Auto Insurance In Illinois: Why So Expensive?

Illinois car insurance is considered moderate compared to other states, with the average yearly cost for a car insurance policy with full coverage being around $1,127. However, the cost of car insurance in Illinois has been rising steadily, and there are several reasons for this. Firstly, people in Illinois are driving more, resulting in an increase in accidents, claims, and payouts. Secondly, auto repairs are becoming more expensive due to the added technology and features in modern vehicles. Thirdly, the number of uninsured drivers in Illinois is increasing as the cost of car insurance continues to rise, and finally, healthcare in Illinois is becoming more costly, with insurance companies bearing the brunt of these increases when paying out claims involving medical bills.

Illinois' high number of uninsured drivers

Illinois has a high number of uninsured drivers compared to other states. In 2019, the last time the Insurance Research Council published national data, an estimated 12% of drivers in the U.S. lacked car insurance, which equated to over 29 million licensed drivers. The state with the highest percentage of uninsured motorists is Mississippi, where one in three drivers lack insurance. In contrast, New Jersey has the lowest recorded percentage of uninsured drivers at 3.1%.

In Illinois, 12% of drivers lacked even minimum liability insurance in 2019. This means that out of the 29 million uninsured drivers in the U.S., approximately 2.3 million of them are in Illinois. The high number of uninsured drivers in Illinois is likely due to the rising cost of car insurance, with more drivers taking the risk of driving without it. As a result, insured drivers in Illinois may experience higher premiums to compensate for the cost of uninsured drivers.

The percentage of uninsured drivers in a state is an important factor in determining insurance premiums. States with a high rate of uninsured drivers typically have higher insurance premiums. This is because insured drivers must bear the cost of accidents caused by uninsured drivers. Uninsured motorist coverage is relatively inexpensive, with a median price of $50 a year for bodily injury coverage and $38 a year for property damage coverage. This coverage can provide financial protection in the event of an accident with an uninsured driver.

In Illinois, the average cost of car insurance is moderate compared to other states. The average annual premium for full coverage is around $1,127, while state minimum coverage costs approximately $483. The cost of car insurance in Illinois is influenced by various factors, including the level of traffic, urban versus rural areas, and local regulations. The degree of urbanization in large cities like Chicago can lead to higher rates due to increased traffic and the likelihood of accidents. However, the overall insurance costs in Illinois are kept moderate by a good balance of urban and rural areas and a lower rate of natural disasters.

The rising cost of auto parts

The rising cost of car parts is a significant factor in the increasing expense of auto insurance in Illinois. This trend is not unique to the state but is observed across the nation. Several factors contribute to this phenomenon, and understanding them is crucial for comprehending the broader context of auto insurance rates.

Firstly, the cost of car parts has been steadily increasing over the years. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, prices for motor vehicle parts and equipment in 2024 are significantly higher than in 1977, reflecting an average inflation rate of 1.87% per year. This means that car parts costing $500 in 1977 would cost a staggering $1,196.41 in 2024. This price increase has a direct impact on the cost of repairing or replacing vehicle components, which is reflected in higher insurance premiums.

Secondly, advancements in vehicle technology have led to more expensive car parts and the need for specialized technicians. Modern cars are essentially computers on wheels, packed with sophisticated technology and safety features. The cost of repairing or replacing these high-tech parts is much higher than their older counterparts. Additionally, some car manufacturers have started patenting basic parts, such as fenders and headlights, restricting the availability of lower-cost alternatives. This creates a monopoly that forces drivers to pay higher prices for repairs.

Furthermore, the recent microchip shortage has also contributed to higher car prices and insurance premiums. A vehicle may have over 100 microchips that enable various functions. The shortage has reduced the supply of vehicles, leading to increased prices due to higher demand as driving habits return to pre-pandemic levels.

Inflation is another critical factor driving up the cost of car repairs and, consequently, insurance premiums. Inflation diminishes the buying power of consumers, resulting in higher prices for auto maintenance and repairs. As insurance companies cover the cost of these repairs, they pass on the increased costs to consumers in the form of higher insurance rates.

