Unraveling The Pharmacy Billing Conundrum: Navigating Multiple Insurances

Pharmacy billing refers to the process of sending a prescription to a pharmacy, which then bills the patient's drug insurance and dispenses the medication. On the other hand, medical billing involves the provider's office billing the patient's medical insurance for the drug and then purchasing it through a drug distributor or pharmacy. In certain cases, insurance companies require either medical or pharmacy billing, while in other instances, the provider has the option to choose. Pharmacy billing can simplify the clinic's workflow, but it also has some drawbacks, such as increased risks of temperature excursions and waste. Medical billing, on the other hand, can be more profitable for the provider's office but comes with additional administrative time and costs associated with purchasing and storing medications. Ultimately, the choice between pharmacy and medical billing depends on various factors, including the specific medications required, insurance coverage, and the patient's preference for convenience or cost savings.

The pharmacy may be out-of-network

In some cases, certain medications must be filled through a mail-order pharmacy and are not offered at a retail pharmacy location. Some plans stipulate that you must use a mail-order pharmacy for all refills after your first in-person fill of a medication. This is becoming more common with many recurring maintenance medications.

It's worth noting that some pharmacies are opting out of the insurance system altogether, instead selling generic drugs at wholesale prices, which can save customers hundreds of dollars a month. These "cash" or "self-pay" pharmacies avoid the fees and rules that inflate medication prices within the insurance system.

The medication may not be covered by your insurance plan

When you visit a pharmacy to fill a prescription, you may assume that your insurance will cover the cost of the medication. However, in some cases, you may discover that your insurance plan does not cover certain medications, leaving you with unexpected out-of-pocket expenses. This can be frustrating and financially burdensome, especially if the medication is necessary for your health and well-being.

There are several reasons why a particular medication may not be covered by your insurance plan. One common reason is that the medication may be considered experimental, investigational, or not medically necessary by your insurance company. Insurance companies typically have formularies, which are lists of approved drugs that they cover. If a medication is not on their formulary, they may not provide coverage for it. This can include newer or more expensive drugs that are still undergoing evaluation for their effectiveness and safety.

Another reason could be that your insurance plan requires the use of generic drugs whenever possible. If a brand-name drug has an equivalent generic version available, your insurance company may deny coverage for the brand-name drug. This is because generic drugs usually cost significantly less than their brand-name counterparts, and insurance companies aim to keep their costs down. In some cases, your doctor may be able to file an appeal or provide a prior authorization to your insurance company, explaining the medical necessity of a brand-name drug over the generic version.

Additionally, certain specialty medications or those used for rare or complex conditions may not be covered by standard insurance plans. These medications are often very expensive, and insurance companies may have specific protocols or requirements that must be met before they will provide coverage. This could include trying alternative treatments first or obtaining prior authorization from your insurance company, which involves your doctor providing documentation to demonstrate the medical necessity of the medication.

If you encounter a situation where your insurance does not cover a medication you need, there are a few steps you can take. Firstly, talk to your doctor or healthcare provider. They may be able to prescribe an alternative medication that is covered by your insurance or work with your insurance company to obtain prior authorization for the medication. Secondly, review your insurance plan's coverage and formulary to understand their medication coverage policies and any exceptions or appeals processes they offer. Finally, look into patient assistance programs offered by pharmaceutical companies or non-profit organizations, which may be able to provide financial assistance or free medication to those who qualify.

It is important to remember that insurance plans vary, and understanding your specific coverage is essential. Regularly reviewing your insurance plan's benefits and exclusions can help you anticipate and navigate situations where your medication may not be fully covered. By being proactive and understanding your options, you can better manage your healthcare and ensure you have access to the medications you need.

