When To Drop Comprehensive Insurance

Comprehensive insurance is a form of motor insurance that covers you for every incident that might involve your vehicle. This includes weather-related accidents, earthquakes and other natural disasters, riots and vandalism, and fallen objects, such as trees. It is optional and you can legally drive a car you own without it, but it is often required if you lease a car or have a car loan.

So, when should you stop carrying comprehensive insurance? Well, there is no easy answer. You have to carefully weigh your options and make a list of pros and cons. One rule of thumb is to drop your comprehensive cover if you are paying too much based on the value of your car. Take your car's value, subtract the deductible, then take away the cost of the six-month policy. If you get a negative amount, it's probably not worth paying for comprehensive cover. Another rule of thumb is that if your annual insurance is over ten per cent of your car's value, it might not be worth taking out additional protection.

When your car's value is minimal and your policy includes a high deductible

When to Drop Comprehensive Insurance on a Minimal-Value Car with a High-Deductible Policy

Comprehensive insurance is a type of car insurance that covers damage to your vehicle caused by events other than collisions. This includes things like natural disasters, vandalism, theft, and contact with animals. While comprehensive insurance is typically required if you have a car loan or lease, it is usually optional for vehicles that are paid off.

If your car's value is minimal and your insurance policy has a high deductible, you may want to consider dropping your comprehensive coverage. Here's why:

The Cost May Outweigh the Benefits

If your car is only worth a few thousand dollars, the potential insurance payout may not be worth the cost of the coverage, especially when you factor in a high deductible. For example, if your car is valued at $2,000 and your policy has a $1,000 deductible, the maximum insurance payout on a comprehensive claim would be $1,000. In this case, the annual premiums may not be justifiable.

You May Be Able to Self-Insure

If you have enough savings to cover potential repairs, you may prefer to self-insure and drop the comprehensive coverage. This is a good option if you can afford to pay for unexpected repairs out of pocket.

Comprehensive Coverage May Still Be Valuable

However, it's important to note that comprehensive coverage can still be valuable, even for older, low-value vehicles. Comprehensive insurance covers a variety of unexpected events and can provide peace of mind. Additionally, if you live in an area prone to natural disasters or collisions with animals, comprehensive coverage could be worth keeping.

Ultimately, the decision to drop comprehensive insurance on a minimal-value car with a high-deductible policy depends on your financial situation, the likelihood of filing a claim, and your comfort level with self-insuring.

When your vehicle is insured on another policy

If your vehicle is insured on a family member's existing policy that includes comprehensive coverage, there is no need to pay for it twice. Note that your car can only be covered on a family member's policy if it is garaged at their residence.

Comprehensive insurance is optional if you own your vehicle. However, if you finance or lease it, your lender will likely require it. Comprehensive insurance is designed to pay for repairs to your vehicle caused by things other than a collision. It covers damage to your car from animals, falling trees, natural disasters, theft, and vandalism. It does not cover damage to other vehicles or people.

If you are thinking of dropping your comprehensive coverage, consider the value of your car. Comprehensive insurance becomes less useful the older your car is because it reimburses you for repairs only up to the actual cash value of your car, minus your deductible, and that value declines as your car ages. So, if your vehicle isn't worth much, it may not make financial sense to keep the coverage. Compare the value of your car to your comprehensive deductible plus the amount you pay for the coverage. If there's not much difference, you're likely paying for coverage you don't need.

When your car is not worth a lot

If your car is not worth a lot, it may be a good idea to drop your comprehensive insurance coverage. Comprehensive insurance covers damage to your car from non-collision events, such as fires, vandalism, or natural disasters. While it is required by lenders if you are financing or leasing a car, it is optional if you own your vehicle.

The general rule is that you should drop your comprehensive cover if the cost is too high relative to the value of your car. To calculate this, take your car's value, subtract the deductible, and then take away the cost of the six-month policy. If you get a negative amount, it is not worth paying for a comprehensive policy.

