White Man's Scheme: Life Insurance Movie Twist

Life insurance is a common plot device in films, often as a negative motivator for criminal activity. One such film is the 1944 film noir classic, Double Indemnity, which received seven Oscar nominations. In the film, a housewife, Phyllis Dietrichson, conspires with an insurance salesman, Walter Neff, to kill her husband and collect on his life insurance policy. This plot is echoed in the 1946 film The Postman Always Rings Twice, in which a woman conspires with a man to kill her husband, partly motivated by his life insurance policy. The 1959 comedy Alias Jesse James also features a life insurance policy as a central plot point, with outlaw Jesse James attempting to collect on his own policy while staying alive.

A wife conspires with a man to kill her husband to benefit from his life insurance policy

The plot of a wife conspiring with a man to kill her husband for his life insurance policy is not a new one. The 1944 film Double Indemnity, considered a classic and one of the greatest films of all time, centres on this premise. An insurance salesman, Walter Neff, played by Fred MacMurray, plots with a housewife, Phyllis Dietrichson, played by Barbara Stanwyck, to kill her husband in order to claim a life insurance payment. The title refers to a "double indemnity" clause that doubles life insurance payouts when death occurs in a statistically rare manner. The film was nominated for seven Academy Awards and is often cited as having set the standard for film noir.

The plot of Double Indemnity has been imitated many times, including in the 1945 film Single Indemnity, and parodied in 1993's Fatal Instinct. The 1946 film The Postman Always Rings Twice, based on the eponymous novel by James M. Cain, also features a similar plot. In this version, a hobo named Frank Chambers starts working at a small restaurant in the country and has an affair with the owner's wife, Cora Smith. The two eventually plot to kill her husband to start a new life together, with the wife's motivation being her husband's life insurance policy. The Italian neorealist version of the film, also based on the novel, features a disgruntled wife who would rather have her husband's life insurance payout and may split the money with her lover.

In addition to these films, there are several real-life cases of wives conspiring with men to kill their husbands for life insurance policies. One such case is that of Nomqondiso, who was found guilty of hiring Wili to kill her husband, Vusumzi, in 2017. Another example is the case of Karl Holger Karlsen, who was convicted of murdering his wife, Christina, by committing arson and collecting $215,000 from her insurance policy.

While the plot of a wife conspiring with a man to kill her husband for his life insurance policy has been explored in film and real life, it is important to note that these stories are fictional or based on criminal acts and should not be considered inspirational.

A man offers an employee money to make his suicide look like murder

The 1944 film noir classic, Double Indemnity, is a prime example of a movie where life insurance plays a pivotal role in the plot. The story revolves around an insurance salesman, Walter Neff, who conspires with a housewife, Phyllis Dietrichson, to kill her husband and collect on his life insurance policy. The title refers to a "double indemnity" clause, which doubles the payout in rare circumstances, such as accidental death. The film, nominated for seven Academy Awards, is known for its iconic characters, including the femme fatale Phyllis, and for setting the standard for film noir.

Another movie that fits the description is Strange Bargain, where a man named Malcolm Jarvis offers his employee, Sam Wilson, $10,000 to make his suicide look like murder. Malcolm's company has gone bankrupt, and he wants his employee to kill him so that his wife and son can collect his life insurance death benefit. Sam initially refuses, but after finding Malcolm's dead body, he decides to honour his wish. The film takes an intriguing turn as Sam is plagued by a crisis of conscience, leading to a big twist ending.

The Postman Always Rings Twice, based on the eponymous novel by James M. Cain, also centres around life insurance. The story follows a hobo, Frank Chambers, who starts working at a small restaurant and has an affair with the owner's wife, Cora Smith. Cora, unhappy in her marriage, conspires with Frank to murder her husband and start a new life together, motivated by the prospect of collecting his life insurance payout.

Alias Jesse James, a 1961 comedy starring Bob Hope, takes a humorous approach to the topic of life insurance. In the film, an insurance agent, Milford Farnsworth, sells a $100,000 policy to the infamous outlaw Jesse James. However, Jesse has a scheme to collect on the policy while staying alive, and the bumbling insurance agent becomes entangled in his plan.

Life insurance has served as a plot device in numerous films, from classics like Double Indemnity to more light-hearted fare like Alias Jesse James. These movies showcase the intriguing, and sometimes treacherous, ways in which life insurance can impact the lives and decisions of the characters.

