Autonomous Cars: Disrupting Industries

The rise of autonomous vehicles is set to have a significant impact on the insurance industry. As vehicles become increasingly automated, the liabilities and risks associated with driving will shift, disrupting the insurance market. With the removal of the human driver, the concept of driver error disappears, and the onus will be on manufacturers to prove they are not responsible for accidents. This shift in liability will impact the insurance industry, with premiums potentially changing lines.

While autonomous vehicles may reduce the number of accidents, the costs of repairing high-tech features like cameras and sensors will be much higher. This will result in higher insurance premiums and policy limits for car owners. The shift to autonomous vehicles may also lead to a decrease in vehicle-related workers' compensation claims and a reduction in healthcare and disability insurance costs related to auto accidents.

Insurers will need to adapt to these changes by finding new niches, such as bundle insurance and car-sharing businesses, and developing new products to protect automakers from lawsuits. The competition within the insurance industry will be forced to shift to other aspects of the business, and insurers will need to reconsider how they do business, including establishing relationships with software-as-a-service (SaaS) companies.

The shift in liability from driver to manufacturer

In the case of semi-automated vehicles, where features like manual override are present, the driver can still be held liable for negligence if they fail to take control when warned by the car. On the other hand, for fully automated vehicles, holding the driver liable for negligence would be unfair as they do not have control over the vehicle's actions beyond setting a destination or route.

When it comes to automated vehicles, there are three primary stakeholders who can be held liable: the driver, the manufacturer of the car, and the developer of the automation software. To determine liability, the functions of each stakeholder must be clearly defined and distinguished. For lower levels of automation, the driver's responsibility is to be aware of warnings and take control in situations requiring manual override. Negligence can occur if they fail to fulfil this function. The developers of the car and the software can be held liable for negligence if they fail to take adequate care in manufacturing or maintaining their product, resulting in inherent defects.

However, negligence does not apply to fully automated vehicles as the concept of reasonable care is inherently human and does not extend to machines. In the case of machine error, where the vehicle's actions, although in line with its programming, lead to undesirable outcomes, the question of liability becomes more complex. This could include emergency scenarios where the vehicle must choose between protecting its passengers or pedestrians, or between different directions that may result in harm to different individuals.

To address these complex scenarios, various models for determining liability have been proposed. One popular model mandates that drivers maintain control of the steering wheel, placing greater responsibility and liability on them. However, this model becomes ineffective with fully automated vehicles as the driver's role is significantly reduced. Other models include imposing strict liability on vehicle owners, shifting liability entirely to the manufacturer, sharing liability between the driver and manufacturer, and mandating insurance for road accidents.

While there is no perfect solution, it is crucial that laws and regulations adapt to accommodate the development of autonomous vehicles and protect the interests of all stakeholders involved.

The potential for insurance to be built into the price of a car

Industry Disruption: The traditional auto insurance market, dominated by internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles, is expected to stagnate by the middle of this decade. The shift towards electric vehicles (EVs) and autonomous vehicles (AVs) will likely disrupt the industry, creating opportunities for new insurance products and partnerships.

Built-in Insurance: Consumers are accustomed to purchasing insurance separately from their vehicles. However, with the advancement of autonomous and electric mobility, there is a potential for insurance to be included in the price of a car. This could streamline the process for consumers and provide them with a seamless, "all-in-one" experience.

Data-Driven Insurance: With the proliferation of connected data from vehicles, insurers will have access to real-time information on driving behavior and vehicle performance. This will enable them to more accurately assess and price risk, potentially leading to "pay-how-you-drive" and usage-based insurance models.

Shifting Liability: As autonomous technology advances, the burden of insurance liability will likely shift from human drivers to automakers and software providers. This shift will impact both personal and commercial insurance products, requiring insurers to adapt their policies and claims processes.

Partnerships and Aggregators: OEMs (original equipment manufacturers) may choose to enter the insurance market themselves or partner with insurers. By leveraging their access to customer data and vehicle technology, OEMs could offer insurance directly to consumers or act as aggregators, providing data and distribution channels for insurers.

Claims and Repairs: The claims journey is expected to become more streamlined and automated with the use of connectivity and telematics technology. Artificial intelligence (AI) will interpret data from sensors and cameras, enabling faster and more efficient claims handling. Additionally, OEMs may have a stronger influence on the repair process, ensuring that vehicles are repaired with OEM-certified parts to maintain product warranties.

Market Evolution: The US auto insurance market is expected to evolve in response to these changes. Insurers will need to reconsider their business models and establish relationships with software-as-a-service (SaaS) companies and mobility businesses. The market may see the emergence of new insurance products, shifting liability landscapes, and changing distribution channels.

While the exact timeline for these changes is uncertain, the potential for insurance to be built into the price of a car is a significant development that could reshape the automotive and insurance industries.