Comprehensive insurance becomes less useful the older your car is, as it reimburses you for repairs only up to the actual cash value of your car, minus your deductible, and that value declines as your car ages. So, if your car isn't worth much, you may want to consider ditching comprehensive insurance.

However, it's important to consider the cost of parts and repairs before making a final decision, as well as the frequency of covered events in your area. If you live in an area with a high risk of natural disasters or vandalism, for example, comprehensive insurance may still be worth the cost.

Additionally, if you don't have cash savings, it might be better to keep comprehensive insurance so that you don't find yourself without a car if you can't pay for repairs out of pocket. Ultimately, you need to assess your financial situation, your risk tolerance, and how car insurance fits into your budget.

When you can cover the cost of repairs yourself

When considering whether to continue carrying comprehensive insurance on your vehicle, one key factor to consider is your ability to cover the cost of repairs yourself. Comprehensive insurance covers repairs to your car resulting from events like theft, vandalism, fire, or natural disasters, and it is often paired with collision insurance, which covers repairs after an accident. While carrying comprehensive insurance can provide valuable peace of mind, there may come a time when you can confidently self-insure and forgo the additional cost.

As your vehicle ages and depreciates, the cost of repairs may start to outweigh the benefits of comprehensive coverage. This is especially true if your car has a low market value or is paid off. When the cost of repairs or replacements would not cause a significant financial burden, you may consider forgoing comprehensive coverage. For example, if you have savings that could easily cover potential repair costs, or if the repairs would only cost a small fraction of your annual income, self-insuring could be a more cost-effective option.

Another factor to consider is the likelihood of a claim. If you live in an area with a low crime rate and safe parking arrangements, the risk of vandalism or theft may be minimal. Similarly, if you are not in an area prone to natural disasters like hurricanes or wildfires, the chances of damage from these events are reduced. In these cases, the probability of needing to make a comprehensive insurance claim is lower, making it more financially sensible to self-insure.

Additionally, your driving record and history can play a part in your decision. If you are a cautious and experienced driver with no history of accidents or claims, you are less likely to need repairs from events covered by comprehensive insurance. Combining this with safe and secure parking arrangements can further reduce the potential for incidents that comprehensive insurance covers. By assessing your personal situation and financial standing, you can make an informed decision about when to stop carrying comprehensive insurance and rely on your ability to cover repair costs yourself.

When your annual insurance is over 10% of your car's value

When considering whether to maintain comprehensive insurance, it is important to assess the value of your vehicle and weigh it against the cost of your insurance. If your annual insurance cost is over 10% of your car's value, it may be worth reconsidering your coverage.

The actual cash value (ACV) of a car is a term used by insurers to determine its current market value. This is calculated by subtracting depreciation from the original purchase amount. Several factors influence depreciation, including mileage, make, age, model, interior and exterior condition, location, and local demand. While insurance companies may use different methods to calculate ACV, knowing your car's value is essential when shopping for insurance.

If your insurance policy costs more than 10% of your car's ACV, you may want to reconsider your coverage. This is known as the 10% rule and can be a helpful guideline when deciding whether to maintain or drop comprehensive insurance.

For example, let's say you own a car worth $10,000. If your annual insurance cost is $1,500, which is 15% of your car's value, you may want to reconsider your coverage. On the other hand, if your insurance cost is $800, which is 8% of your car's value, it may be more beneficial to keep the insurance.

It's important to note that the 10% rule is just a guideline, and there are other factors to consider as well. For instance, if you live in an area with a high cost of living, insurance prices may be higher, and it may be challenging to find coverage below the 10% mark. Additionally, if you have a high-value car, specialised insurance with greater coverage may be necessary, even if it exceeds the 10% threshold.

Ultimately, the decision to maintain or drop comprehensive insurance should be based on a comprehensive assessment of your car's value, the cost of insurance, and your personal circumstances.

Frequently asked questions