Your insurance information on file may be incorrect or outdated

If your pharmacy is unable to bill your insurance, it may be because the insurance information they have on file for you is incorrect or outdated. This is a common issue, and it's important to address it to ensure that you can use your insurance coverage for your medications. Here are some steps you can take to correct incorrect or outdated insurance information:

• Contact your insurance company: Call the phone number on the back of your insurance card or locate their website to get in touch with their customer service department. Be prepared for a possible lengthy hold time if you call. On their website, look for any change forms that you can complete and submit online or print and mail back.
• Name changes: Name changes are common, especially for women. Most insurance companies will require proof of a name change and will not accept a verbal change over the phone. Proof can include a certified copy of your marriage license, divorce decree, birth certificate, or other legal documents.
• Address changes: Address changes are also common. In some cases, you may be able to fill out an online submission form to update your address. For Medicare, they will use the address currently on file with the Social Security Administration, so you may need to update your address with them first.
• Eligibility questions: Only your insurer can provide specific eligibility and benefit information and explain why something isn't covered. In general, state Medicaid and Medicaid replacement plans (HMO, MCO, PPO) will cover incontinence supplies, while Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans do not. Commercial and private pay insurance plans typically do not cover incontinence supplies.
• Review your application: It's always a good idea to review the information your insurance provider has on file once a year. Keep a copy of your policy and take the time to understand your coverage and limitations. If you notice any mistakes, contact your representative to correct the information.
• Incorrect information on your application: Providing inaccurate information on your insurance application can have consequences. In some cases, it could result in the cancellation of your policy or increased rates or compensation. It's important to be honest and accurate when providing information on your insurance application to avoid these issues.

By taking these steps, you can help ensure that your insurance information is correct and up-to-date, which may resolve issues with your pharmacy billing your insurance.

The medication may be cheaper without insurance

Secondly, drug companies and insurance companies negotiate deals on how much consumers pay out of pocket for medications, and these deals vary by insurance company. This can result in confusion and frustration for consumers, who may find that their insurance company's formulary (i.e., the list of covered drugs) does not cover the cost of their medication. Additionally, insurance companies may have high copays or coinsurance for certain drugs, making it more financially sensible to pay the cash price without insurance.

Thirdly, the cost of prescription drugs can vary significantly from one pharmacy to another. A survey by Consumer Report found that drug prices could differ by up to ten times in the same city. Independent and supermarket pharmacies tend to have lower prices than national chain pharmacies. Online or mail-order pharmacies may also offer lower prices and the convenience of medication delivery.

Lastly, there are various ways to save on prescription drug costs, with or without insurance. These include using coupons, prescription drug discount cards, prescription assistance programs, generic drug alternatives, and shopping around for the best prices.

The pharmacy may be a cash pharmacy that doesn't accept insurance

A "cash pharmacy" is a small but growing number of pharmacies that do not accept insurance. Instead, they sell generic drugs at wholesale prices, plus a small markup that goes to the pharmacy. This can often be much cheaper than buying with insurance.

For example, Nate Hux, owner of Pickerington Pharmacy in Ohio, opened Freedom Pharmacy in 2020, a separate business that does not accept insurance. One of his customers, Sharon Kitchen, found that her eight medications were far cheaper at Freedom Pharmacy. One of her medications cost $141 for a three-month supply with insurance, but was just $23.40 without it.

Cash pharmacies are able to offer lower prices by opting out of the insurance system, thus avoiding the fees and rules that inflate medication prices. According to Avalere Health, a health care data analytics and consulting firm, 91% of prescriptions in the U.S. are filled through insurance. However, high-deductible health plans (HDHPs) are becoming increasingly common, with enrollment increasing from 19% of covered workers in 2012 to 29% in 2022. With the rising co-pays of HDHPs, patients can sometimes overpay for their prescriptions when using insurance. This is forcing cost-conscious customers to find new ways to save.

In addition, working with insurance is expensive for pharmacies. The various fees, rules, and processing time that come with accepting insurance affect how pharmacies operate and push up labor costs. By cutting out the middlemen, cash pharmacies are much cheaper to operate.

However, it is important to note that cash pharmacies still make up a tiny portion of the market, and most Americans are unlikely to have one in their community.

Frequently asked questions