Michigan's High Insurance Rates: What's The Deal?

Michigan is the most expensive state in the country for car insurance, with drivers paying an average of $7,161 per year for full-coverage insurance. This is 270% more than the national average and nearly double the cost of the next most expensive state. There are several reasons for Michigan's high insurance rates, including its no-fault status, high minimum insurance requirements, a large number of uninsured drivers, a high rate of insurance fraud, and frequent personal injury lawsuits.

Michigan's no-fault insurance system

Under Michigan's no-fault law, drivers must select their desired level of Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage. PIP insurance covers medical care, treatment, recovery, and rehabilitation expenses related to car accidents. Prior to reforms, Michigan law required drivers to purchase "unlimited" PIP coverage, with no cap on medical benefits. However, after July 1, 2020, drivers were given the option to choose between different coverage levels, ranging from $50,000 to $500,000, or even opting out if they are on Medicare.

The no-fault insurance system in Michigan has been a significant contributor to the state's high insurance rates. In the past, no-fault or PIP claims accounted for a large portion of Michigan's insurance losses, with a minimum limit of $250,000. This led to higher payouts and higher losses for insurance companies, which resulted in increased insurance rates for drivers. While the recent reforms aimed to reduce insurance costs, many drivers and experts have not seen significant savings, and Michigan remains one of the most expensive states for car insurance.

One of the reasons for the high insurance rates in Michigan is the generous coverage provided by the no-fault insurance system. The state has high minimum liability coverage requirements, including a $1 million property damage liability minimum for in-state accidents. Additionally, Michigan handles all medical and personal injury coverage after the first $600,000, which is significantly higher than in other states. This extensive coverage contributes to the rise in auto insurance premiums. Furthermore, Michigan has a high percentage of uninsured drivers, exceeding 25%, which also impacts insurance rates.

While the no-fault insurance system in Michigan has its challenges, it is designed to protect car accident victims and ensure they receive the compensation they need. The system aims to provide financial support for medical expenses and lost wages, regardless of who is at fault in an accident. However, the high insurance rates associated with this system have been a concern for many Michigan residents.

High number of uninsured drivers

Michigan has a high percentage of uninsured drivers, with estimates ranging from 20% to 25% of all drivers in the state. This is significantly higher than the national average of 13%. The presence of so many uninsured drivers on Michigan's roads has a direct impact on insurance rates for those who are insured. When an accident occurs involving an uninsured driver, insurance companies often have to cover the costs, and they do so by increasing premiums for their customers. This practice, known as cost-shifting, means that insured drivers end up paying more to compensate for the actions of those who are uninsured.

The high rate of uninsured drivers in Michigan also leads to a higher number of claims being made against insured drivers. When an uninsured driver causes an accident and cannot pay for the damages, the financial burden often falls on the insured driver involved. This dynamic further contributes to the rise in insurance premiums, as insurance companies adjust their rates to account for the increased risk of accidents involving uninsured motorists.

The issue of uninsured drivers is not unique to Michigan, but the state's relatively high percentage of uninsured drivers exacerbates the problem. This situation creates a significant risk for all drivers on Michigan's roads and contributes to the state's notoriously high insurance premiums.

To mitigate the risks associated with uninsured drivers, some experts recommend that Michigan drivers consider purchasing Uninsured Motorist (UM) and Underinsured Motorist (UIM) coverage. These optional types of coverage can provide additional protection and help cover costs if an accident involves a driver who lacks sufficient insurance or has no insurance at all.

High rate of insurance fraud

Michigan has some of the highest insurance rates in the country, and a contributing factor to this is the high rate of insurance fraud in the state. Insurance fraud affects everyone in the state and costs Americans billions of dollars every year. In 2020, auto insurance fraud made up 81% of all insurance coverage fraud in Michigan, with the state losing at least $29 billion a year in premium leakage. This includes missing or wrong information provided by drivers, which inaccurately lowers auto premiums. These losses amount to 14% of all personal auto premiums.

The state of Michigan does not have a watchdog group to monitor no-fault insurance fraud, which contributes to the high number of lawsuits. Other no-fault states, like Florida, have watchdog groups that pursue fraud in urban areas, which helps to keep insurance costs down. In addition, Michigan has a high percentage of uninsured drivers, with more than 25% of drivers in the state uninsured, which also raises insurance rates.

The high rate of insurance fraud in Michigan has led to increased scrutiny by insurance companies. More than 60% of insurers say fraud has climbed over the last three years, and nearly 75% of insurers now use automated systems to detect false claims. This is a large increase over the 2014 and 2012 studies, where the use of such systems was much lower. Insurers are also increasingly using rate-evasion tech and predictive modelling to detect fraud.

The state of Michigan has taken some steps to address insurance fraud. The Fraud Investigation Unit (FIU) is a criminal justice agency within the Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services dedicated to preventing criminal and fraudulent activities in the insurance and financial services markets. However, despite these efforts, insurance fraud in Michigan remains a significant issue, contributing to the high cost of insurance in the state.

High medical costs

Michigan has some of the highest insurance premiums in the country. The state's extremely high insurance premiums are driven by many factors, including high medical costs.

Michigan's no-fault auto insurance law is unique and complex. Under this system, drivers turn to their insurance companies after an accident, regardless of who is at fault. The aim is to ensure quick payments for medical expenses, wage loss, and other costs. One major feature is the unlimited Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage. This means that insurance will cover high medical bills for life. While this offers comprehensive protection, it also significantly raises premiums. Michigan is the only state with such unlimited benefits.

PIP medical coverage costs in Michigan are exceptionally high. Higher medical costs mean that insurance companies have to pay out more for each claim, which drives up the cost of insurance for everyone. Michigan's PIP has a minimum limit of $250,000, which is significantly more than the average total losses that no-fault losses account for across the US. Higher PIP limits mean higher payouts and higher losses.

Michigan also has the highest property damage liability minimum of any state - $1 million for in-state accidents. The Michigan Catastrophic Claims Association (MCCA) handles all medical or personal injury coverage after the first $600,000, which is the most generous policy in the US. This extensive coverage causes auto insurance premiums to rise. In Detroit, in particular, medical bills are exorbitant. For example, as of 2017, Detroit medical providers charged as much as $5,300 for an MRI that would cost under $500 with Medicare or under $1,000 at other facilities.

High number of deer-car collisions

Michigan has a high number of deer-car collisions, which is a contributing factor to the state's high insurance costs. According to the Michigan Office of Highway Safety Planning, there were over 58,000 motor vehicle-deer crashes in 2022, exceeding the typical average of 50,000. These collisions can result in significant repair costs, often reaching thousands of dollars.

Deer-car accidents in Michigan are covered by insurance, but the type of coverage available depends on the specific circumstances. No-Fault insurance covers medical treatment for injuries sustained in a deer-car collision. This includes medical expenses, lost wages, and attendant care in cases of serious injury. Additionally, Survivor's Loss Coverage provides financial support to families if a loved one passes away in a deer-related car accident.

However, it's important to note that injured individuals cannot claim pain and suffering compensation or "uninsured" or "underinsured" motorist benefits in deer-car accidents. This is because there is no at-fault driver who can be held liable for the crash and resulting injuries. To cover vehicle damage, comprehensive insurance is required. This type of coverage is optional and will help pay for repairs if the car is damaged by a collision with an animal, among other things.

The fall season, particularly during hunting season and shorter daylight hours, tends to see an increase in deer-car collisions. This is due to deer being more active and moving erratically during this time of year. As a result, insurance providers often take these seasonal factors into account when determining coverage and rates for Michigan drivers.

Frequently asked questions