Auto Insurance Premiums: Why The Steep Cost?

Auto insurance premiums are influenced by a variety of factors, some of which are within the policyholder's control, while others are not. The cost of auto insurance has been steadily increasing, with a significant jump of 22% from March 2023 to March 2024, the highest increase since 1976. This rise can be attributed to several reasons, including the rising cost of modern vehicles, increased car repair costs due to supply chain issues and labour shortages, and higher rates of car accidents and injuries as people return to offices and in-person learning. Additionally, inflation, increased medical and legal costs associated with accidents, and distracted driving behaviours have all contributed to higher insurance rates. Location also plays a role, with drivers in large metropolitan areas and certain states experiencing higher premiums due to more crowded roadways and varying regulations.

Inflation and rising car repair costs

The pandemic also played a role in the increase in car repair costs. Supply chain disruptions and labour issues during the pandemic made car parts more expensive and led to longer repair times. The increasing sophistication of technology in vehicles today has also contributed to rising costs. Cameras and sensors, used for driver-assistance technologies, require more expensive parts and higher labour costs.

The higher cost of buying a vehicle has also led to people holding on to their existing cars for longer. As a vehicle ages, it is more likely to need repairs, increasing the demand for repair services. This, in turn, has resulted in higher insurance premiums as insurers try to recoup the cost of claims.

The rise in inflation and car repair costs has had a significant impact on vehicle owners, especially those who depend on their cars for work. The increased costs have added financial stress, and some people may opt for basic repairs instead of comprehensive ones to try to manage the higher prices.

More severe and frequent accidents

There are several factors contributing to the rise in auto insurance premiums, and one of the most pressing issues is the increase in the number and severity of car accidents. This trend has been observed across the United States, with a notable rise in traffic fatalities and severe collisions.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration reported a significant increase in traffic deaths in 2022, with approximately 7,000 more fatalities compared to pre-pandemic levels. This has resulted in a higher number of insurance claims, and the severity of these accidents has led to more costly payouts for insurers. LexisNexis Risk Solutions data indicates that insurers booked losses on 27% of collision claims in 2022, a 3% increase from 2021.

The rise in severe accidents can be attributed to several riskier driving behaviours, including speeding, texting while driving, and driving under the influence of drugs or alcohol. These behaviours not only increase the likelihood of accidents but also tend to result in more severe vehicle damage and injuries. As a result, the cost of repairs and medical care for injured crash victims has increased, contributing to higher insurance premiums.

Additionally, accidents involving newer vehicles with advanced technology and safety features can be more expensive to repair or replace. The sophisticated sensors, cameras, and high-tech components used in modern vehicles are more costly to fix or replace, further adding to the overall expense of accidents.

The increase in accident severity and frequency has had a significant impact on insurance rates, as insurers adjust their premiums to account for the rising cost of claims. This trend highlights the importance of safe driving practices and the need for drivers to be aware of the potential consequences of risky behaviours on the road.

Distracted driving

Texting while driving is illegal in almost every state, and drivers caught engaging in this behaviour can face fines and increased insurance rates. The average rate increase after a texting ticket is 28%, but it can range from 9% to 51% depending on state laws and insurance companies. Some states, like Idaho and North Carolina, prohibit insurers from raising rates based on texting violations.

To avoid distracted driving, it is recommended to keep your phone out of reach, use apps that silence notifications or send auto-replies while driving, model safe driving behaviour, pull over if necessary, use a cellphone mount, and take advantage of safety features in newer vehicles that allow hands-free communication.

Weather catastrophes

The increase in claims due to weather catastrophes is not an isolated incident. The rise in weather-related claims is part of a broader trend of increasing auto insurance claims. This trend is driven by several factors, including the increasing severity of claims, with higher medical and litigation costs, as well as an increase in risky driving behaviours such as distracted driving, speeding, and driving under the influence.

The impact of weather catastrophes on insurance premiums is also influenced by the fact that auto insurance covers more than just vehicle repairs. It also includes the cost of injured crash victims' medical care, lost wages, and repairs or replacements of vehicles and any property damaged in the crash. As medical and auto body repair costs have been increasing at a rate faster than inflation, this further contributes to the rise in insurance premiums.

Additionally, the frequency and severity of car accidents have increased, with the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration reporting a rise of around 7,000 traffic deaths in 2022 compared to pre-pandemic levels. This has led to an increase in claims that is well above historical averages. LexisNexis Risk Solutions data indicates that insurers booked losses on 27% of collision claims in 2022, a three-percentage-point increase from 2021.

The combination of severe weather events and increasing claims puts pressure on insurance companies, who then pass on some of these costs to their customers in the form of higher premiums. As a result, weather catastrophes are a significant factor contributing to the overall increase in auto insurance rates.

Location and personal characteristics

Auto insurance premiums are influenced by a range of factors, including location and personal characteristics.

Location

Location is a primary factor affecting auto insurance rates. Premiums vary significantly by state, ZIP code, and neighborhood. Rural drivers generally pay less than those in urban areas, where vandalism, theft, and accidents are more prevalent. The number of crashes and the cost of these crashes also impact rates, with more crowded roadways in large metropolitan areas leading to an increased number of accidents.

Personal Characteristics

Age is a significant factor, with younger, less experienced drivers considered more likely to be involved in fatal accidents. As a result, drivers in their 20s often face higher insurance rates. Gender also plays a role, with young men typically charged higher rates than young women due to perceived risk factors. Marital status is another consideration, as married drivers often benefit from lower rates than their single, separated, divorced, or widowed counterparts.

Education level is another factor, with drivers holding college degrees generally paying less for auto insurance. Some insurers argue that highly educated individuals tend to file fewer claims, although the use of education levels in pricing has faced criticism in recent years, leading some states to move away from this practice.

Occupation can also influence insurance rates, with certain professions deemed more likely to file insurance claims. However, this practice has been challenged by consumer advocates, and some states have banned or are considering banning it.

Credit score is a further consideration, with many insurers using credit-based insurance scores to set prices. Poor credit can significantly impact auto insurance rates, although this practice is not allowed in all states.

In conclusion, location and personal characteristics play a significant role in determining auto insurance premiums. Rates vary based on factors such as age, gender, marital status, education, occupation, and credit score. These factors are used by insurers to assess the risk of insuring an individual, with higher-risk individuals typically facing higher premiums.

Frequently asked questions