When Filing An Auto Insurance Claim Can Wait

There are several situations in which it may be better to avoid filing an auto insurance claim. Firstly, if you are involved in a single-car accident and the damage to your vehicle is minor, it is often more cost-effective to pay for repairs yourself rather than risk an increase in insurance rates. Secondly, if the claim amount is the same or less than your deductible, filing a claim may not make financial sense as you would be paying out-of-pocket regardless. Thirdly, if the cost of a potential insurance rate increase over several years would be higher than the out-of-pocket repair costs, it may be wiser to avoid filing a claim. Additionally, for minor accidents with another vehicle where both parties agree to settle privately, it may be preferable to avoid involving insurance companies to prevent potential complications. Lastly, if you have an older vehicle and are not concerned about its cosmetic appeal, you may choose to forgo filing a claim for minor damages.

If damages don't exceed your deductible

If the repair costs are less than your deductible, there is no need to file an auto insurance claim. The deductible is the amount you pay out of pocket before your insurance company covers the remaining costs. So, if your deductible is higher than the cost of repairing the damage to your vehicle, you will be paying for the entire cost yourself, and there is no need to file a claim. For example, if your deductible is $1,000 and your repairs cost $800, you will pay for all the repairs yourself, as the cost is lower than your deductible.

Additionally, if no one else's property is damaged and no one is injured, there is no need to file a claim. This is because your liability insurance covers damage to other people's property and injuries to others. If no one else is involved, and the damage is minor, it is often better to pay for repairs yourself to avoid a possible insurance rate increase.

However, it is important to note that if you have collision coverage, your insurance company will pay for repairs minus your deductible. So, if the repair costs are only slightly more than your deductible, it may still be worth filing a claim.

Moreover, if you live in a no-fault state, your insurance rate may increase even if the accident was not your fault. Therefore, it is essential to consider the potential impact on your insurance rate when deciding whether or not to file a claim.

If it's a minor self-accident

If you've been in a minor self-accident, there are a few things to consider before filing an auto insurance claim. Firstly, check if you have collision coverage as part of your insurance policy. If you don't, and the damage is only to your car, there's no need to contact your insurance company as they won't cover it anyway.

Secondly, assess the damage to your car. If the repair costs are less than your deductible, it's generally not worth filing a claim as there would be no claim payment from your insurer. For example, if your deductible is $500 and the repair costs are $700, you would only receive $200 from your insurer. In this case, it's better to pay for the repairs yourself and avoid a possible insurance rate increase.

Even if the repair costs are slightly more than your deductible, it's still worth considering paying out of pocket to avoid a potential increase in your premiums. Insurance rate increases can be significant and last for several years, so it's important to weigh the short-term cost of repairs against the long-term cost of higher premiums.

Additionally, consider the age and condition of your car. If your car is old and you don't care about its cosmetic appearance, you may choose to leave minor dents or scratches unrepaired.

It's also important to note that if you decide not to file a claim after a minor self-accident, you should still document the accident as much as possible. Take pictures of the damage, get repair estimates, and keep any related receipts. This documentation can be helpful if you need to provide evidence to your insurance company at a later date.

Remember, each situation is unique, and it's always a good idea to review your insurance policy and consult with a trusted source to make an informed decision about filing a claim.

If your insurance rate increase will cost more than out-of-pocket repair costs

If the cost of an insurance rate increase will exceed the cost of out-of-pocket repairs, it may be better to pay for the repairs yourself and avoid a possible insurance rate increase.

A 2017 study found that a $2,000 claim can result in a 44% rate increase. Filing a second claim within a year could see your rate jump by 99%. According to Ross Martin, a licensed insurance agent at The Zebra, an at-fault accident can cost you around $2,000 in premiums over three years. Claims remain on your history for three to five years, so it's worth considering paying for repairs yourself if you want to avoid a rate hike.

If you've been in an accident, get a repair estimate. If the cost of repairs is less than your deductible, there's no point in filing a claim. Your deductible is the amount you pay out of pocket before your insurance company begins to pay out. If the repair costs are more than your deductible, you need to weigh up whether the insurance payout is worth the risk of a rate increase later.

