Auto Insurance Claims: What's The Cost Of Filing?

Whether or not your auto insurance premium will increase if you file a claim depends on several factors. These include the type of claim, the number of claims, the severity of the accident, and whether you are at fault. In general, the more claims you file, the more your insurance will cost. Filing an at-fault claim is very likely to lead to an increase in your insurance rates, with one major insurance company reporting an average increase of 28% after an at-fault claim. Even if you are not at fault, your rates may still increase, especially if you have a history of claims or driving violations. Additionally, different insurance companies have different rules and thresholds for increasing premiums after a claim.

At-fault vs. no-fault accidents

When an accident occurs, insurance companies try to determine which driver was at fault. This can be a challenging process, and fault can be hard to prove. The determination of fault can affect the amount of the insurance claim payout. In most states, the at-fault party is generally responsible for covering the injuries of the other driver and their passengers, usually through their liability insurance coverage. However, some states are known as "no-fault" states, where medical bills are covered by each driver's individual personal injury protection (PIP) coverage, regardless of who is at fault.

In at-fault states, the at-fault driver's insurance typically covers the other driver's injuries, damaged property, and in some cases, additional damages such as pain and suffering. The process of determining fault can be straightforward if one party admits fault or the situation is clear-cut. However, in more complex cases, a claims adjuster may be involved to investigate the cause of the accident.

On the other hand, in no-fault states, drivers are required to carry personal injury protection (PIP) insurance. PIP coverage pays for medical expenses and, in some cases, lost wages resulting from a car accident, regardless of who was at fault. No-fault insurance can streamline the claims process by eliminating the need for drivers to file claims through each other's insurance. However, one downside of PIP coverage is its cost, as most states that require it have premium rates above the national average. Additionally, no-fault insurance may not cover non-economic damages, such as pain and suffering.

It is important to note that filing an insurance claim, whether in an at-fault or no-fault state, can impact your insurance rates. At-fault claims are very likely to lead to an increase in car insurance rates, as insurance companies consider the driver a higher risk. Even not-at-fault claims can sometimes result in higher rates, as any accident on your record can make you appear riskier to insure. The exact increase in rates will depend on factors such as the severity of the accident, your driving history, and the cost of the claim.

Comprehensive claims

Comprehensive insurance covers property damage from events other than collisions, such as vandalism, car theft, inclement weather, or hitting an animal. It's worth noting that comprehensive auto insurance doesn't cover normal wear and tear, and it provides restricted coverage on maintenance costs.

Surprisingly, insurers can increase your rates following comprehensive claims, although much less than for at-fault accidents. Even other people in your area making comprehensive claims can increase your rates as it implies a greater chance of car theft, vandalism, and more.

The Zebra discovered that a comprehensive claim increases auto insurance premiums for a standard six-month policy by an average of $36. The most affordable insurance companies for drivers who have previously filed a comprehensive claim are USAA, GEICO, and State Farm.

WalletHub reports that, in most cases, filing a claim will cause your auto insurance premiums to rise by an average of 3% to 32% for three to five years. The extent of the rate increase depends on the type and amount of the claim, your insurance company, and the availability of accident forgiveness.

Some car insurance companies may not raise your rates for comprehensive claims below a certain amount, and some may raise your rates minimally.

Factors impacting premiums after claims

There are several factors that determine how much your auto insurance premium will increase after a claim. Firstly, the severity of the accident plays a role. More severe accidents that result in higher costs for repairs or medical bills are likely to lead to a higher increase in your premium compared to minor fender benders. The cost of the claim is a significant factor, where more expensive claims will generally result in higher rate increases.

Secondly, your driving history is taken into account. If you have a history of accidents and violations, you may be considered a ""high-risk driver"" and your insurer is more likely to charge you a higher premium. Conversely, if you have a good driving record and have gone several years without any incidents, your insurer may be more lenient and not raise your rates for a minor accident.

Thirdly, the fault determination is crucial. If you are found to be at fault in an accident, your insurance rates will almost certainly rise, and the higher your percentage of fault, the higher the rate increase. In some states, such as California, your rates can only be increased if you are more than 50% at fault and the accident results in substantial property damage. Being assigned an adjuster who assesses the damage and determines fault can also impact your rates.

Additionally, the state you live in can influence rate increases. For example, no-fault states may see higher premium increases compared to liability (at-fault) states, as each party is responsible for their own medical bills in no-fault states.

It's important to note that even not-at-fault accidents can lead to an increase in your insurance rates, although the increase is typically lower than for at-fault claims. This is because any accident on your record, regardless of fault, can make you appear riskier to insure.

Finally, the number of claims you file can also impact your premium. The more claims you file, the higher your insurance costs are likely to be, and filing too many claims may result in your insurance company refusing to renew your policy.

Discounts and safe driving bonuses

Safe driving bonuses come in several forms. For example, an accident-free discount is given to a policyholder who hasn't been involved in an auto accident. Depending on the auto policy, the policyholder needs to be accident-free for three to five years. A moving violation discount is another example of a safe driving bonus, where being ticket-free may make you eligible for a discount on your insurance rates.

Safe driving discounts can also be incorporated into telematics programs, also known as usage-based insurance (UBI). These programs record and evaluate your habits behind the wheel. If the data shows you've been a responsible motorist, you could see your rate drop by as much as 40%. Some top insurers that offer discounts for safe driving include Allstate, American Family, Farmers, Geico, Nationwide, Progressive, State Farm, Travelers, and USAA.

In addition to safe driving bonuses, there are other ways to get car insurance discounts. For example, accident forgiveness can keep your premiums the same even if you're involved in an auto accident. Defensive driving courses can also help to keep points off your driving record, helping your insurance premiums decrease. Combining auto insurance with homeowners insurance can also result in discounts.

Reporting accidents and claims

The general consensus is that it is always best to report an accident, even if the damage seems minor. If you don't report it, your insurance company might refuse to honour your policy altogether. If anyone else involved in the accident sues you at a later date, not having reported the incident will make it harder for your insurer to gather evidence to represent you.

Your driving record is taken into account when you get your auto policy. The more driving risk you've demonstrated in the past, the more you'll have to pay for your auto insurance premiums. So, if you have a history of accidents and violations, your insurance company may decide not to renew your policy.

If you are involved in an accident, you will need to report this to your insurance company if you want it to pay to have the damage fixed. You may also be required to report the incident if you were hit by another driver. The company will then investigate the incident and either approve or reject your claim. If the claim is approved, the company will issue a payment to cover the cost of the repair.

The number of insurance claims you file will have a direct impact on your rates. The more claims you file, the more your insurance will cost, even if the accidents were not your fault. Filing an at-fault claim is very likely to lead to an increase in your car insurance rates. However, even if you aren't at fault, your rates may still increase.

Frequently asked questions