A woman kills her husband with her lover to start a new life

The plot of a woman killing her husband with her lover's help to start a new life is not unheard of in Hollywood. In fact, the 1944 classic film noir "Double Indemnity" centres on this premise. The film stars Fred MacMurray as Walter Neff, an insurance salesman who plots with a woman, Phyllis Dietrichson (played by Barbara Stanwyck), to kill her husband in order to claim the life insurance payment. The title refers to a "double indemnity" clause, which doubles life insurance payouts when death occurs in a rare manner. The film was nominated for seven Academy Awards and is often cited as one of the greatest films of all time.

Another movie with a similar plot is the 1946 version of "The Postman Always Rings Twice", based on the eponymous novel by James M. Cain. In this film, a hobo named Frank Chambers (John Garfield) starts working at a small restaurant in the country and has an affair with the owner's wife, Cora Smith (Lana Turner). Cora, who does not love her much older husband, Nick Smith (Cecil Kellaway), eventually hatches a plot with Frank to murder her husband so they can start a new life together.

In the 1959 comedy Western "Alias Jesse James" (also known as "The Private Life of Jesse James"), Bob Hope plays Milford Farnsworth, a bumbling insurance salesman who sells a $100,000 policy to the infamous outlaw Jesse James. Jesse then plans to have Farnsworth dress as him and get killed so that Jesse's widow, Cora Lee Collins, can collect the insurance money. However, Cora falls in love with Farnsworth, adding a comedic twist to the plot.

The 1955 film "The Incredibles" also features life insurance as an integral part of the plot. In this Pixar film, public opinion turns against superheroes due to the collateral damage caused by their crime-fighting. As a result, Helen and Bob Parr are forced to abandon their superhero alter egos and try to live normal lives.

An insurance agent sells a policy to an outlaw, then protects him so the company doesn't pay out

The film, a comedy set in 1959, takes an unexpected turn when Jesse James' widow, Cora Lee Collins, falls in love with the insurance agent. This twist adds a layer of complexity to the story, as the outlaw's plans are potentially jeopardized by the romantic entanglement. The audience is treated to a unique plot that blends humour with suspense, as the insurance agent navigates the delicate balance between protecting his client and ensuring the company doesn't pay out.

The premise of an insurance agent selling a policy to an outlaw and then having to protect them is a fascinating exploration of the complexities of the insurance industry. It showcases the challenges faced by insurance agents, who have a duty of care to both their clients and the companies they represent. The agent in this film finds himself in a precarious situation, having to walk a fine line between fulfilling his professional obligations and ensuring the safety of his client, all while being entangled in the outlaw's devious plans.

The film effectively highlights the potential conflicts and ethical dilemmas that insurance agents can face. On one hand, the agent has a responsibility to the insurance company to protect their investment and ensure legitimate payouts. On the other hand, they also have a duty of care to their client, which includes keeping them safely insured and informed. In this case, the agent's client is an outlaw with questionable intentions, creating a tense and intriguing dynamic.

This unique film premise not only provides entertainment but also offers an insightful glimpse into the world of insurance and the complex relationships between agents, clients, and insurance providers. It showcases the delicate balance that insurance agents must maintain, navigating between conflicting interests and the potential consequences of their actions.

A wife kills her husband to cash in on a special clause in his life insurance policy

In the film, the wife, Phyllis Dietrichson, is unhappy in her marriage and desires a drastic change. She conspires with the insurance salesman, Walter Neff, to murder her husband and collect the insurance money. However, their plan does not go as expected, as is often the case in such schemes. The film explores the dark side of human nature and the lengths to which people will go for financial gain.

While "Double Indemnity" is a work of fiction, real-life cases of spouses killing their partners for life insurance money have also made headlines. One such example is the case of Karl Holger Karlsen, who was convicted of murdering his son, Levi, in 2013. Karlsen's son had taken out a life insurance policy worth $700,000 and named his father as the sole beneficiary. Just hours after signing the paperwork, Levi was found dead under a truck in his father's garage.

The conviction raised suspicions about the death of Karlsen's first wife, Christina, who had died in a fire in 1991. It was later discovered that Karlsen had collected $215,000 from her insurance policy shortly after her death. He was eventually convicted of murdering his wife as well, demonstrating that greed can lead people to commit unthinkable acts.

Life insurance policies are meant to provide financial security and peace of mind, but they can also be a source of temptation for those who see them as an opportunity for personal gain. While most people would never consider harming their spouse for money, the combination of love and money has proven to be a potent and dangerous motive in some rare cases. These incidents serve as a stark reminder that life insurance, while important, should never be viewed as a potential windfall.

Frequently asked questions