Remember, your insurer can't require you to have repairs done at a particular shop, but they can insist that you get more than one estimate if they feel the initial quote is too high. You don't have to accept the insurer's adjuster's estimate, but it's a good benchmark. You can get your own estimate from your mechanic, garage, or car dealer to compare.

If you have an older vehicle and aren't worried about cosmetic damage

If you have an older vehicle and aren't worried about its cosmetic appeal, you could save money by not filing an auto insurance claim for minor damage. This is because filing a claim can lead to a rate increase, which could cost you more in the long run than simply paying for the repairs yourself.

For example, if you have a $500 deductible and you accidentally reverse into your mailbox, causing $700 of damage, it may not be worth filing a claim. In this case, your deductible will contribute a minimal amount towards your repair costs ($700 - $500 = $200). By choosing not to file a claim, you avoid the possibility of increased insurance premiums, which can be significant. According to a 2017 study, a $2,000 claim can result in a 44% rate increase, and filing a second claim within a year could see your rate jump by 99%.

It's important to note that if the damage affects the functionality of your car or is significant enough to affect its value, it may be worth filing a claim. Additionally, if there are any injuries involved, you should always file a claim, as it's hard to predict how much an injury from a car crash will cost in medical treatment.

When deciding whether or not to file a claim, consider the extent of the damage, the cost of repairs, your deductible amount, and the potential impact on your insurance rates. Remember that even if you choose not to file a claim, it's a good idea to document the incident with photos and, if necessary, file a police report to protect yourself from any future claims or disputes.

If you can settle privately with the other party

Settling a car accident privately with the other party is possible, but it's not always a good idea. Here are some things to keep in mind and steps to take if you decide to settle privately:

When to Consider Settling Privately:

• Minor Accidents: If the accident is minor and both parties agree to settle privately, you may choose to do so. However, be aware that what seems minor could have more serious underlying damage that is only visible to a mechanic.
• Single-Car Accidents: If you were involved in an accident with no other drivers and the damage to your car is minimal, it may be easier to pay for repairs yourself and avoid potential insurance rate increases.

Steps to Take When Settling Privately:

• Exchange Information: Always exchange contact and insurance information with the other driver(s). Get their name, phone number, address, driver's license number, and license plate number. Also, make note of the make, model, and color of their car.
• Document the Accident: Take photos of the damage to all vehicles involved and the scene of the accident. Note the location, date, and time of the accident, and any relevant details such as weather conditions or traffic signals.
• Get a Police Report: Obtain a police report, even if your state doesn't require it. This provides official documentation of the accident, including vehicles and people involved, any injuries, and damage. The police may not respond to minor accidents, but it's worth calling them to request a report.
• Get Multiple Repair Quotes: Get at least two or three estimates from mechanics or repair shops for the cost of repairs. This will help you understand the financial impact of the accident and make an informed decision about whether to involve insurance.
• Keep a Paper Trail: Maintain records of all communication and correspondence with the other party, including receipts, payments, and conversations. Send documents or money with proof of receipt, such as registered mail or electronic transfers.
• Draft a Legally Binding Agreement: When settling, create a contract with the other party that includes key elements such as offer, acceptance, and consideration (money). Consult with a lawyer to ensure the agreement is valid and protects your interests.
• Report the Accident to Your Insurer: While you may choose to settle privately, it's important to report the accident to your insurance company promptly. Failure to do so could impact your ability to make a claim later if issues arise or the settlement falls through.

Risks of Settling Privately:

• Undetected Damage: Settling privately before assessing the full extent of the damage could leave you with unexpected costs. If you've already settled and new damage is discovered, your insurance company may deny a subsequent claim.
• Potential Medical Issues: Injuries may not always be apparent immediately after an accident. If the other party experiences pain or injuries that require treatment later on, you could be held responsible for their medical bills.
• Obligation to Report: Auto insurers typically require you to report accidents promptly. Failing to do so could result in future claims being denied.
• Financial Risk: Settling privately means you are financially responsible for any agreed-upon payments. Be cautious if the other party suggests a private settlement, as they may be trying to avoid responsibility or lack the financial means to pay.

Remember, while settling a car accident privately is an option, it's important to carefully consider the risks and take the necessary steps to protect yourself. Involving your insurance company, especially in more serious accidents, can provide added security and peace of mind.

Frequently asked questions