Insurance Scams: Why The Risk?

Insurance fraud is a deliberate deception perpetrated against or by an insurance company or agent for financial gain. It has existed since the beginning of insurance as a commercial enterprise and is a significant problem, costing billions of dollars annually. The chief motive in all insurance crimes is financial profit, with fraudsters viewing it as a low-risk, lucrative enterprise.

Insurance fraud can be committed by both buyers and sellers of insurance. On the seller side, common schemes include premium diversion, fee churning, and asset diversion. On the buyer side, it can involve exaggerated or false claims, falsified medical history, post-dated policies, and even faked death or kidnapping.

Insurance fraud affects all areas of insurance, including health insurance, property insurance, auto insurance, and workers' compensation. It is a bigger problem than many realise, with Americans losing at least $80 billion a year to insurance fraud, according to the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud.

Financial gain

One of the most common types of insurance fraud is premium diversion, where an insurance agent or broker keeps the policyholder's premium payments instead of sending them to the insurance company. This can occur when an agent fails to send premiums to the underwriter and instead uses the money for personal gain or when an unlicensed individual sells insurance and collects premiums without any intention of paying claims. Another form of insurance fraud is asset diversion, which involves acquiring control of an insurance company with borrowed funds and then diverting the company's assets for personal gain.

Insurance fraud can also occur when individuals inflate or exaggerate claims to receive a larger payout. This type of fraud, known as "padding," is common in natural disasters, as it can be challenging to prove the extent of the damage. Individuals may also stage accidents or file false claims, such as reporting a burglary that never occurred or causing a car accident to collect insurance money.

Healthcare insurance fraud is a significant concern, with fraudulent activities by doctors, hospitals, and other providers resulting in billions of dollars in losses annually. This includes billing for services not rendered, upcoding (billing for more expensive procedures than were performed), filing duplicate claims, and performing unnecessary services.

Insurance company fraud is another form of financial gain through deception. Illegitimate insurance companies and dishonest agents may collect premiums for bogus policies, never intending to pay out claims. These companies often offer policies at significantly lower prices to attract consumers looking for a bargain. In some cases, even legitimate insurance agents may be misled by these fraudulent companies, unknowingly selling policies that have no value.

Low risk, high reward

Insurance fraud is often viewed as a low-risk, high-reward enterprise. The potential for large financial gains is a significant motivator for insurance scams. The "chief motive in all insurance crimes is financial profit", and the rewards can be substantial.

Insurance fraud has existed since the inception of insurance as a commercial enterprise. It is perpetrated by both claimants and insurance company employees, and it affects all areas of insurance. Fraudulent claims can range from slightly exaggerating claims to deliberately causing accidents or damage. The diverse nature of insurance fraud makes it challenging to detect and combat.

The financial incentives for insurance scams are considerable. In the United States, insurance fraud costs consumers an estimated $308.6 billion annually, according to a 2022 study by the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud (CAIF). This includes fraud across various sectors, such as life insurance, property and casualty insurance, workers' compensation, and auto theft. The cost of insurance fraud is ultimately borne by honest consumers, as insurers pass on the costs in the form of higher premiums. The average U.S. family pays between $400 and $700 more per year due to insurance fraud.

The potential for significant financial gain, coupled with the perception of low risk, makes insurance fraud an attractive proposition for scammers. The lenient court sentences for insurance fraud compared to other crimes further reduce the perceived risk. Additionally, insurance companies sometimes settle suspicious claims instead of pursuing legal action, as it can be cheaper to do so.

Insurance fraud can take many forms, from opportunistic soft fraud to more elaborate hard fraud schemes. Soft fraud, which is more common, involves policyholders exaggerating legitimate claims or misrepresenting facts on insurance applications. Hard fraud, on the other hand, involves deliberately planning or inventing a loss, such as a collision or theft, to claim payment for damages.

The diverse and creative nature of insurance scams, along with the potential for substantial financial rewards, makes insurance fraud an ongoing challenge for the industry. While insurers are constantly improving their fraud detection methods, including the use of artificial intelligence, the perception of insurance fraud as a low-risk, high-reward endeavour persists.