The impact on workers' compensation claims

The introduction of automated vehicles is expected to have a significant impact on workers' compensation claims. Driving-related injuries account for approximately 25% of all workers' compensation claims, and car accident claims cost about twice as much as other types of claims due to the frequency of severe injuries. As autonomous vehicles are predicted to reduce the number of road accidents, there will likely be a substantial decrease in the number of driving-related workers' compensation claims. This will have a notable financial impact on the insurance industry, with a potential loss of around $3 billion in workers' comp premiums.

However, it is important to note that the transition to autonomous vehicles may also result in new types of injuries and risks for workers. For example, the introduction of robots in warehouses has led to an increase in employee injuries, with Amazon's internal records from 2019 showing that 14,000 workers in their automated warehouses sustained serious injuries during that year. The productivity quota for workers has also skyrocketed, leading to an increased risk of muscle strain, sprain, and overexertion.

The impact of autonomous vehicles on workers' compensation claims will depend on the balance between the reduction in driving-related injuries and the potential emergence of new types of injuries associated with these technologies. Additionally, the shift in liability from human drivers to manufacturers and software companies may also influence the workers' compensation landscape.

Furthermore, the widespread adoption of autonomous vehicles could result in job losses for professions such as truckers and taxi drivers, who drive for a living. This could have a significant impact on workers' compensation insurers, as these professions account for about five million jobs.

While the overall impact on workers' compensation claims is yet to be fully understood, it is clear that the introduction of autonomous vehicles will bring about significant changes to the industry. Insurers and employers will need to adapt to these changes and redefine what constitutes a work-related injury in the age of autonomous vehicles.

The effect on insurance company profits

The insurance industry is facing a period of significant change and disruption due to the increasing prevalence of autonomous vehicles. This shift will likely have a notable impact on insurance company profits, with a range of factors influencing the extent and nature of this effect.

Firstly, the introduction of autonomous vehicles is expected to reduce the frequency and severity of accidents, leading to a decrease in insurance claims. This will result from the advanced safety features and crash avoidance technologies that these vehicles offer, which address the human error that currently causes the majority of car crashes. The shift towards autonomous vehicles may also lead to a change in liability, with manufacturers and suppliers being held responsible for accidents instead of drivers. This change in liability will impact insurance company profits, as manufacturers will be required to take out different types of insurance policies, such as product liability coverage, to protect themselves from potential claims.

The reduction in accidents and shift in liability is expected to lead to a decrease in insurance premiums for autonomous vehicles compared to traditional automobiles. This decrease in premiums will likely result in a decline in profits for insurance companies, as they collect less money from policyholders. However, the impact on profits may be mitigated by the increased cost of repairing or replacing damaged parts in autonomous vehicles due to their complex components.

Furthermore, the introduction of autonomous vehicles is expected to reduce the need for insurance underwriters. Autonomous vehicles collect driving data through telematics features and usage programs, which can be used to determine insurance premiums without the need for manual underwriting. This development may lead to job losses in the insurance industry, particularly affecting those responsible for underwriting.

While the impact of autonomous vehicles on insurance company profits is complex and multifaceted, it is clear that this technology will disrupt the industry. Insurance companies will need to adapt their business models and strategies to maintain profitability in the face of these changes.

The need for new insurance products

The rise of autonomous vehicles (AVs) will likely bring about a significant shift in the insurance industry, with traditional products and processes becoming obsolete. As vehicles become increasingly automated, the risks and liabilities associated with driving will change, and insurance companies will need to adapt their offerings to keep up with the evolving landscape.

One of the key changes will be the shift in liability. With fully autonomous vehicles, the concept of driver error disappears, and the responsibility for any accidents or incidents will likely fall on the vehicle manufacturer or the provider of the autonomous technology. This shift in liability will require insurance companies to develop new products that cater to the changing needs of their customers.

In addition, the advancement of autonomous technology is expected to reduce the frequency of accidents, resulting in improved safety on the roads. This will have a direct impact on the insurance industry, as the number of claims and payouts are likely to decrease. As a result, insurance companies may need to explore other aspects of the business to maintain profitability.

Furthermore, the cost of repairing advanced driver-assistance systems and autonomous technology is expected to be significantly higher than that of traditional vehicles. This will impact the insurance claims process, as the cost of repairing or replacing damaged parts will increase. Insurance companies will need to take this into account when designing their coverage plans and pricing their policies.

The transition to autonomous vehicles is also expected to impact the way insurance is purchased and distributed. Currently, most consumers buy insurance separately from their vehicles. However, with the advancement of AV technology, there is a possibility that insurance could be built into the price of the car, with manufacturers assuming full liability for accidents caused by their vehicles. This would represent a significant shift in the industry, requiring insurance companies to forge new partnerships and business models.

Overall, the rise of autonomous vehicles will likely lead to a disruption in the insurance industry, with traditional products and processes becoming outdated. Insurance companies will need to innovate and adapt their offerings to cater to the changing needs of their customers. The development of new insurance products that address the unique risks and liabilities associated with autonomous vehicles will be crucial for the industry's future success.

Frequently asked questions