Insurance Contract Litigation: Exploring The Enforceability Of 'Against Us' Clauses

An insurance contract is a legally binding agreement between an insurance company and an insured party. The contract allows the insured to transfer the risk of a significant financial loss or burden to the insurer in exchange for a small, guaranteed payment known as a premium. The insured must meet all obligations under the policy before bringing a suit in contract.

Insurance contracts are unilateral agreements, meaning only the insurance company makes a legally enforceable promise to pay for covered losses. The insured does not have the right to sue the insurer for enforcement of the policy. However, the insured can request specific riders and exclusions to the policy.

To be enforceable, insurance contracts must contain all the essential elements of a contract, including offer and acceptance, consideration, legal capacity, and legal purpose.

Offer and Acceptance

If the insurer rejects the offer, it may make revisions and send a counter-offer to the applicant, who can then choose to accept the new terms and conditions. In some cases, the insurer may accept an offer without a premium payment, in which case the effective date of the policy would be the date the insurer issued the policy.

It is important to note that insurance contracts are regulated by state law and must comply with specific requirements, including being in legal form and approved by the state insurance department. These contracts are typically unilateral, meaning only the insurer makes a legally enforceable promise to pay for covered losses.

Legal Capacity

In the context of insurance contracts, legal capacity typically requires that neither party is a minor, intoxicated, or suffering from a mental impairment. Minors are generally not considered legally competent to enter into contracts, and their agreements are usually voidable. Similarly, individuals who are intoxicated by drugs or alcohol may not have the capacity to understand the terms and implications of the contract. However, voluntary intoxication is typically not a valid excuse for evading contractual obligations.

In the case of insurance companies, legal capacity is established by their licensing under the prevailing regulations. They are considered competent if they are authorised to sell insurance in a particular state and are operating within the scope of their charter.

To ensure legal capacity, courts may perform cognitive and motivation tests to determine an individual's understanding of the contract and their ability to make informed decisions. These tests assess reasoning, language comprehension, and the presence of delusions or mania.

It is important to note that certain groups, such as minors and those with mental or physical incapacities, are generally considered incapable of entering into contracts. However, each case may be assessed individually, and the court will make a determination based on the specific circumstances.

Legal Purpose

An insurance contract is a legally binding document that outlines the rights and responsibilities of both the insured and the insurance company. It is essential that an insurance contract has a legal purpose to be enforceable by the courts.

The legal purpose of an insurance contract is to protect the insured from financial loss or burden in the event of an insured incident. The contract transfers the risk of significant financial loss from the insured to the insurer. In exchange, the insured pays a small, guaranteed payment called a premium.

For an insurance contract to be valid, it must meet four conditions:

• Offer and acceptance: The insured makes an offer to the insurance company by submitting a proposal form. The insurance company accepts the offer by agreeing to provide insurance.
• Competent parties: Both parties must have the legal capacity to enter into a contract. This means being of sound mind and body, and not under the influence of drugs or alcohol. Minors under the age of eighteen are generally not considered legally competent.
• Legal purpose: The contract must not encourage illegal activities. It must be supported by an insurable interest, which means the insured will experience financial loss if the insured person or item is damaged, lost, or dies.
• Consideration: Both parties must exchange items of value. The insured pays a premium, and the insurer promises a payout in the event of an insurance claim.

Insurance contracts are regulated by state law and must comply with specific requirements. They must be approved by the state insurance department and adhere to all applicable laws. The contract must also cover only legal activities and cannot be used to encourage illegal ventures.

Principle of Indemnity

The principle of indemnity is a fundamental principle of insurance that applies to most policies, except personal accident, life insurance, and other similar policies. This principle states that an insurance contract compensates the insured for any damage, loss, or injury caused only to the extent of the loss incurred. In other words, the insured will be compensated enough to be "made whole" again, or to be restored to the same financial position they were in prior to the loss.

For example, if a person suffers a loss to their home due to a fire and it is estimated that it would cost $50,000 to repair the damage, then that is what they would get from the insurance company, subject to the limits of the insurance selected and other terms and conditions of the insurance policy. The principle of indemnity ensures that the insured does not profit from their claim.

The principle of indemnity is linked to the principle of insurable interest, as the policyholder cannot receive a sum that goes beyond their insurable interest. The principle of indemnity also applies when there are multiple insurance policies covering the same loss. In this case, each insurer would be liable for their respective share of the loss, rather than one insurer being responsible for the entire loss.

The principle of indemnity provides guidance on how claims should be handled. It requires that the insurer investigate claims thoroughly and promptly and that it must act in good faith when dealing with claimants. This includes ensuring that all relevant information is considered when making a decision about the claim and that the claimant is given the opportunity to present their case before a decision is made.

Principle of Subrogation

The principle of subrogation is a fundamental principle of insurance that allows an insurer to pursue legal action against a third party responsible for causing a loss to the insured. This principle is based on the idea of substitution, where the insurer steps into the shoes of the insured and has the same rights and legal standing to seek compensation for losses.

The principle of subrogation comes into play when an insurer has compensated the insured for their loss. At this point, the insured transfers their legal rights to pursue recovery against the third party to the insurer. The insurer then has the authority to initiate legal proceedings against the third party on behalf of the insured. This process is known as subrogation by equitable assignment.

It is important to note that the insurer cannot proceed with subrogation without the consent of the insured. Additionally, the insurer must fully indemnify the insured before initiating subrogation. However, some insurance companies may allow the insurer to commence subrogation in the name of the insured, even if the negotiation over compensation is not finalised.

The principle of subrogation ensures that the insured does not profit from the insurance claim and that the damages are compensated equitably. It also protects the insurer from suffering losses due to the negligence or mistake of the third party.

There are three types of subrogation:

• Subrogation by equitable assignment: This type of subrogation is based on the insurance policy and the receipt issued by the insured, acknowledging that the claim has been paid in full.
• Subrogation by contract: This type of subrogation is evidenced by an instrument, such as a letter of subrogation, to avoid any disputes regarding the right to claim reimbursement or settling the priority of inter-se claims.
• Subrogation cum contract: In this type of subrogation, the insured executes a letter of subrogation cum assignment, enabling the insurer to sue the third party in the name of the insured or the insurer itself.

Frequently asked questions