier placement and more expensive insurance.

It is important to note that insurance companies have different rating systems, and drivers may be classified differently by various insurers. Therefore, it is beneficial to shop around and compare quotes from different insurance companies to find the best rates and coverage options.

Lowering premiums

As mentioned, the new tiered system for auto insurance means that premiums are more personalised, based on a driver's history and likelihood of filing a claim. This means that premiums are more accurately reflective of a driver's risk level. However, this also means that there are more opportunities to lower your premium.

Firstly, it is important to maintain a good driving record. Safe drivers are rewarded with lower premiums. This means avoiding speeding, accidents, and other driving incidents. Some companies offer discounts for those who have not had any accidents or moving violations for a number of years. Taking a defensive driving course can also help to lower your premium.

Secondly, it is worth shopping around for insurance. Different companies will rate drivers differently, so it is worth getting several quotes and comparing the coverage and costs. It is also worth checking what discounts each company offers. For example, some companies offer discounts for buying your policy online, enrolling in preferred payment options, bundling your car insurance with home insurance or multiple vehicles, having advanced safety and anti-theft features in your car, and more.

Thirdly, you can lower your premium by increasing your deductible. This is the amount you pay out of pocket before your insurance coverage begins. By increasing your deductible, you can decrease your auto insurance payments. However, you need to be prepared to pay the deductible amount yourself if you get into an accident, so it is important to have savings set aside.

Another way to lower your premium is to reduce your coverage. You can do this by dropping collision and comprehensive coverage on older cars, or lowering your liability insurance limits. However, you should check that you still meet the minimum amount of car insurance required by your state.

Finally, improving your credit score can help to lower your premium. In some states, a credit check may be part of your risk assessment by insurance companies. People with higher credit scores tend to get lower insurance rates. Therefore, it is worth taking steps to improve your credit score, such as paying your bills on time, decreasing your credit utilisation rate, and checking your credit report for any errors.

Frequently asked questions