Lastly, the correlation between car prices and insurance rates is evident. As the cost of buying a car increases, insurance rates tend to rise accordingly. This is because more expensive cars often require costly replacement parts and specialized technicians for repairs.

In summary, the rising cost of auto parts is a multifaceted issue influenced by inflation, technological advancements, supply shortages, and the economics of supply and demand. These factors collectively contribute to higher auto insurance premiums, not just in Illinois but across the nation.

Healthcare costs are increasing

The cost of car insurance is steadily increasing in Illinois, and one of the key factors driving this increase is the rising cost of healthcare. When there are claims involving medical bills, car insurance companies have to pay out substantial amounts, and as healthcare costs go up, so do the payouts from insurance companies. This, in turn, leads to higher premiums for consumers.

In addition to the rising cost of healthcare, there are several other factors contributing to the increase in car insurance rates in Illinois. One factor is that people in Illinois are driving more, leading to an increase in accidents, claims, and payouts. The number of fatal crashes in the state has risen in recent years, which has a direct impact on insurance costs.

Another factor is the increasing cost of auto repairs. With the addition of new technology and features, vehicles today are more expensive to repair. This means that when accidents occur, the cost of fixing the damage is higher, and this is reflected in the insurance premiums.

The rise in healthcare costs in Illinois is a significant contributor to the overall increase in car insurance rates. As healthcare spending continues to rise, car insurance companies are faced with higher costs, which are then passed on to consumers in the form of higher premiums. This trend is expected to continue, and it will be a key factor in the future of car insurance rates in Illinois.

Severe weather events are becoming more common

Illinois is experiencing more frequent and intense severe weather events, including storms, serious winter weather, and droughts. These weather events are causing insurers to pay out a higher number of claims, which tend to be more expensive and less predictable. Consequently, insurers have to raise rates to keep up with the increasing number of claims.

In recent years, severe weather events have had a significant financial impact on both homeowners and drivers in Illinois. Between 2014 and 2023, there were a record-breaking 183 billion-dollar disaster events. These events have resulted in increased costs for both auto and home insurance, as well as other household expenses such as higher utility bills and evacuation costs, which are typically not covered by insurance.

The increase in severe weather events has also led to a rise in the cost of auto insurance across the country. In areas that experience repeated catastrophic losses, such as Florida and California, insurance premiums have surged due to the heightened risk of future losses. Weather-related damage covered by car insurance includes:

• Windshield damage from hail or flying debris
• Flood damage
• Damage from fallen trees or branches
• Vandalism or theft during a power outage

While Illinois residents may not be able to control the impact of severe weather on their auto insurance rates, they can take steps to mitigate the financial impact. Preventative measures such as home and auto maintenance can help reduce losses from extreme weather. Additionally, reviewing insurance policies regularly and comparing rates from different insurers can help identify ways to lower costs.

The state's high DUI rate

Illinois has a DUI law that limits the maximum blood alcohol concentration (BAC) to 0.08. This law was implemented in 1997, and since then, there has been a 43% reduction in drunk driving fatalities in the state. Despite this improvement, Illinois still has a high rate of DUI offences, which contributes to the high cost of auto insurance in the state.

In 2017, Illinois police officers arrested 27,046 DUI offenders, with 91% of them losing their driving privileges. The typical DUI offender in Illinois is male, and the average age of offenders is 34 years old. Most drunk driving arrests occur between 11 pm and 4 am, and the average BAC is twice the legal limit.

The consequences of driving under the influence are severe and can include emotional, financial, and physical hardships for the driver. In Illinois, a DUI conviction can result in up to one year in prison and a maximum fine of $2,500. For subsequent convictions within five years, the penalties increase, including mandatory minimum sentences, community service, and higher fines.

The high rate of DUI offences in Illinois impacts the cost of auto insurance in the state. Insurance companies take into account the driving record of individuals when determining their insurance premiums. A DUI conviction can nearly double insurance rates, with an average increase of 82% in Illinois.

Additionally, the cost of auto insurance is influenced by other factors such as age, credit score, vehicle type, and location. However, the high rate of DUI offences is a significant contributor to the high cost of auto insurance in Illinois.

Frequently asked questions