Greed

Insurance fraud can be lucrative due to holes in protections against fraud and the leniency of court sentences. Insurance fraud can be easier and less risky than other crimes, and the potential financial rewards are high. Fraudulent claims can be worth billions of dollars annually and account for a significant portion of all claims received by insurers.

Insurance fraud can also be lucrative because of weaknesses in the insurance system itself. For example, some insurance providers may pay suspicious claims as it is often cheaper than pursuing legal action. In addition, insurance providers may sometimes encourage over-insurance, where someone insures property for more than its real value, as a way to obtain greater profits. This enables fraudsters to profit by destroying their property since they receive an insurance payout greater than the value of the property.

Insurance fraud can take many forms, from slightly exaggerating claims to deliberately causing accidents or damage. Common frauds include "padding" (inflating claims), misrepresenting facts on an insurance application, submitting claims for injuries or damage that never occurred, and staging accidents. Fraudulent activities affect the lives of innocent people, both directly and indirectly by increasing insurance premiums.

Lack of deterrents

Insurance fraud has existed since the beginning of insurance as a commercial enterprise. The "chief motive in all insurance crimes is financial profit". People who commit insurance fraud include organized criminals who steal large sums, professionals and technicians who inflate service costs, and ordinary people who want to cover their deductible or view filing a claim as an opportunity to make a little money.

Compared to other crimes, court sentences for insurance fraud can be lenient, reducing the risk of extended punishment. Insurance fraud is deliberately undetectable, and the number of detected cases is much lower than the number of actual cases. This makes it hard to place an exact value on the money stolen through insurance fraud. The best that can be done is to provide an estimate for the losses that insurers suffer due to insurance fraud.

In the United States, the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud estimates that insurance fraud costs consumers $308.6 billion yearly. The FBI estimates the cost to be over $40 billion per year, which increases the premiums for the average U.S. family by between $400 and $700 annually. According to the Insurance Information Institute, insurance fraud accounts for about 10% of the property/casualty insurance industry's incurred losses and loss adjustment expenses.

The National Health Care Anti-Fraud Association estimates that 3% of the healthcare industry's expenditures in the United States are due to fraudulent activities, amounting to a cost of about $51 billion. Other estimates attribute as much as 10% of the total healthcare spending in the United States to fraud—about $115 billion annually.

Insurance fraud can be classified as either hard fraud or soft fraud. Hard fraud occurs when someone deliberately plans or invents a loss, such as a collision, auto theft, or fire that is covered by their insurance policy to claim payment for damages. Soft fraud, which is far more common than hard fraud, consists of policyholders exaggerating otherwise legitimate claims. For example, when involved in an automotive collision, an insured person might claim more damage than actually occurred.

Insurance fraud affects the lives of innocent people, both directly through accidental or intentional injury or damage and indirectly by the crimes leading to higher insurance premiums.

Opportunism

Insurance scams can be committed by a range of people, from organised criminal gangs to professionals and ordinary individuals. Opportunists will often inflate or exaggerate claims, or even cause deliberate damage, to receive a higher payout. This can include adding pre-existing damage to a claim for a legitimate accident, or inflating the cost of repairs. For example, a car owner might approach a repair shop and ask them to add the cost of their deductible to the bill, with the shop then billing the insurance company for the full amount.

Opportunistic fraudsters also take advantage of natural disasters or accidents by filing false or exaggerated claims. They may even intentionally damage their property further to increase the amount they can claim. This type of fraud is common following natural catastrophes, and can also involve contractors who take advantage of homeowners by performing unnecessary or inflated repairs.

Another form of opportunistic fraud is "title washing", where the identities of vehicles are altered to hide the fact that they have been damaged by flooding. This often involves switching or cloning vehicle identification numbers and putting them on repaired but flooded vehicles, which are then sold on.

Healthcare insurance is also a common target for opportunists, who may bill insurance companies for services never rendered, or for more expensive treatments than those actually provided. This type of fraud can involve both medical providers and patients, who may be unwittingly drawn into a scam.

Overall, opportunism in insurance scams takes many forms, but all are driven by the desire to exploit the system for financial gain.

Frequently asked questions